LIBRARY ^CONGRESS. 






UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.! 



NOTICES OF THE PRESS, 



(From the Chicago MedicalJournal, Oct., 1866.) 

4 'We have read this monograph with much pleasure. An 
agreeable style does wonders for a dull subject. For the first 
time we have been interested by the chapter which forms the 
dreary introduction to all other books on cholera — the chapter 
which is devoted to the history of the origin of the disease. 
Thanks to Dr. Peters, we have waded through the filth of Big- 
ginugar, Kamieseveram, of Jessore, Mysore, Conjeiveram, and 
the feast of Kuibar Bariam without losing all stomach for the 
remainder of the book. This we consider a victory of no small 
importance to the author. The chapter on the course and dis- 
tribution of cholera presents an array of facts and arguments in 
proof of the portability and communicability of the germs of 
cholera which may be considered as decisive. It will be difficult 
for any one hereafter to entertain the miasmatic or atmospheric 
wave theory of the causation of the disease. It appears certain 
that the victim of cholera throws off, probably through the me- 
dium of the intestinal dejections, innumerable germs which are 
transported in a manner analogous to the distribution of the 
seeds of plants. The causes which favor the germination and 
reproduction of the one class of germs, are strictly analogous to 
those favorable to the growth of the other. The experience of our 
own community during the 'present, visitation of cholera, fully illus- 
trates this proposition. Warmth, moisture, filth, and physical 

a 



11 NOTICES OF THE PRESS. 

predisposition afford the soil upon which cholera flourishes and 
spreads. When these elements are withdrawn the prevalence of 
the disease is reduced to a minimum, and it becomes extinct, 
precisely as the seed of the sower springs not up when cast upon 
the dry and stony rock. 

"The section on treatment is little more than a catalogue of 
the various remedies which have been used by all classes of doc- 
tors — homoeopathic included. Having enjoyed peculiar advan- 
tages for the observation of every variety of treatment — the 
homoeopathic included — the author is enabled to speak with 
authority. Dr. Peters gives the preference to iron-alum, and 
sulphate of iron. The book is beautifully printed on tinted pa- 
per, and forms a work which does credit to all who have been 
concerned in its production." 



(From the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal, Nov. 8, 1866.) 

"Cholera is discussed in this the last, and perhaps the best, of 
the many volumes published this year upon this subject, 

"The reader will find this volume very interesting throughout, 
and the chapter on treatment is particularly instructive" 



"The opinions which Dr. Peters adopts are not different from 
those maintained by many experienced physicians of the times ; 
but it is safe to say that no book which has been published in 
this country, and so far as we know in Europe, contains either 
so complete a history of cholera, or so thorough an analysis of 
its manifestations in all parts of the world. To professional men 
it cannot but be of the highest value ; while to the general pub- 
lic a careful reading of a sensible work like this must be benefi- 



NOTICES OF THE PRESS. Ill 

cial. It is a small volume and should be widely circulated." — 
Boston Journal. 



"We suppose that we are warranted in congratulating the pub- 
lic on its escape from cholera — for the present. But it is a long- 
lived, a persevering, and a pertinacious scourge. It may have 
spared us only for a season — or for this season. Another year 
may find it less favorably disposed toward us, for it is as capri- 
cious as it is persistent in its course and operations ; and there- 
fore it behooves us to obtain as much and as accurate knowledge 
of it as we can acquire. Dr. Peters's treatise is the best which 
has fallen under our notice. In a comparatively small compass 
he has massed all the facts that bear upon the nature, origin, 
progress, and history of the disease. How much has been done, 
and how it has been done, and what should be done to reduce 
cholera to a tame disease, can be learnt from the calm but strong 
pages of this treatise, which has quite exhausted the subject. A 
more invigorating book it would not be possible to name, for its 
arguments and statements remove fear by the process of actual 
demonstration ; and fear is cholera's chief feeder. Dr. Peters's 
treatise deserves the most extensive circulation, and means 
should be taken to make it universally known," — Boston Post 



(From the St. Louis Medical and Surgical Journal, September and 
October, 1866.) 

"Dr. Peters's work is one of the best on our list, for its mate- 
rial has been collected with diligence and care. Much space is 
devoted to the oiigin and mode of distribution ; while the theory 
of its portability by persons, ships, clothing, and baggage, and 



IV NOTICES OF THE PRESS. 

by water, dust, etc., is fully carried out. The chapter on the pre- 
vention of cholera, and that on the management of patients and nurses, 
are the most commendable ; they are very correct and efficient in 
our opinion. The materia medica of cholera is very complete, 
and therefore very useful to any one desirous of studying the re- 
sources of the physician against this dire disease. The length 
of our notice bears testimony that we have not found it void of 
worth and useful information. 

"It remains to pay our tribute to the publisher, who has left 
us nothing to criticise in the appearance of the book. Its 
clear type and general neatness make us express a warm desire 
to see Mr. Van Nostrand engage more extensively in medical 
publication." 



"Dr. Peters, as is usual with him, claims but little more than 
the credit of a compiler, which we think is much less than his 
due, for we have met with more original matter in his book than 
in many works of greater pretension. We agree with the reviewer 
of a former work of Dr. Peters, that if the value of a work 
may be in some sort predicated by the modesty of an author who 
would make no claim for himself, nor challenge our profound re- 
gard by a flourish of trumpets — and it is not often a bad index — 
we are in duty bound to award him the full benefit of that short 
but admirable commendation of Horace: 

" * Non fumum exfulgere, sed ex fumo dare lucem. ' 

"This man gives us not smoke from flames, but from smoke 
produces splendor ! The internal evidence of the work proves it 
to be valuable to the oldest and most experienced physician. 
Indeed, it is a most valuable compendium of practical informa- 
tion selected from the very best authorities. Such a compila- 



NOTICES OF THE PRESS. V 

tion affords the best evidence that its author possesses much 
more than a theoretical acquaintance with his subject. It is the 
work of a practical man who understands what practical men 
require." 



"Dr. Peters discusses the origin, nature, prevention, and 
treatment of cholera in a thorough and systematic manner. He 
establishes many facts in reference to the cause of the disease 
and the means by which it is transported and communicated. In 
his plan of treatment he is decided, although he recites many 
other and varied methods of treatment, and endeavors to esti- 
mate them at their true value. The book is an interesting 
one, and will be of much use to the general public by the infor- 
mation which it contains as to the means of guarding against 
cholera." 



(From the New York Journal of Medicine, Nov., 1866.) 

Dr. Peters's treatise is an exquisite specimen of type, paper, 
and binding. It is an unpretending little volume, condensing 
within moderate limits and in a very readable way the current 
cholera literature, and those who have neither time nor inclination 
to consult the originals will find in this work a very reliable 
digest. The views of the author with regard to the propagation 
of cholera are substantially endorsed in the report of the Cholera 
Commission at its recent session at Constantinople. The influ- 
ence of clothing and articles in common use in the transmission 
of cholera is strongly stated by the author, though here again he 
is backed by the Commission. We agree with Dr. Peters in at- 
taching much importance to the infection of drinking water by 
the choleraic evacuations as at least a precipitating cause. The 



VI NOTICES OF THE PRESS. 

work is excellent in its way and creditable to all concerned in 
its production . 

" "We are particularly impressed with the catholicity and candor 
of this, the more noteworthy as not being common in medical 
literature. Dr. Peters's physiological theory seems more sound 
than any that has yet been brought forward. " 



"We have read this book with very great pleasure. As one 
reads on, its interest and power takes away all thought of words 
except as a vehicle of thought, and produces an absorbing inter- 
est which is rarely felt, especially in a medical book. It and 
Baker's work on the Nile have been the most striking recent in- 
stances of the power of mind — intent upon one object, and itself 
seeing that clearly — to infuse the same spirit into the reader." 



1 ' This volume bears witness to faithful and careful observation 
on the part of its author. Industry, accuracy, and an almost 
marvellous prevision of the nature and course of this dire dis- 
ease, are evidenced in every part of it. His statements of the 
possible prevention of the disease as an epidemic by hygienic 
and sanitary municipal regulations have been happily verified by 
this season's experience in New York, as contrasted with the far 
greater mortality from cholera in smaller cities in the central 
portion of the country, especially Cincinnati, Chicago, St. Louis, 
Nashville, etc., to which it was doubtless conveyed from New 
York." 



NOTES 



ORIGIN, NATURE, PREVENTION, AND TREATMENT 



OP 



ASIATIC CHOLERA. 



By JOHN C; PETERS, M. D. 





SECOND EDITION, WITH AN APPENDIX. 








gkb fork: 


D. 


VAN NOSTRAND, 192 BROADWAY. 




1861 
• 



\o 



<v<( 






Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year of our Lord, 1867, by 

D. VAN NOSTRAND, 

in the Clerk's office of the District Court of the United States, for the Southern 
District of New York. 



LC Control Number 




tmp96 028688 



PREFACE. 



I have been present as a practising physician in New 
York during the whole of the epidemics of 1849, '54, and '66 ; 
and have as distinct a recollection of that of 1832 as a boy 
thirteen years of age, at the time, could have. 

I have seen no more of true Asiatic cholera, outside 
of hospitals, than usually falls to the lot one whose resi- 
dence and practice are in the cleanest portions of this city. 
But I have visited cholera hospitals in 1849, '54, and '66, 
and have witnessed every variety of treatment, including 
the homoeopathic, both of the high and low dilution, of the 
strict and liberal kind. The lowest average loss in asylums, 
like the Protestant Half-Orphan, of this city, and in homoeo- 
pathic hospitals for the reception of the better classes of 
the poor, like that of the Sisters of Charity in Vienna, is 
from twenty-five to thirty-five per cent. In hospitals where 
the poorer and most depressed classes, and the almost 
dead and dying, are received, as well as those in the more 
or less advanced stages of the disease, as in Tessier's ho- 
moeopathic wards in the Hospital St. Marguerite, in Paris, 
and in those of Charges, at Marseilles, the mortality varies 
from fifty to seventy per cent. These estimates apply ex- 



4 PREFACE. 

clusively to cases of true Asiatic cholera, and do not in- 
clude any of cholera morbus, bilious or septic cholera, 
or that great majority of diarrhoeas which are misnamed 
cholerine. The examples of actual Asiatic cholera among 
the middle and better classes are so few, and the slighter 
similarities are so numerous, that they can hardly be 
taken into account. Yet all these are counted in , " in 
cholera times," by almost all irregular practitioners, like 
the eclectics, hydropathists, &c. 

No indulgence is asked for any statements or argu- 
ments which have been advanced, but I do request a 
kindly criticism of the literary portion of this treatise ; 
for the greater portion of it has been written before 8 
a. m. and after 10 p. m. There has been no leisure time 
to revise the first rough notes, and three fourths of the 
materials collected have been necessarily omitted. 

There has been neither opportunity nor inclination to 
hurry the completion of this little treatise, in order to 
profit by the excitement of the times ; but its necessary delay 
has favored a careful watch over the present epidemic, 
and it is confidently supposed that no facts decidedly in 
opposition to those on which it is based have been de- 
veloped this season. 

The opinions which are here advocated and adopted, are 
those maintained by the most experienced and scientific 
physicians of the times : 

1st. That Asiatic cholera is both portable and commu- 
nicable. 



PREFACE. 5 

2d. It is generally carried about by persons, ships, cloth- 
ing, and baggage. 

3d. It never affects the entire atmosphere of any one conn- 
try, district, town, or village, and rarely that of the whole 
of one hospital, ship, or house ; but only those parts of 
them into which it is directly imported. 

4th. That the quality of infectiousness belongs peculiar- 
ly, if not exclusively, to the matters which the cholera 
patient discharges by vomiting and purging. 

5th. That cholera discharges, if cast away without previ- 
ous disinfection, impart their own infective quality to the 
excremental matters, or any more innocent filth with which 
they mingle in drains or cesspools, and wherever else they 
flow or soak, and to the gases and effluvia which these 
substances evolve ; thus poisoning the air and subsoil 
water. 

6th. That no amount of filth, imprudence, or diarrhceal 
disease, without the addition of this peculiar cause, will 
give rise to true Asiatic cholera in temperate climates. 

7th. That if the cholera poison, by leakage or soakage 
from drains or cesspools, or otherwise, gets access, even in 
small quantity, to wells or other sources of drinking water, 
it will infect, in the most dangerous manner, very large 
volumes of this fluid. 

8th. That the cholera poison affects, with equal virulence, 
everything in the nature of bedding, clothing, towels, and 
the like, so that the soiled linen of a single house in 



b PREFACE. 

which there is a cholera patient may spread the disease 
over a whole district. 

9th. That there is scarcely any limit to the extent to 
which even a single case of cholera or cholerine may 
infect a whole neighborhood. 

10th. The counteracting and remedial agencies are simple 
and efficient. Whenever the disease has manifested itself, 
even in its slightest form, thorough disinfection must be en- 
forced. With this single precaution no epidemic gives less 
excuse for any unmanly or excessive fear, since none seems 
to involve less of danger to those around. 

11th. As cholera only affects the air of certain localities, 
there is not the slightest necessity for any of those general 
departures from the ordinary mode of life and diet which 
were formerly recommended. The golden rule is to live 
temperately, naturally, and well. 

12th. Finally, no case of diarrhoea, cholera morbus, or 
dysentery, can be converted into cholera unless the patient 
has also been exposed to the peculiar infection of this dis- 
ease. 

In conclusion I put in no claim for great originality 
in any portion of this work, except for the development 
of the Physiological Theory, and the advocacy of the in- 
ternal disinfectant and corrective treatment. 



SECOND PREFACE. 



It is a source of great gratification to me that every 
chapter of the first issue has been selected by some 
different reviewer for special commendation ; and it is 
hoped that all essential deficiencies are now supplied in 
the Appendix. 

The true nature of the cholera poison has, in all like- 
lihood, been discovered during the past year. (See 
page 163.) 

The prevention of cholera is already so well understood, 
that the disease must, sooner or later, become extinct ; 
and it is not improbable that Europe and America have 
already experienced its last epidemic visitation. (See 
page 179.) 

The distribution of cholera by drinking water, and 
the conveyance of the disease around the world by 
means of ships, persons, and clothing, may be considered 
positively proven. (See pages 168 and 171.) 

In the first issue all other pathological appearances 
were intentionally omitted, except those of the intestinal 



8* SECOND PREFACE. 

villi and glands, for the express purpose of directing 
special attention to them. (See pages 83, 84, and 183.) 

As the object of the prescriptions given on pages 111 
to 119 was to meet, not only cholera, but most of the 
allied diseases which occur in the Summer season and 
in cholera times, they will not be found too numerous, 
nor the selection difficult for any one who has a passable 
knowledge of these diseases and their remedies. 

The opinions of Drs. Budd, Petenkofer, Niemeyer and 
others, given on pages 5 and 6, which it seems were 
formularized by Dr. Simon, require no alteration, 

I have received much assistance in the composition of 
this work from Dr. F. G. Snelling, of New York, to whom 
my best thanks are due. 



ASIATIC CHOLERA, 



1. ORIGIN. 

Ordinary country, or Indian cholera, has been endemic in 
the delta or marsh region of the Ganges for centuries. But 
formerly it was a disorder peculiar to the natives, mainly in- 
duced by their mean habitations, filthy habits, and poor food ; 
and so rare among the better fed, clothed, and housed foreign 
residents, that neither of the physicians who had been con- 
nected, one for five and the other for ten years, with the 
General Hospital of the Bengal Presidency for Europeans, 
had seen a single case of the disorder previously to the out- 
break of the great epidemic of 1817. At Jessore, in 1817, 
it underwent certain unknown changes, so as to become in 
many respects a new disease ; it then, for the first time, 
became epidemic and pestilential, portable and doubtless 
contagious ; and also first broke loose from its usual con- 
fines, and commenced that fearful march of seventeen years' 
duration, which did not cease until it had encircled the 
globe. The great peculiarity of that dread march was that, 
although it reached China to the eastward, it did not, and 
has never since crossed the Pacific ocean ; its westward 
course was slow and interrupted, but upon the whole con- 
tinuous, so that it reached Moscow, Hamburg, England, and 
America, in about fifteen years. The second epidemic 



8 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

required five or six years to traverse the same space, and 
that of 1865, only six months. This difference of speed 
in the progression of the various epidemics is most easily 
explained by the increased facilities and rate of travel 
which have followed the extension of steamboat and rail- 
road enterprises. After 1817, the disease was called epidemic 
or Asiatic cholera, although twice previously to this date, it 
had prevailed to such an extent in the town of Jessore and 
its immediate neighborhood, as to render it necessary to shut 
the courts of justice, and suspend all business for a time. 

Dr. Barnes, resident at Jessore for many years, had medical 
charge of the district, from 1810 till 1823 ; he had been fa- 
miliar with the ordinary Indian cholera, during all that time, 
and considered it a disease peculiar to that section of the 
country, and one which had superseded the peinodical remittent 
fever, formerly so prevalent in that district. He says, the 
sources of this disease could not be mistaken, although they 
were too extensive to be brought under human control. 
Putrid exhalations from the constant and rapid decomposition 
of animal and vegetable matter, and the use of unwholesome 
water, were the sole causes. 

But the extent and fatality of its attack depended alto- 
gether upon the season, or seasons ; for there were two in 
which cholera was apt to prevail : 

1st. If those violent storms of thunder, lightning, wind, and 
rain, which annually occur in Bengal, and are known by the 
name of northwesters, commenced early in March, and re- 
curred at short intervals, until the rainy season began, then 
the hot season as it is called, viz., April, May, and June, was 
comparatively healthy, and vice versa. It is during this first 
period that the disease is apt to spread to other countries ; 



ORIGIN. 9 

for it gathers strength during the hot season, and is carried 
on by travellers and pilgrims. 

2d. If the annual rains did not terminate till the end of 
September, and the floods subsided gradually during the 
month of October, the autumn season would be free from 
sickness ; but, if the rains ceased at the end of August, and 
the waters sank rapidly during September, then the pesti- 
lence commenced at the beginning of October and raged till 
the middle of December, when it soon became apparently 
extinct. The weather, in 1816 and 1817, rendered the 
atmosphere peculiarly favorable for the development of 
cholera, its extension beyond its usual limits, and even for 
its generation throughout those parts of Bengal, where the 
materials necessary for its production existed in a less 
extensive degree than at Jessore. Instead of the usual 
rainy and dry seasons, there was scarcely a week during 
the whole twelve months from January to December, 1816, 
without rain. The sun was constantly obscured ; the atmo- 
sphere close, heavy and moist ; while the thermometer never 
ranged below seventy to seventy-five degrees from March to 
November. "In such a climate as this," says Barnes, "any 
person acquainted with the materials that accumulate in In- 
dian towns and villages, and with the crowded, filthy, and 
ill-ventilated state of the houses and streets must be satis- 
fied that these, of all others, are the conditions most favor- 
able for contagion. The huts of the natives are nearly 
surrounded with pits, the earth from which is used to 
raise mounds on which their habitations are erected. These 
trenches are the receptacles for every kind of nastiness, 
as well as stagnant water, and the exhalations from them 
are at times almost insufferable." From July to October 

2 



10 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

the atmosphere of Bengal usually resembles that of a filthy 
vapor-bath, producing a sensation of indescribable fatigue 
and oppression, and an exhausting perspiration. 

Jessore is a thickly-populated town, one hundred miles 
northeast of Calcutta, on a flat, reedy bank of the Gan- 
ges, but slightly elevated above the sea level ; during the 
rainy season the neighborhood of the place is changed into 
a fetid swamp, covered with rank vegetation. By the side of 
this sluggish water, stood the bazaar and long rows of low, 
mean huts, surrounded by trees, which afforded shade, but pre- 
vented the rapid escape of moisture. The river was the recep- 
tacle for excrementitious matter, and the remains of partly 
burned corpses were also thrown into it, in accordance with 
religious superstition ; and this filthy water was often used 
for drinking. In addition to these extremely insalubrious 
conditions, the first rice harvest turned out badly, for there 
are two rice crops in India yearly ; the first occurs in 
August, and is always more or less unwholesome, like 
very fresh hay ; sometimes it even produces a fatal dis- 
ease, morbus oryzaeus, marked by vomiting and diarrhoea. 
It is also asserted that an unusual quantity of spoiled 
fish was eaten that year, the season being very unfavor- 
able for its proper curing. Most violent attacks of vom- 
iting, purging, and cramps, simulating cholera, have some- 
times been traced in India to eating bad shell-fish. 

Some of these exciting causes of cholera prevail over 
other portions of Bengal, besides in the neighborhood of 
Jessore. 1st. During the rainy season, viz., from June to 
October, from fifty to eighty inches of water falls, and 
the surface of the Ganges rises until the lower part of 
Bengal is inundated for a breadth of one hundred miles ; 



ORIGIN. 11 

the river itself becomes two miles wide during the wet 
season, while it is only half that width during the dry 
time. Still, the same happens with the Nile, without sim- 
ilar pestilential consequences. 2d. On the great plains 
where lie the principal cities, and where the bulk of the 
natives dwell, the heat, during the greater part of the 
year is excessive ; the thermometer often ranging from 
one hundred to one hundred and ten degrees. 3d. The 
population of Hindostan is very great, amounting to one 
hundred and seventy-two millions, nearly ten years ago ; 
and it has at least thirty cities with over one hundred 
thousand inhabitants. 4th. In India, the religious preju- 
dices of the people not only prevent them from using 
the cattle-droppings as manure, but they consider them holy 
and preserve them for religious purposes. There is especially 
the utmost recklessness as to the disposal of all descrip- 
tions of offal, and more particularly of the dejections from 
the human intestine. Montgomery says : " The people are 
naturally devoid of habits of cleanliness, and almost of 
decency ; if allowed, they will not only resort to the public 
thoroughfares for the purposes of nature, but will construct 
cloacae under the rooms in which they live, cook, and sleep." 
In short, the filth of the native villages requires to be seen to 
be believed in ; and the streets of all the cities are narrow, 
dirty, and ill-paved. 5th. The rivers and streams are made 
the common sewers and cemeteries of the towns, while the 
great reservoirs or tanks of water, which are the chief public 
works in Hindostan of native construction, supply a more or 
less stagnant fluid, which is largely defiled by the careless 
habits of the people. 6th. The frequent accumulation of hun- 
dreds of thousands of persons together during their great 



12 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

religions pilgrimages and public fairs, with all the attendant 
filth, misery, fatigue, exposure, and bad food. 7th. Every 
camping-ground, or place of night's-rest of the pilgrims, not 
only becomes saturated with filth, but remains for days, weeks, 
or months, a depot of " cholera-dirt" for those who subsequently 
linger on those contaminated places, or pass very near them. 
8th. The people eat very little meat, and subsist mainly on 
rice. 

Almost all these causes prevail in China, except the care- 
lessness about human ordure, and the frequent aggregation of 
immense multitudes of unclean men, such as occur in the 
pilgrimages and fairs, which are almost peculiar to the Hin- 
dostanee and Mohammedan races ; yet cholera does not origi- 
nate in China, as far as has yet been ascertained. China has 
a population of over four hundred millions, and hence is 
more overcrowded than Bengal; it has cities with millions 
of inhabitants, instead of a few hundred thousands as in 
Hindostan ; but all refuse appKcable to the purpose of manur- 
ing the soil is carefully collected and delivered to the farmers, 
viz., human ordure, ashes, muck, gypsum, offal, hair, even 
human hair clipped by the barbers, is saved with all other 
matters which can invigorate the ground. Personal cleanli- 
ness is not among the virtues of the Chinese any more than 
among the Hindoos ; they do not change their under-clothes 
till they are worn out ; their houses are poorly ventilated 
and lighted ; many of their streets are crooked and narrow* 
few of them exceeding ten or twelve feet in width, while 
most of those in the city of Canton are less then eight ; but 
although offal and manure are not allowed to decompose in 
the street, there is a constant stench perceptible arising from 
the continual passage of the loaded scavenger's carts through 



ORIGIN. 13 

the city. Still, we repeat, in spite of ail this, cholera does not 
originate in China, where religious pilgrimages are also not so 
frequent, nor of such gigantic proportions as in India. 

We will now turn our attention to the effect of pilgrim- 
ages in the production of cholera in India. 

As early as 1858, Dr. Nardoo, of the Madras medical estab- 
lishment, drew attention to the causes which give rise to 
cholera among the pilgrims to Juggernaut. He states that 
the food of the devotees is prepared exclusively by the 
priests, in the temples ; this stuff is acrid, oily, and often 
putrid ; and the drink sour. The pilgrims arrive at their 
tabernacles after undergoing every fatigue on their toilsome 
marches, half starved, and much exhausted, and are con- 
ducted to small and badly-ventilated rooms for the accommo- 
dation of twenty to thirty persons each ; they wash them- 
selves in foul pools or tanks, and visit the image with their 
wet clothes still upon them ; eat a variety of bad food with 
eagerness, taking no notice of its condition, taste, or quality, 
under a deeply-impressed idea that such observation would be 
an act of blasphemy ; drink a jumbo full of very sour, rancid 
tyre and feel themselves refreshed and very much satisfied, 
for the first twenty-four hours. But on the second or third 
day the causes of diarrhoea and cholera, viz., sudden transition 
from heat to cold, aliment of indigestible character, acrid, 
oily and putrid food, acid drinks, and want of free ventilation 
and drainage, soon begin their operation. 

The streets and houses quickly become impregnated with 
noxious exhalations emanating from the decomposition of the 
excrementitious and urinous deposits with which the streets 
and alleys, fields, and plains, are loaded during the assemblage 
of people in such great numbers, as well as from the dead 



14 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

bodies thrown out in the fields and towns without sepulchre. 
Diarrhoea and cholera having thus originated, great alarm and 
despair are produced among the pilgrims ; fright and despon- 
dency on the one hand, and their longings for home, rela- 
tions, and friends, on the other, act conjointly as depressing 
agents, rendering their systems more favorable to the action 
of disease. Dr. Nardoo says the ravages made by this dis- 
order are annually very lamentable ; and that it is most pitiable 
to observe the dreadful scenes at Juggernaut, resulting from 
deaths in such vast numbers. 

Stewart Clarke says a fresh outbreak of cholera takes place 
at the great fair at Hurdwar, nearly every year. 

Dr. Montgomery, of Madras, has given a most careful and 
graphic account of the habits of pilgrims, and the origin of 
cholera among them. He says : '"The Eastern pilgrims 
travel, either on foot, walking incredible distances under a 
burning sun, or closely packed in stifling carts, which are 
crammed to suffocation by human beings, and from which 
every breath of air is carefully excluded. Thus, they strug- 
gle along indifferent roads, or no roads at all, slowly dragged 
by miserable, half-starved, over-worked bullocks. Their food, 
indifferent in quality at the best, is cooked under the shade 
of a tree, or beneath the cart in which they travel; and 
they drink pernicious arrack, or fermenting toddy, or offen- 
sive tank or well water, which is scarcely less pernicious. At 
night they sleep in the foul conveyances in which they 
have travelled, or lie exposed on the ground, chilled by dews 
or damp, and subject to the influence of the cold land wind. 
If they stop at a native town, they crowd into the over- 
filled bazaars, and sleep, perhaps, in some filthy choutry (or 
travellers' rest-house), seldom little more than a shed en- 



ORIGIN. 15 

closed on two or three sides ; and there they lie packed as 
close as may be, with the thermometer at seventy or eighty 
degrees at the lowest. 

" Can it be wondered at that they are unhealthy ? Is it sur- 
prising, if, on reaching the goal they seek, when they mingle 
with others influenced by similar injurious surroundings, and 
meet in a densely-crowded native town without sanitary pre- 
cautions, and drink water defiled by cattle, the washings of 
carts and filthy clothing, and the bathing of crowds of foul 
human beings, they fall victims to disease ? The wonder is 
that any should escape. 

" Situated at a distance of forty-five miles from Madras 
is a native town called Conjeiveram. It is large, pretty, and 
regularly built ; the streets are very broad, and planted 
with cocoa-nut trees ; and a beautiful stream runs along its 
western side. The soil is very fertile ; the river and sur- 
rounding tanks are favorable for irrigation and cultivation ; 
the inhabitants are chiefly ryots (cultivators of the soil) 
and weavers ; and many Brahmins reside there. The large 
pagoda or temple at Conjeiveram is greatly famed in heathen 
mythology, and is one of the great strongholds of Hindooism 
in Southern India. The city therefore appears to be favorably 
circumstanced for the maintenance of public health. Many 
of the inhabitants, and especially those attached to the 
temples, and also the leading cloth merchants of the place, 
are wealthy. It occupies a somewhat secluded position, and 
the mode of construction of the town, with its broad streets 
for the passage of large processions along its leading 
thoroughfares, is favorable to ventilation. The occupations 
of the people are healthful, much of the weaving being 
carried on out of doors ; and the general health of the 



16 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

natives is satisfactory. The festival is comparatively of short 
duration (about ten days), and held in the month of May, 
which is not unhealthy in that part of India. Yet, with all 
these advantages, the annual feast at Conjeiveram is almost 
regularly the means of introducing pestilence into Madras. 
Scarcely a year up to 1863 passed without an outburst of 
cholera, during or immediately subsequent to the festival ; 
and its appearance in Madras, a few days afterwards, has 
been directly traced in many instances to the visitors re- 
turned from Conjeiveram. A better-marked example of the 
deadly effect of these festivals could scarcely be found. For 
here we have a town naturally tolerably salubrious, with a 
population independent and healthfully employed, and yet 
find that cholera appears with the aggregation ■ of strangers, 
even though the majority of them have come comparatively 
short distances, and their stay is limited. 

u Up to the festival of 1863 no provision of any kind 
of an hygienic nature had been made. No latrines or 
places of public convenience were erected, and an indiscrimi- 
nate collection of men, women, children, bullocks, horses, 
and cattle, of all kinds, crowded and defiled the public 
streets, and polluted the water. Pigs, the natural scav- 
engers of an Indian town, devoured the foul and decom- 
posing excreta, festering under a tropical sun, and were 
subsequently slaughtered to supply pork for Madras. Mad 
revelry by day and night, when the tumult rendered 
sleeping a matter of difficulty even to a native, excited 
to a preternatural degree the religious zeal of the Hin- 
doo ; while excess and debauchery prostrated his ener- 
gies and made him an easy prey to disease. The efflu- 
vium arising from decomposing excreta polluted the air, 



ORIGIN. 1*7 

and in this foul atmosphere the inhabitants of the town 
had to live, with an addition of two hundred thousand 
strangers. The carts in which the pilgrims came to the 
feast became saturated with the poisonous atmosphere. 
The clothing of the poorer saints, tainted by prolonged 
wear, and the various contaminations likely to arise during 
an orgie of days, rendered each of the miserable dev- 
otees, upon his return to Madras, the possible nidus of future 
disease. Exhausted, weary of excitement, with all the sus- 
taining hope of religious zeal to support them gone, they 
hastened back to the presidency town, itself notorious for in- 
sufficient cleanliness, thus perilling the lives of all. 

" In connection with the foregoing facts regarding the con- 
dition of a town, when the scene of a religious festival, we 
will next turn to the consideration of the effects left behind 
by bands of pilgrims traversing the land. Some of these 
come from the provinces of Upper and Central India, collect- 
ing from distant stations in bands more or less numerous, but 
sometimes amounting to thousands. Many of these, poor, ill- 
fed, and diseased, start on their tedious journey of some fifteen 
hundred to two thousand miles. The miserable caravan slowly 
wends its way, which, for obvious reasons, is that of the grand 
trunk roads of Southern India. Visiting the sacred shrines of 
Trichinopoly, weary and exhausted, they still pass on, till at 
length their courage is revived by the longed-for sight of the 
sacred island of Ramieseweram ; for visits to this island, and 
bathing in the sacred waters, where the two seas mingle, are 
supposed to free from sin and give a passport to immortality. 
This belief explains the strong motive that impels all these 
pilgrims, who, so long as their religion lasts, will continue to 
flock to Ramieseweram, and to be a constant source of disease, 

2* 



18 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

if stringent measures are not adopted to check the evils they 
give rise to. Ten years ago the population of the island 
was under five thousand, but no less than one hundred and 
thirty thousand annually arrived there to worship. To this 
a large addition must be made for those who failed to reach 
the goal ; the hearts of many fail them, the money of others 
fall short ; frequently death has checked them, for thousands 
of graves, unseen because unmarked, exist on these trunk 
roads of the pilgrims. 

" But, perilous as is the journey thither, the return is even 
more fraught with danger. When their ceremonies have 
been performed, and when the strong feelings of religious 
enthusiasm have been gratified, they yoke their travel-worn 
cattle, and set their faces homeward. No longer upborne 
by excitement, the object of their lives fully attained, wearied, 
poor, and with no hope to cheer them on their way, they start 
on their return journey unresisting victims to the first mor- 
bific influence which assails them. On the home-stretch all 
the dangers of the outward route are encountered in an ex- 
aggerated form; they return to the filthy camping grounds 
before defiled by themselves ; they listlessly occupy the 
same infected vehicles which brought them ; they are de- 
pressed by the dread that spoliation of their property has 
occurred during their absence, and they are in a strange 
country, speaking an almost unknown tongue. Forced 
marches knock up both man and beast ; and footsore, down- 
hearted, and ill-fed, they fall an easy, unresisting prey to epi- 
demic disease. 

" Another prolific source of cholera is the great fair of 
Bigginuggar, which annually collects thousands of native 
traders, and, like that of Hurdwar at the issue of the Ganges 



ORIGIN. 19 

from the Himalayas, is equally with Conjeiveram and Ramiese- 
weram, a source of annual danger. From these centres, cholera 
almost always accompanies the homeward-bound pilgrims or 
traders, and the gradual dispersion of the travellers is the im- 
mediate means of distributing and propagating the disease, if 
it has seized them. The villages on their route are visited, and 
as free intercourse with the villagers and frequent access to 
the crowded and unhealthy bazaars are inevitable and cannot 
be controlled, great diffusion of cholera results. The public 
roads and thoroughfares become saturated with elements of 
disease, and dangerous to troops or private travellers who are 
exposed to their emanations. We have but to recollect the 
numberless instances of ch61era imported into moving cam]: s 
or attacking private individuals to recognize the facility with 
which passers-by are often found to succumb under this con- 
tagion. Supplies have to be obtained from villages already 
infected by the pilgrims, and even the slight amount of inter- 
course thus arising may implicate the safety of a whole com- 
mand. But, in addition to this explanation of seizures of 
cholera among soldiers, and independent of the predisposing 
causes which travelling itself originates, it is no fancied con- 
clusion to infer that if troops pass near or even rest for a short 
time upon tainted camping grounds, they become the victims 
of disease. Of this latter point a sad proof was given within 
the limits of the Madras presidency, at least as affecting 
some of its army, for, on the breaking up of the Sangar divis- 
ion in 1860, many of the regiments, returning to their own 
stations, crossed the route of the pilgrims who had gone to 
and returned from Ramieseweram, and in numerous instances 
they were attacked with cholera. This was no rare coinci- 
dence, but occurred with such frequency and precision 



20 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

that it must be deemed a natural effect of an undoubted 
cause. In 1859, Inspector-General Macpherson records, 
that a detachment of the 74th Highlanders were attacked 
with cholera from passing within one hundred yards of 
the camp of the 35th regiment when it was suffering 
under an epidemic of that disease. The same regiment was 
subsequently brought down to Madras to embark for 
England in 1864, and being most improperly encamped 
on ground denied by previous occupation, for weeks, of 
the 76th foot, was attacked with cholera, and a great num- 
ber of deaths ensued. In this case, the first occupants 
of the ground had not suffered from the disease ; and in 
all these instances the troops were in high health ; those 
from Central India had passed through a glorious cam- 
paign ; they had won a large amount of booty, and were 
under the professional charge of medical officers of great ex- 
perience, thoroughly competent to adopt any possible means 
to guard the lives and health of the men in their charge. 
Yet, they fell victims to the foul atmosphere and soil of 
camping-grounds tainted by previous occupation. The case 
of the 74th at Madras is another proof of the innate 
power of infected regiments to generate epidemic disease, 
for cholera was brought from the camp (six miles off) into 
Madras, soon took root and spread rapidly in a densely- 
populated portion of the city, remarkable for its want of 
ventilation and cleanliness. Analogous to the experience of 
the detachment of the 74th Highlanders (quoted above) who 
contracted cholera near Bellary from an affected camp by 
which it passed but did not halt, was that of a wing of 
the 43d regiment of Europeans, who passed through a vil- 
lage near Palmanair — one of a number of small native vil- 



ORIGIN. 21 

lages, skirting the frontier border of the Mysore table-land, 
and some two thousand feet above the level of the sea — it 
was seized with cholera, and the men brought into Madras 
dying by scores, some of their dead bodies lying among the 
living, for miles of their dreadful railway journey. If it 
were necessary to multiply proofs of the ill effects of native 
encampments and of native habits of travelling, they could 
easily be given. 

" The native cities may be regarded as permanent filthy 
encampments. Madras abounds in cart-stands, where native 
travellers' vehicles are parked, places uncared for, appa- 
rently, by any one, and they are for the whole year round 
nuclei of epidemic choleraic disease. The larger up-country 
railway stations — as, for example, Coimbatou and Salim — 
are found to prove perfect nests of cholera ; the virulence 
of which is maintained by an almost total absence of clean- 
liness. Cholera is always present in Calcutta, which we have 
already had characterized as one of the filthiest cities in the 
world. There is not a month in the year in which deaths 
do not occur from it, both European and native. It is the 
cause of one third of the total deaths, which vary from 
eleven thousand to sixteen thousand per year, out of a native 
population of about four hundred thousand. The deaths 
from cholera, from 1840 to 1850 were forty-six thousand, six 
hundred and ninety-seven ; in 1850 to 1860, forty-five thou- 
sand, eight hundred and twenty-three. The smallest mor- 
tality in any one month was, forty-six, in July, 1843 ; the 
largest is generally in April. 

" No language can be used that would be too strong to 
deprecate the wanton risk to human life which is needlessly 
allowed to cause such dire results ; and no exertions should be 



22 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

spared to save the life and protect the health of the general 
population of India, in villages, cities, and encampments. 
Very simple measures may suffice to ward off much of the 
danger now threatening citizens and pilgrims, and those who 
follow their line of march, and it may even be possible, by 
timely warning, to enable the commanding and medical offi- 
cers of troops to guard their men against the dangers of 
pestilence from occupying old camp-grounds. 

"In accordance with these views, in 1864, steps were 
taken to mitigate the evils alluded to at the grand feast 
of Conjeiveram. Cattle were, as far as possible, removed 
from the strict limits of the town. Public places of con- 
venience were erected, and their contents removed twice 
a-day. The main streets were swept and watered, and sup- 
plies of good water were made available near places of pub- 
lic resort. As regards the result of these measures, Captain 
Cloete, superintendent of police, writes : ' In 1862 and 1863, 
at this festival, the effluvium arising from the hedges and 
ditches on the side of the main street was so offensive as 
to make it quite sickening to walk in the streets in the 
morning. In 1864, 1 walked a distance of about two miles 
at daylight, and experienced no more disagreeable smell 
than is to be noticed in the bazaar at all times. The con- 
trast to the previous year was most marked, for not one case 
of cholera occurred during the festival, although it seldom 
or never, happens that cholera does not break out either 
in Conjeiveram itself, or among the people returning from the 
festival, or in Madras after the feast. I have not heard 
of any case in which the seeds of the disease were traceable, 
as having been sown in Conjeiveram. It and the adjacent 
villages have been singularly free from cholera since the fes- 
tival, and, to my belief, Madras has been unusually so.'" 



ORIGIN. 23 

In this conviction, Captain Cloete is doubtless correct. 
Madras was unquestionably saved from an epidemic by the 
timely sanitary precautions observed at Conjeiveram. Of 
the particular caste of persons willing to do the scavengery 
necessary, none were to be found in the place, and they 
had to be forwarded from Madras, forty-five miles distant. 
This absence of the sweeper caste in Conjeiveram causes an 
accumulation of rubbish, house refuse, and excreta, to remain 
piled up in the yards, even of the wealthier classes, which 
alone is sufficient in a hot climate to breed disease. But 
even the scavengers did not bring back the disease to 
Madras. Mr. Kinsley says, in a report on these sanitary meas- 
ures : " During the ten days of the festival the town remained 
free of cholera, and no cases occurred that year, although tra- 
dition says that ever since cholera was first known in India, it 
has never failed to make havoc among the Hindoo population 
at this festival. So notoriously was, and is, this the case, that 
it is said people from distant places, before starting for this 
feast, take« solemn leave of their friends in anticipation of their 
never returning." Similar precautions were observed in 1865 
with a like favorable result, although the year was notoriously 
unhealthy. 

We are now prepared to point out the principal factors 
of an epidemic of cholera: 

1st. An atmosphere impregnated with the products of 
fermenting human excitement is at once the most obvious and 
constant concomitant of the disease. 

2d. An elevated temperature with a still, stagnant, and 
peculiarly oppressive condition of the atmosphere (more 
oppressive than the elevation of the thermometer can ac- 
count for). During almost all cholera epidemics the nights 



24 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

were warmer than the days ; the atmosphere, on both land 
and sea, was singularly stagnant, and so unusually still, 
close, and hot, that it was impossible to ventilate even 
large houses, in which no change of air seemed to take 
place for almost a week together. 

3d. Unusually high readings of the barometer, viz., over 
30°, and up to 30.46°, and 30.48°. Such meteorological con- 
ditions have a marked tendency to favor the chemical de- 
composition of organic substances, and to render the season 
defective in those atmospheric changes, which, by decom- 
posing and dispersing into space the products of putre- 
faction, renew the purity of the air. 

Uh. Lowness of site, swampy grounds, moist soil, decom- 
position of vegetable matter, and all those causes which 
tend to produce bilious and remittent fevers. 

5th. Foul camping grounds, filthy streets and yards. There 
is much proof, that not only the fresh moist soil of contam- 
inated grounds is injurious, but that these, even when in a 
dry and dusty condition, are equally dangerous. Numerous 
instances are given in India, in which travellers, merchants, 
and soldiers, have encamped upon parched and arid places, 
and have quickly sickened in great numbers soon after the 
dust was thoroughly stirred up by the movements of men 
and animals. 

6ih. Impure water, especially that which is poisoned 
by the washing of the persons or clothes of cholera sub- 
jects, or which has been fouled by cholera discharges di- 
rectly emptied into it, or which has had cholera matter per- 
colated into it through the soil, or by means of imperfect 
drains. 



ORIGIN. 25 

*lth. Bad, spoiled, or defective food; especially spoiled or 
rancid meats or fish ; unripe or stale fruits and vegetables, 
&c. The natives of both Hindostan and Egypt prefer un- 
ripe melons, and think all others destitute of flavor. 

We agree substantially with Dr. McLean, Deputy Inspector- 
General of England, who concludes, from great experience in 
India, that cholera is generally propagated by human inter- 
course, and, in all probability, mainly by the poisonous ac- 
tions of the excretions of affected persons, after they have 
undergone certain changes and decompositions ; that camps 
and dormitories most under the influence of a privy or 
faecal atmosphere, invariably present the largest number 
of cases and the heaviest mortality; that cholera always 
starts from some city or district in India, and is spread by 
pilgrims, bodies of travellers, or troops, who are in move- 
ment from village to village, or from one district to another ; 
that a tainted regiment or caravan will disseminate the dis- 
ease along its route ; that a healthy caravan or regiment 
meeting with a choleraic one almost invariably contracts 
the disease, and becomes a fresh focus or centre of propa- 
gation along its line of march ; that healthy bodies of men 
who camp on ground saturated with the discharges of 
cholera patients usually suffer severely. 

Dr. Montgomery gives the following summary of the causes 
of cholera : 

(1.) Undue exposure to the vicissitudes of climate, espe- 
cially during cold nights following hot days, and the occur- 
rence of certain atmospheric conditions, including frequently an 
absence of ozone. 

(2.) Physical fatigue and nervous depression from prolonged 



26 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

travelling, mental apprehension and sorrow ; or fear, more 
especially of this disease. 

(3.) Undue abstinence or deprivation of food, or the presence 
of injurious properties in it. 

(4.) Excess in eating and drinking, and licentiousness. 

(5.) Vitiated atmosphere from all foul causes, such as filthy 
camps, nasty houses, streets, yards, &c. 

(6.) Direct exposure to the contagion of the disease. 

(a.) As regards the first of these causes, the most unhealthy 
seasons in India are those before the commencement and at 
the close of the rains. These periods, technically called the 
monsoons, rapidly chill the air at their onset, and predispose 
to fevers and bowel complaints ; while their termination, 
marked by the subsidence of floods, exposes decaying animal 
and vegetable matter to the influence of a tropical sun. Hence, 
out of 92,000 deaths, 65,000 occurred in the seven dry months, 
and only 17,000 in the five rainy ones. In twenty Aprils, there 
were 16,193 deaths ; in twenty Augusts, only 2,586 fatal cases. 
The dry months are : November, December, January, Febru- 
ary, March, April, and May. The wet months : June, July, Au- 
gust, September, and October. The hot months are : one half 
of February, March, April, May, and one half of June ; the hot 
and wet months : one half of June, July, August, September, and 
one half of October ; and the cold months : one half of October, 
November, December, January, and one half of February. Twice 
as many die in the cold months as in the wet ; and more than 
four times as many in the hot as in the wet months. Natives 
suffer most in the cold months ; Europeans in the hot months. 

A heavy fall of rain for a couple of hours has often stopped 
an outbreak, at least, for a time, Macpherson always looked 



ORIGIN. 27 

with pleasure upon rain, certain it would relieve him from 
much of the anxiety which always attends the treatment of 
cholera. 

As regards atmospheric phenomena, it will be remembered 
that when the cholera first appeared in India, in 1817, the year 
was from its commencement uncommonly moist, and the an- 
nual rains began in Bengal some three weeks before the usual 
time. The delta of the Ganges was so flooded as to become 
one vast sheet of water, and the rains exceeded the average of 
ordinary years by some thirty-three per cent. Jessore, the 
station from which the disease originated, was especially ex- 
posed to these injurious influences, lying as it did in a dense 
jungle, surrounded by stagnant water, and receiving all the 
filth of the up-country. The disease, in a mitigated form, was 
not however absent from other parts of Bengal, and more 
especially from Calcutta, which was then, and is now, 
one of the filthiest cities in the world. With appalling ra- 
pidity the pestilence spread through the different cities of 
Bengal, up towards the source of the Ganges, and beyond 
the Jumna. The territories of Oude and Rohilcund, lying 
on an elevated plateau, appear not to have suffered in 
the first instance, though they did subsequently. Within 
two or three months of the first appearance of the distemper 
it was brought to the camp of the Marquis of Hastings, 
then moving slowly through the low and unhealthy district 
of Bundelcund. A reign of terror followed its appearance — 
and the army became temporarily demoralized. The epidemic 
only lasted eight days, but during that time one thousand 
seven hundred and sixty-four soldiers and eight thousand 
native followers died. The sudden subsidence of the malady 
allowed the progress of the army, and its health became 
rapidly re-established. 



28 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

(b.) Of the second predisposing cause, namely, physical 
fatigue and nervous depression, it need only be said, that 
experience has conclusively shown that individuals proceed- 
ing on long journeys, or after their conclusion, are markedly 
liable to be attacked. It has been conclusively shown 
from well-framed and trustworthy statistics, that the prob- 
ability of cholera in the Indian army may be estimated as 
being in direct proportion with the number of men and the 
distance to be travelled. Macpherson alludes to the readi- 
ness with which, in certain districts, both European and 
native troops get cholera on their line of march. He says 
it is well known how pilgrims on their way through Lower 
Bengal and Orissa, strew the road to Juggernaut with their 
bones. Natives travelling are just as apt to suffer as Euro- 
peans. Previously fouled camp-grounds are doubtless active 
agents here. Mental or nervous depression is a recognized 
source of danger. 

(c.) Undue abstinence, during which the absorbent sys- 
tem is unusually active and the nervous system suffers 
under hypersensibility induced by depressed vital power, 
tends to its development; particularly if any of the little 
food used is of an improper description, either from directly 
producing intestinal irritation, or as wanting in nutrition. 
To the importance of this latter source, too much attention 
cannot be given. The laborers on the canal of Suez were 
mainly preserved from cholera, in 1865, by the issue of 
additional rations of healthy animal food. Certain articles 
of diet have indubitably been the immediate and exciting 
cause of a cholera capable of propagation, and of inducing 
a fatal termination. Many vegetables, more especially of 



ORIGIN. 29 

the orders of cruciferae and cucurbitacge, cause many of the 
symptoms, and are capable of originating the disease, or at 
least of developing it when the seeds have been latent. 
Unripe watermelons are conspicuous among these articles of 
diet, and are consumed by the natives in immense quanti- 
ties, more particularly when they are travelling and during 
the hot season — when pilgrimages are usually made. Its 
first appearance was by some referred to diseased rice. 

(d.) Equally, if not more injurious, than insufficient or im- 
proper food is excess ; and this is common among the Hin- 
doos, in the use of alcoholic and narcotic stimulants and 
extreme venery, to an amount that would hardly be cred- 
ited among European nations, but which is common enough 
among natives, particularly at festivals. 

(e.) Of the evil effects of overcrowding in houses, and of the 
influence of bad air, it is not necessary to say much, but the 
imagination of an English mind, could never depict the extent 
to which causes of disease are allowed to exist in native 
towns. Mere humanity itself, can, as we know, poison the 
surrounding air and fill it with fatally morbific elements. In 
these cases, cholera is not of necessity produced, but a fruit- 
ful ground is prepared where its seeds will germinate and 
eventually spring up under favoring circumstances. 

(/.) Last, but not least, among the immediate and direct 
causes of individual seizures of cholera, stands the exposure 
to its poison. 



30 ASIATIC CHOLERA, 



2. COURSE AND DISTRIBUTION. 

Having thus, in some measure, accounted for the origin of 
cholera in India, it becomes our next duty to chronicle its 
progress and diffusion over the world. First, we recall the 
fact, that although it is over forty years since it first prevailed 
in China it has never crossed the atmosphere of the Pacific, 
while it has repeatedly been brought across the Atlantic 
ocean. In 1817, the facilities of travel in India were very 
much less than they now are in Europe, and we find that 
cholera then only travelled westward, about twenty-one miles 
per week. It is also presumable that there was a greater fre- 
quency and rapidity of commercial and personal intercourse 
between Eastern and Western Hindostan than between Cal- 
cutta and China ; and we find that it only progressed about 
ten miles a week from the Ganges to Canton. When it 
reached Europe in 1830, it travelled from eighty to one hun- 
dred miles a week, and crossed the Atlantic, in old-fashioned 
sailing-vessels, at a speed of three or four hundred miles 
in seven days. Again, Moscow was the first large city 
in Europe reached by the epidemic of 1817, and it did not 
arrive there till 1830. At that time Moscow was the com- 
mercial emporium of Central Russia and Western Asia ; pa- 
godas, temples, churches, Chinese tea-houses, French cafes, 
Turkish bazaars, and Russian market-places, were there jum- 
bled together ; and Persians, Armenians, Tartars, Circassians, 
Russians, Poles, Germans, French, and other Europeans met 
in a common centre. Asia and Europe came together, and, 
of course, cholera found its way there also, and was thence 
distributed to Germany, England, and America. 

To return to India. The first great epidemic commenced, as 



COURSE AND DISTRIBUTION. 31 

usual, in the marsh region of the Ganges at Jessore ; in a 
month it progressed one hundred miles south to Calcutta, 
which is one of the filthiest cities in the world, and raged 
there more than a year. It required between two and three 
years to traverse India, from Calcutta on the East to Bombay 
on the West, where it arrived in 1820, and destroyed over 
one hundred and fifty thousand persons. In 1821, it advanced 
to the northwest, pursuing the course of rivers and travelled 
roads to Persia, Arabia, and Asia Minor. There it seemed to 
stop for a time, and devastated Central Asia ; but in 1829, it 
reached Southern Persia, and arrived in Moscow in 1830. 

At one time it was quite common to assume that the cholera 
poison was wafted solely by means of a steady atmospheric 
wave. But we have no record of a wind which blew for thir- 
teen years on the line from Calcutta to Moscow ; while we 
know that in India, the disease advanced from east to west 
in the face of a monsoon blowing persistently night and day 
in the opposite direction, and marched down the western 
shore of the Bay of Bengal in the face of a similar wind. It 
followed the course of travellers and not that of the wind. 
Even of the first epidemic, it is stated by Professor Tommasini, 
on the authority of Dr. Frias, who had lived several years in 
Alexandria, that the disease was carried from Mecca to Alex- 
andria by pilgrims returning from the feast of Kurbar-Bariam. 
There was no steamboat navigation on the Mediterranean in 
1817 to distribute the disorder promptly. 

The second great epidemic commenced in India in 1844, and 
by 1847 had reached Tantah in the delta of the Nile, where 
165,000 pilgrims had assembled from all parts of Syria and 
Egypt ; over 3,000 died there of cholera, and soon after the 
dispersion of this vast crowd, it appeared in Cairo and Alex 



32 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

andria, and also quickly forced its way into Persia. In Lower 
Egypt alone, 55,000 died in 1847, out of a population of 
2,500,000. It reached Moscow the same year ; was carried 
again from Russia and Germany, in ships to London, in Octo- 
ber, ] 848, and arrived in America soon after. 

About the present epidemic, or that of 1865 and 1866, we 
have gathered the following account : In the month of March, 
1865, the cholera showed itself on the banks of the Ganges, 
its perpetual bed, and raged for twenty-two days as an epi- 
demic without leaving the country ; then, possibly, somewhat 
aided by a strong southwest wind, it began to move, dividing 
itself into two columns, one following the track of the Hindoo 
pilgrims as far as Mecca and Medina ; the other, not less ter- 
rible, advanced by Afghanistan towards Cashmere and Bok- 
hara, and thence forced a passage into the Russian provinces 
of Asia, and into Russia in Europe, accompanying the caravans 
of merchants. It broke out on ships with pilgrims, and also 
on the line of march of the Hindoo pilgrims on their way from 
India to Mecca, long before anything of the kind had occurred 
at Mahomet's shrine. Early in May, seven hundred thousand 
pilgrims and over one million of animals arrived at Mecca. Most 
of these were, of course, poorly clothed, had long been badly 
fed, and many of them were exhausted ; they found no en- 
campment worthy of consideration, no sufficiency of fresh, 
wholesome food, no full supply of pure, fair water ; they made 
no latrines or drains ; no one was ready or willing to bury the 
dead ; they were exposed to great heat ; and finally, on a par- 
ticular day each pilgrim was required to sacrifice one animal. 
The enormous mass of blood and entrails which was cast 
among the other heaps of filth which had accumulated in a com- 
paratively small place, was sufficient to engender severe dis- 



COURSE AND DISTRIBUTION. 33 

ease : and, in addition, " cholera-matters" were introduced by 
the Hindoo pilgrims. It is below the mark to say, that forty 
thousand of the devotees died of cholera in 1865, at and near 
Mecca. We have seen that the festivals of the Hindoos at Jug- 
gernaut, Conjeiveram, and Ramieseweram, and their great fairs 
at Hurdwar and Bigginuggar, have often played an important 
part in the origin and distribution of cholera — hereafter the 
Kourban-Bairam, or " Feast of Sacrifices," at Mecca, will hold 
the first rank in public estimation. Mecca is so close to the east 
bank, and so nearly opposite the centre of the Red Sea, that 
it becomes a convenient place for the distribution of cholera. 
Nearly twenty thousand pilgrims from Mecca, all more or less 
infected, passed the Isthmus of Suez, early in 1865, in order to 
embark at Alexandria for Europe and Algeria. Suez and 
Alexandria were healthy until pilgrims returning from Mecca 
arrived there. 

Dr. Frazer, a resident of Suez, says it is not only the great 
highway for intercourse and traffic between Europe and Asia 
including Australasia, but forms besides the chief route for the 
devout of the Islam world, from Asia and Africa, Bokhara, 
Turkey, and the Crimea, and from the very centre of North 
Africa. At Suez, cholera has always been distinctly traced 
to importation, and has in every instance been brought by 
the pilgrims on their way either to or from Mecca. It has 
been brought from North Africa and the Crimea, to Suez and 
Mecca, and vice versa. 

From Mecca and Suez it quickly reached Cairo, where it 
raged only twelve days ; the atmosphere of the city is exces- 
sively dry, as for twenty leagues around there is a complete 
absence of marshes. But the very place in Cairo, where the 
common people obtain their drinking water, is impregnated 

3 



34 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

with loathsome impurities ; many large barracks are there 
and a numerous collection of grain and other boats in the 
vicinity, and the soldiers and boatmen use the river as a great 
cesspool or water-closet. 

From Cairo it was carried to Alexandria, where it prevailed 
three weeks. Alexandria is a damp city, surrounded by 
immense marshes, and the air is loaded with carbonic acid. 
Cholera once lingered around St. Petersburgh for four years y 
apparently because that city is built on. marshes, and the air 
contains at least four parts per thousand of carbonic acid. 
Cholera first appeared in Alexandria, on May 11th, 1865, 
near the railway station from Cairo, in one of the lowest sub- 
urbs of the city, and inhabited by 20,000 of the lowest class 
of Arabs, Greeks, and Maltese. It seemed to arise from one 
case, but doubtless many others were imported ; only three or 
four died during the first two or three days ; then eight to ten 
succumbed daily. By June 1st, there were 30 deaths per day ; 
on the 17th, 61, and on the 25th, 183. At this time the sani- 
tary condition of the city was infamous, and the water-supply, 
derived from the Nile, was charged in its course with decom- 
posing matter derived from the carcasses of 700 animals lying 
in the canal. In Lower Egypt alone, over 80,000 died of 
cholera in 1865. 

The malady was brought to Aleppo by a Persian caravan, 
August 14, 1865 ; at first there were only five or six deaths 
per day ; then 40 to 50, and by September 1st, 250 died every 
twenty-four hours. It was also taken to Bagdad by pilgrims 
from Mecca, and thousands died in a short time. 

For some days it was hoped that the disease would be 
stayed at Alexandria ; but it soon appeared at Constantinople, 
and a few days later at Ancona, in the direct line of steamboat 



COURSE AND DISTRIBUTION. 35 

travel. In Constantinople it is estimated that 50,000 persons 
died ; and in one district of the city, with 2,000 inhabitants, 
between 300 and 400 succumbed. At Ancona, 1,346 died, out 
of a population of 46,000. 

Constantinople, like all Turkish and Eastern towns, is dis- 
tinguished for want of cleanliness ; all offal and filth are 
thrown into the streets, and what is not consumed by dogs 
remains under a burning sun, a heap of putrefying vegetable 
and animal matter ; the only drains are open ditches in the 
middle of narrow streets ; their sluggish contents empty into 
the almost stagnant waters of the Golden Horn, for the cur- 
rent of the Black Sea passes so gently by the docks as to 
leave the water in the harbor almost unchanged. 

From Constantinople the disease spread into the surround- 
ing country, and in almost all cases the infection could be 
traced to fugitives. The pestilence was particularly violent 
at the first part of the epidemic ; there were but few premoni- 
tory symptoms ; cramps and vomiting were rapidly followed 
by collapse. In the city itself, there were, as a rule, only a 
very few cases in any recently-affected quarter, for the first 
day or two ; afterwards, in a single night, countless victims fell, 
as if by one stroke from the avenging angel ; then everybody 
took to flight ; the dead were left unburied, and the sick were 
deserted by their relatives ; for some days subsequently a few 
more cases occurred, and gradually such local epidemics 
seemed to burn themselves out. The same course which the 
scourge thus pursued in whole quarters of the city was also 
observed in single streets and houses ; at first the disease was 
imported, and there was a case or two ; suddenly there was an 
immense mortality, and then it gradually diminished. A single 
case in one house was quite exceptional ; there were generally 



36 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

several, and in some instances the whole population of a dwel- 
ling was literally swept away. 

(a.) DISTRIBUTION BY SHIPS. 

Pilgrim and emigrant ships may be broadly described as 
floating encampments of filthy people ; and steamboats, on ac- 
count of their greater heat below decks, increase all infectious 
diseases which may be brought to them. It seems that 
cholera has the same predilection for ships that yellow-fever 
has ; both have a lengthened incubation at times, and may 
only break out long after the vessel has left port ; and when 
the disorder is once established on board, it clings to the un- 
fortunate boat with great tenacity. In yellow-fever, it is the 
exhalations from the patient and the vomits which are most 
dangerous ; but in cholera the alvine discharges propagate 
the disorder ; hence, bedding which has been used by cholera 
patients, and water-closets which have been visited by them, 
may retain the contagion for a long time. And it seems to be 
well-proven that the discharges of persons suffering from the 
milder forms of the disease, called cholera-diarrhoea, or choler- 
ine, contain the poison just as copiously as the severer varie- 
ties. As early as 1819, an English frigate carried cholera from 
Ceylon to Mauritius and the Isle of France, whence it was 
taken, in 1820, to Zanguebar, on the east coast of Africa. It 
also arrived in the Philippines by ship from Madras in 1820. 
But, we first propose to turn our attention to the increase 
and conveyance of the disease by steamships during the 
present epidemic, or that of 1865 and 1866. In former times 
the principal movements of trade and pilgrimage from India 
were carried on by caravans by land, and in the case of the 
pilgrims to Mecca, the passage of the Arabian desert contrib- 



DISTRIBUTION BY SHIPS. 37 

uted to improve the health of the travellers. At the present 
day, owing to the conveniences and speed of steam travel, it 
is by sea, and in a very short time that these journeys are in 
great part accomplished. On the Red Sea Boats, thousands 
of Mohammedans of every nationality are now crowded, and 
numbers of pilgrims from India died on them, during the 
months of March and April, 1865. On one vessel alone 
there were no less than eighty deaths from cholera. If 
an epidemic breaks out among the pilgrims at Mecca, the 
next places, of all others, most likely to suffer, will be Suez, 
Cairo, and Alexandria ; and if the disease reaches Alexan- 
dria, the first town in the Papal states will be Ancona, as 
the communication between the two places by steam is 
most perfect. The next most exposed places, are : Con- 
stantinople, Malta, Marseilles, and G-ibr altar. And this is 
the exact route which the epidemic pursued, for, within two 
or three days after it was decidedly fixed at Ancona, it also 
appeared in Constantinople. As far as the latter city is con- 
cerned we are in no doubt about the origin of the disease, for 
it was brought from Egypt by a frigate, the Mourbir Sour our, 
laden with stores, and charged with infection ; two cholera 
patients were landed from her on July 8th, and by the 12th 
thirty fatal cases had occurred in the hospital, whence it 
spread into the city. Thus, the epidemic quickly became 
active at three great centres : 1st, at Alexandria, commanding 
the whole of the Mediterranean from Tripoli on the east to 
Barcelona on the west ; 2d, at Ancona, controlling the gulf of 
Yenice ; and, 3d, at Constantinople, the head of navigation of 
the Black sea. Steamships played a most important part in 
carrying cholera to various parts of the Black sea, and up the 
Danube ; finallv the regular lines were discontinued when it 



38 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

became only too evident that the disease was carried on, and 
distributed from them. At one time they were filled with those 
flying from the various places where the pestilence prevailed, 
and outbreaks of cholera occurred at the different landings 
soon after the arrival of the boats. It would also pass by 
cities nearer the localities where the disease was raging and 
attack others more distant, but with which steam communica- 
tion was more frequent and direct. It is stated positively 
that the epidemic took an overland route in no single instance, 
at first, but travelled from one coast town to another, as it was 
carried by steamships. It was also introduced into Beiroot by 
steamers, some of whose passengers died at the quarantine, 
others in the houses, or even in the very streets of the town. It 
reached Malta in the direct line of steamboat travel by August 
28th, and Marseilles on September 11th. In the course of five 
days, four steamers arrived at Marseilles direct from Alexan- 
dria with six hundred and sixty-two passengers, some of whom 
were Algerine pilgrims from Mecca. One vessel brought 
sixty-seven pilgrims ; two more had died, of cholera on the 
voyage, and one immediately on landing. At this time there 
was no cholera in Marseilles, but in eleven days it prevailed 
as an epidemic. By September 24th, it reached Paris by rail- 
road from Marseilles ; on September 22d, it arrived in South- 
ampton, by steamers direct, in four days, from Gibraltar, 
where the disease was also raging. This is the first time that 
cholera has reached England by the way of the South; in 
1832 and 1848, it was introduced into England from Eussia 
and North Germany, and directly traced to ships arriving from 
Biga, Cronstadt, Hamburg, and Dantzig, where the disease pre- 
vailed in those years, before it did on the Mediterranean. In 
fact, in January, 1833, an English ship brought down the dis- 



DISTRIBUTION BY SHIPS. 39 

case to Lisbon, whence it spread to Portugal and Spain ; did 
not reach Marseilles till December, 1834, nor Lombardy and 
Venice till 1836, and Trieste in 1837. 

The point of attack of every epidemic in England has always 
been at one, or the other, of the principal seaport towns. In 
1832, it was originally brought from Hamburg to Sunderland, 
where the German Ocean has its greatest width, and the dis- 
tance is too great for the disease to be blown across. In 
1848, it first broke out in London, and could be clearly traced 
to Hamburg emigrants, as cases of cholera had occurred on the 
vessel by which they arrived. The third general epidemic 
reached St. Petersburg in October, 1852 ; prevailed extensively 
in the north of Europe in 1853 ; reached Hamburg on July 
28th, and was carried to Liverpool by August 22d ; still arriv- 
ing in England by the northern route, and not by way of the 
wind, which would have reached the eastern shore of Eng- 
land before it did the western, on which Liverpool is situated. 
In 1866, after the disease had prevailed in various parts of 
Germany during the winter, it was brought down the Rhine 
to Rotterdam, and thence taken in a direct line to Hull, on the 
eastern coast of England, and subsequently, by rail, to Liv- 
erpool. 

Cholera has always been brought to America by ships. 
Early in 1832, the brig Carrick, bringing emigrants from 
England, arrived at Quebec ; forty-two of the passengers had 
died of cholera on the voyage, and it broke out in a severe 
epidemic form at Quebec, on the 6th of June ; by the 10th, it 
had travelled up the St. Lawrence to Montreal, and soon 
reached Detroit, In the latter part of June the ship Henry 
IY. arrived at New York with cholera patients, and the dis - 
ease appeared in the city by the 24th ; it spread up the Hud- 



40 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

son river, and joined the Canada trail. From New York it also 
was quickly carried to Philadelphia and the West. Again, dur- 
ing the second epidemic in Europe, two vessels sailed from 
Havre, where cholera prevailed ; one, the New York, for New 
York, the other the Swanton, for New Orleans. Both vessels 
carried large numbers of German emigrants ; on one the 
cholera appeared when sixteen days out, with fourteen deaths ; 
on the other, in twenty-six days, with thirteen deaths. The 
New York arrived at Staten Island on December 2, 1848, and 
a severe epidemic soon broke out, but was confined to the 
Quarantine grounds. The Swanton arrived at New Orleans 
December 11 ; no quarantine was instituted, and in two days 
cholera patients were taken into the Charity hospital; this 
was the beginning of a severe epidemic, which lasted the 
whole of the winter, which was unusually mild. There 
were three or four hundred deaths from cholera in New 
Orleans, in December, 1848; about six hundred in January, 
then increasing till June, when there were two thousand five 
hundred. On the 20th of December, it reached Memphis, by 
steamboat, from New Orleans, where for twenty-five days it 
remained confined to the landing-place, and to the persons 
communicating with the vessel ; then it began to spread to the 
more distant houses. In the spring of 1849 it was brought to 
St. Louis and Cincinnati, and the whole valley of the Missis- 
sippi was finally involved. By October of the next year, it 
reached Sacramento, by means of overland emigrants; and 
almost simultaneously arrived at San Francisco by the United 
States mail steamer Northerner from Panama. The Chinese in 
California suffered the most severely ; the disease was brought 
almost around the world, by way of the west, to reach them 
there. It is probable that with increased steam communica- 



DISTRIBUTION BY SHIPS. 41 

tion to and from San Francisco, it may soon be brought direct 
from China, across the Pacific ocean. 

In the latter part of 1853, cholera was brought to Liverpool 
and prevailed during the winter, more or less extensively 
throughout England. In the fall, cholera-ships came in great 
numbers to New York ; in October alone, twenty-eight in- 
fected ships arrived with eleven hundred and forty-one cases, 
and the disease became epidemic on the Quarantine grounds 
at Staten Island, but seemed to die out during the winter. In 
the spring, however, other vessels added fresh infection to 
the embers of the old, and the first case occurred in New 
York, on May 11th, and thence spread, as usual, to the larger 
cities on the regular lines of travel. 

Dr. Swinborne, Port physician of New York, gives the fol- 
lowing account of the origin of cholera on board the Atalanta, 
in 1865 : She sailed from Havre, on October 12th, with fifty- 
two cabin and five hundred and fifty-two steerage passengers, 
all of whom had been a few hours or days in Paris, where 
cholera prevailed ; and five days at the hotels, Weissen Lamm, 
and Rullgarder Hof in Havre. While at these hotels, emi- 
grants who had arrived only a few days before, were taken ill 
with cholera and sent to the hospital. On the first day out 
(October 13th), a little child from the Weissen Lamm died ; in 
six days, five deaths occurred in one party from the Hullgar- 
der Hof In all, the Atalanta had one hundred and two cases 
and twenty-three deaths. The Hermann arrived shortly after 
(November 16) with several cases, and the first death on board 
occurred in the very family who had lost their mother of 
cholera at the Hullgarder Hof at Havre. It is also significant 
that the Atalanta, Mary Ann, Hermann, and Harp swell, all had 
names on their passenger-lists the owners of which were not 

3* 



42 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

to be found among the passengers, but were declared to have 
been sent to the hospital at Havre. Up to November 17, 
there had been six thousand deaths by cholera in Paris and the 
department of the Seine. Another account says : The cholera 
of 1865 made its first appearance in Havre, on October 10th, 
and was undoubtedly brought there by German emigrants, of 
whom about nine hundred arrived between the 7th and 9th, 
from Paris, where the disease was at its height. These emi- 
grants were en route for New York, and the cholera broke out 
among them on the 10th ; eight died in forty-eight hours in 
the hospital, and two or three more in the emigrant hotels. 
Many of these emigrants sailed on the Atalanta for New York 
on October 12th. 

The steamship England, from Liverpool for New York, 
bringing the same class of passengers, was obliged to put into 
Halifax, in distress, on the 9th of May, 1866, having had one 
hundred and sixty cases of cholera and fifty deaths, on that 
short voyage. On the 18 th of April, the steamship Virginia 
arrived at New York, with over one thousand passengers, 
most of them Germans, who had come from infected places on 
the Rhine ; about fifty died of cholera on the passage. 

We all know how cholera prevailed in Paris ; how it ob- 
tained but a slight foothold in England last year. How it 
lingered along the Rhine last winter, and recommenced this 
spring ; how it was conveyed by German emigrants down the 
Rhine to Rotterdam, and thence to Hull and Liverpool ; and 
we all know how many abortive attempts have been made to 
land it in this country from the steamships Atalanta, Helvetia, 
Virginia, and others. The history of the cholera on board 
these vessels is somewhat peculiar ; they and they alone 
brought cholera to our shores, although other vessels were 



DISTRIBUTION BY WIND. - 43 

bringing emigrants of the same class and nationality ; but they 
and they alone, had a lower or orlop deck for passengers, 
below the water line, where three or four hundred per- 
sons, out of one thousand, or more, were kept in darkness, 
heat from the boilers and furnaces, in their own filth, and with 
very imperfect ventilation. Almost the counterparts of the 
climate and injurious influences of India were here reproduced 
artificially, and cholera might almost have originated anew on 
board this peculiar line of steam-vessels. Xot a single case 
occurred in the comparatively well-ventilated cabins while it 
raged among the poor steerage passengers. 

It is significant that cholera has always lingered in Europe 
during the winter preceding its occurrence in America. 

(b.) DISTRIBUTION BY WIND. 

It may safely be affirmed that wind plays but an occasional 
and insignificant part in the conveyance of cholera ; a favoring 
gale may promote its transmission somewhat, and an adverse 
one can only retard it temporarily. Dr. Parkes once thought 
that it generally progressed with the wind and not by the 
shortest route of human intercourse, or even by the way of 
the greatest travel ; but, in 1664, he writes : " On looking back 
to the epidemics I saw in India, I can perceive many points 
which are capable of a different explanation, if putrefying 
stools are the cause." Still, when these become dry. they may 
be blown about by the wind, and some observers have even 
noticed a peculiar aromatic smell in the air (odor cholerica) 
when cholera prevailed. The rapidity with which the " rice 
water discharges" must pass into a dry state, under the burn- 
ing rays of a tropical sun, renders it highly probable, that in 
India, dust, the so-called ;: cholera-dust," takes a large share in 



44 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

the distribution of cholera. This remains on the camp-grounds 
where the disease has prevailed, and may be blown to greater 
or lesser distances by the wind ; and very frequently it is 
stirred up by men and animals and carried about in their 
clothes and skins. In India such cases are thought to be 
numerous. In 1854, one wing of a cavalry regiment, just 
arrived from England and in high health, ascended the Ganges 
in boats ; at a certain period of the voyage it arrived at a part 
of the country where cholera prevailed in the villages on the 
banks of the river, but with which they did not communicate. 
There, cases of the disease occurred in the boats, and the men 
were advised to push on rapidly, and in a few days after, when 
they had passed the limits of the existence of the disease on 
the banks, it ceased to show itself among the troops. The 
other wing of the regiment followed some time afterwards, by 
the same mode of conveyance ; became affected with cholera 
at the same place, and lost it again at the same point. 
These attacks were thought to have arisen from inhaling 
the air, or cholera dust blown over the river from the 
infected villages ; but, they may have been caused by 
drinking the river-water, contaminated, as it must have been, 
with " cholera matters." Another case seems to point to its 
diffusion by the air alone : In one of the Western Islands 
off Scotland, the most remote from the main land, cholera sud- 
denly appeared, when so little intercourse existed with the 
place, that the clergyman had continued to pray, regularly 
every Sunday, for King William the Fourth, for eighteen 
months after Queen Victoria had ascended the throne. Still, 
one or more persons with cholerine may have crossed over 
from the main land. Again, on the arrival of an infected 
steamer from Egypt, in 1865, which was permitted to perform 



DISTRIBUTION BY WIND. 45 

a three days' quarantine off Beiroot, almost the entire crew of 
a British corvette, lying at anchor to windward, suffered se- 
verely from diarrhoea. In this case, the bilge and washing 
water of the infected ship, and ihe scrubbings of the privies 
and the discharges of the cholera patients, may have been car- 
ried down by the wind to the corvette, and contaminated 
water may have been used to wash her decks. At Naples, 
in 1865, the number of cases began to increase coincidentally 
with the sirocco wind. Hence the sirocco was supposed to 
carry cholera with it. This theory lasted till the wind 
changed and blew from a northerly direction, with greater 
violence than had been known for years before. Still the 
malady grew worse, and the greatest havoc by it was al- 
most all on those blustering days. Cholera had already got a 
footing by means of individuals in Naples, and the public 
sewers and drains were in a horrible condition. In 1832, Dr. 
Vache lost thirty small-pox patients in hospital at Staten 
Island from cholera, where the distance between the hospitals 
was between two and three hundred feet, and strict non-inter- 
course was enforced. But it may have been conveyed by 
clothes, or washerwomen. Dr. Bryson found it on the English 
fleet, when several miles off shore, after a cruise of some 
duration, and before any communication had been had with 
the land. In other cases it is said to have been noticed that 
vessels would become infected at anchor, in harbor, when the 
wind blew from the shore, or over other affected vessels. It 
is possible that it may be carried a short distance by the wind, 
but not far, as the poison soon becomes so much diffused as to 
lose its power. Others think it can be blown long distances, 
and cite the fact that infusoria have been found three hundred 
and eighty miles from the coast ; that ashes from Vesuvius 



46 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

have been carried by the wind to Venice and Greece, and 
have even reached Calabria, fifty leagues off in a thick cloud ; 
and that the same has happened from Mount Hecla. They bid 
us to remember, in this connection, that a wind barely sensible 
moves at the rate of two miles an hour ; a gentle breeze, five 
miles ; and a very strong wind twenty-five miles ; and a gale, 
forty miles. Still, as Dr. Sayre has pertinently put it, it did not 
move two hundred feet, nor twenty feet, from the steerage to 
the cabin passengers, on board the Atalanta, England, Virginia, 
and many other steamships, notwithstanding all the breezes 
which blow on the Atlantic. Again, in the epidemic at Ebrach, 
in Bavaria, in 1854, of over two hundred soldiers, guards, 
nurses, servants, physicians and clergymen, not one was 
attacked who did not use the affected privies of the prisoners, 
or wash their clothes. 

(C.) DISTRIBUTION BY DRINKING-WATER. 

Impure water is even more injurious than foul air, filthy 
people, contaminated soil, neglected sewers, cesspools, and 
privies. In places where the water is not as pure as the 
Croton water of New York, nor as perfectly protected by 
pipes, the choice of water for drinking and culinary purposes 
demands great care ; and that taken from rivers which pass 
cities and towns is particularly objectionable, as it is certain 
to be contaminated with sewerage matters. Thus, Croton 
water contains but 6.66 of impurity ; London water from 
19 to 35 ; and Paris water from 24 to 46. If a little of the 
sediment from the Thames water, after being well dried, be 
held for a minute or two over the flame of a candle, it will 
emit an odor which is most disagreeable and disgusting, aris- 
ing from the evolution of gases from the decomposition of 



DISTRIBUTION BY DRINKING-WATER. 4? 

organic matter. The consequences of drinking such water in 
cholera times have been fully developed by Dr. Snow. He 
tells us that the South districts of London are mostly supplied 
with water by two companies, the Lambeth, and the South- 
ward: and Yauxhall. In 1849, the water of both companies 
contained the sewage of London as it was washed to and fro 
with the tide, and the whole of the districts which they sup- 
plied suffered severely with cholera. In 1852, the Lambeth 
company changed their source of supply to Thames Ditton, a 
part of the river beyond the influence of the tide, and out of 
reach of the sewage of London. In 1853 and 1854, the 
districts to which this new water-supply extended suffered 
less than in 1849, and the houses supplied by the New Lam- 
beth water not nearly as much as the others. The pipes of 
both companies go down all the streets, courts, and alleys. 
Some houses are supplied by one company, and the rest by the 
other ; in many cases a single house has a supply different 
from that on either side. Each company supplies both rich 
and poor, both large houses and small, and there is no differ- 
ence in the condition or occupation of the persons receiving 
the water of the two companies. No experiment could have 
been devised which would more thoroughly test the effect of 
pure and impure water on the progress and distribution of 
cholera than this, which circumstances placed ready-made 
before so careful an observer as Dr. Snow. The experiment, 
too, was on the grandest scale. No fewer than 300,000 people 
of both sexes, of every age and occupation, and of every rank 
and station, from gentlefolks down to the very poor, were 
divided into two groups without their choice, and, in most 
cases, without their knowledge ; one group being supplied 
with water containing the sewage of London, and among 



48 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

it, whatever might have come from cholera patients ; the other, 
getting water comparatively free from such impurity. Dr. 
Snow obtained at the Kegistrar-General's office a list of deaths 
from cholera during the first four weeks of the epidemic of 
1854, and went to the houses himself to ascertain the charac- 
ter of the water supply. There were 334 fatal cases in all, 
and 286 of these had lived in houses supplied by the impure 
water of the Southwark and Vauxhail Company ; and only 
fourteen in those dependent on the Lambeth Company ; in 
twenty-two instances, the water was obtained by dipping a pail 
directly into the Thames ; in twelve cases, from pump-wells, 
&c. Cholera was fourteen times more fatal to those who drank 
the impure water. In another period of three weeks, 997 
deaths occurred in houses supplied with the foul water, and 
only eighty-four in those which got the purer liquid. There 
were six hundred and eleven deaths among the patrons of the 
Lambeth water, and three thousand four hundred and seventy- 
six among those of the other company. Dr. Snow has also 
distinguished himself by the pains-taking manner in which he 
has proved that cholera may be distributed through the medi- 
um of drinking-water, by the cholera evacuations getting into 
pumps and other local supplies of water, owing to accidental 
communications between privies, drains, or cesspools, and the 
wells. The most striking feature of these outbreaks is, that 
they occur very suddenly and nearly simultaneously, and very 
soon after a single case has happened among the persons 
whose evacuations contaminated the water. In a very severe 
outbreak of cholera which took place in Wandsworth road, 
London, in 1849, the water was not habitually polluted, but 
became so by the bursting and overflow of the house-drains 
into the water-tanks, during a thunder-storm. The houses in 



DISTRIBUTION BY DRINKING-WATER. 49 

which this catastrophe occurred were seventeen in number ; 
they were semi-detached villas and genteel suburban dwell- 
ings ; they were drained and supplied with spring-water on 
one plan. The water was conducted into a series of tanks 
placed underground at the back of each house, at the same 
level, and the water which overflowed ran into a drain which 
also received the house-drains and the overflow from the cess- 
pools. The contents of this drain were forced back into the 
drinking-water tanks at the time of the thunder-storm, and 
when the tanks were afterward opened by the Commissioners 
of Sewers, privy-soil was found from six to nine inches deep 
in them. In order to explain how water can be used under 
these circumstances, it is necessary to state, that when privy- 
soil is left at rest in water, it settles principally to the bottom, 
leaving the water above not much altered in physical appear- 
ance. At the time of the overflow of the drain, a lady in one 
of the houses had been suffering for two days with cholera, of 
which she died two days afterward, and two days subse- 
quently to her death the great outbreak took place. About 
half the persons living in the seventeen houses were affected, 
and about one half of them died. The attack extended to all 
the houses in which the water was polluted, and did not reach 
any others, though there were plenty of houses both in a con- 
tinuous line with these, and before and behind them. Dr. 
Snow also gives a very full account of the fatal and extensive 
outbreak of cholera which occurred in 1854, in Broad street, 
Golden square, London. He quickly suspected some contami- 
nation of the water, of the much frequented Broad street 
well, took away the handle of the pump on his own respon- 
sibility, and quickly put an end to an epidemic which had al- 
ready caused six hundred and fourteen deaths. Dr. Snow 



50 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

made inquiry at every house in which the first seventy-three 
deaths took place during the first two days of the epidemic ; 
sixty-one persons had certainly drank of this water, and the 
others had all died or moved away except six. The parish 
authorities made excavations and found that the contents of a 
cesspool, situated only three feet from the well passed through 
its decayed walls, and percolated through the intervening 
ground and then ran through the open brickwork of the side 
of the well. A child had died of cholera in the house to 
which the cesspool belonged, three days before the great out- 
break and its dejections had been emptied into the cesspool. 
Seventy workmen of a brewery quite near the pump escaped 
entirely, because they had a well on their own grounds ; and 
the inmates of the workhouse situated in the infected district 
enjoyed a like immunity, from having a pump of their own. 
A lady who formerly lived in Broad street, but had moved to 
the West end, had the water from this pump taken out of 
town to her every day ; she and a niece who was visiting her 
were fatally attacked with cholera, and her only servant had a 
severe attack of diarrhoea. A remarkably corroborative fact 
has been reported by Mr. Lawrence : Bethlehem Hospital and 
an asylum for children stand near together, on an open space 
of ground between fourteen and sixteen acres in extent, in the 
parish of St. George, Southwark. Being dissatisfied with the 
filthy water then supplied by the Lambeth Company, the 
governors of these two institutions, some thirty years ago, 
sank Artesian wells on the premises and the pure water thus 
procured is used exclusively by the inmates, about seven hun- 
dred in number ; it is said there has not been a single case of 
cholera in the hospital or asylum in any of the three epi- 
demics, although the disease has prevailed extensively in the 



DISTRIBUTION BY DRINKING-WATER. 51 

streets in their immediate vicinity. The epidemic of 1849, at 
Paris, was evidently spread extensively by means of impure wa- 
ter ; and at Sevres, diarrhoea frequently became epidemic among 
those who drank the water of the Seine and ceased when that from 
an Artesian well was used. In 1865, the clothes and mattresses 
of cholera subjects were washed in the basin of a public foun- 
tain at Tavatola ; unfortunately the waste pipe was broken and 
the foul water was carried into the clean ; and in one day sixty 
people died in a small section of the city, supplied with this 
fluid. There were terrible epidemics in 1861 and 1862 at 
Mean Meer, in India, and the water was not only found brack- 
ish, but tainted with fsecal impurities. The British man-of-war 
Euryalus had a healthy crew when she went to Tokohama ; 
but the ship's water was taken from a reservoir situated in a 
paddy field, which was manured with human ordure, and 
where the Japanese had been seen to wash their soiled 
clothes ; three hundred and forty cases of bowel-disease oc- 
curred among five hundred and twenty men. The small Ep- 
ping epidemic of 1865 is also quite instructive ; a gentleman 
had been indisposed for two years with indigestion and great 
lowness of spirits, and his wife and mother had been out of 
sorts for a long time. Their sole supply of water came from a 
deep well, situated down the hillside ; this water had had for 
a long time an unpleasant odor and nauseous taste, and sul- 
phuretted hydrogen was detected in it, with much organic mat- 
ter. They were ordered away to the seaside and improved 
greatly, but unfortunately on their return stayed a day or two 
in Southampton and Portland, where cholera prevailed ; they 
returned home, were attacked with the disease, and eight per- 
sons out of eleven in their family died, including one of the 
physicians. Their house was half a mile away from any other 



52 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

residence ; it was on a hill ; the temperature was falling, so that 
heat had nothing to do with it ; they were attacked suddenly, 
so that fear had nothing to do with it ; there was no pervading 
atmospheric influence, for there were no other attacks in the 
neighborhood ; there was plenty to eat and drink, so that 
poverty had nothing to do with it. But a leakage was found 
in the pipes of the water-closet which ran under the founda- 
tion of the house down towards the well, and sewage-matter 
was not only distinctly traceable on the outside of the well, 
but privy filth was found at the bottom of it. It is very evi- 
dent that pumps and wells which are located near and below 
the level of drains, cesspools, privies, or stables, may become 
very dangerous in cholera times. It is also probable that in all 
cities which are built on hillsides, the receptacles of drinking- 
water in the lower parts may become contaminated by foul 
drainage getting into them from the higher ground. 

(d.) DISTRIBUTION BY INDIVIDUALS. 

Persons, already sick with cholera, are the most active 
agents in disseminating the disease ; they, and they alone, 
contaminate the air, water, and soil, and bring the disease to 
our houses, ships, and camps. Among the most striking 
proofs of this, we select the following : In October, 1865, 
there was no cholera in Western Germany, until it was im- 
ported into Altenburg, near Leipzig, in the very heart of 
Saxony. A lady and her daughter left Odessa on the 16th of 
August, when cholera was at its' height there, and travelled 
nine days and nights continuously, to reach their home in 
Altenburg, on the 24th. The daughter had cholera-diarrhoea 
when she started, and died in Altenburg in a few days after 
her arrival. The mother, who had been well previously 



DISTRIBUTION BY INDIVIDUALS. 53 

sickened on the 27th with real cholera and died in two days ; 
her sister-in-law was attacked in the same house on the 29th, 
and died in twenty-eight hours. This dwelling formed the 
first centre of infection, from which the disease extended. 
The epidemic lasted from August 28th to November 18th, 
and one hundred and eighty cases occurred in all, of which 
one hundred and eight were fatal. It is asserted that 
Altenburg was in an unusually healthy condition, but that 
the inhabitants live mostly on vegetables, black bread, 
coffee, and beer ; meat being only used regularly by the 
better classes. The disease spread from Altenburg to Werden, 
a neighboring town, by railway communication, and up to 
October 20th, 1865, there had been one hundred and forty- 
nine cases there, with fifty-two deaths. It is justly thought 
that this isolated outbreak of cholera in a previously healthy 
district, and which was clearly traced to persons coming from 
a centre of infection, must prove an important link in the 
evidence already accumulated to prove the portable and con- 
tagious nature of the disease, and its comparatively long 
period of incubation, at times. The sequel of this Altenburg 
epidemic promises to become still more interesting ; for in a 
late paper we read : " Xo cases of cholera have been re- 
ported from the Prussian army in Saxony, but the close 
vicinity of this disease at Altenburg makes people look with 
apprehension on any marked change in the weather, and the 
heat has much increased of late." The very next steamer 
brought the following : " The Prussian government is much 
disquieted at the spread of cholera in the army ; for on the 
4th and 5th of June, thirty-one cases, six of which were fatal, 
occurred in the 3d regiment of the guards." A letter from 
the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, states that the greatest 



54 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

alarm prevails throughout the district, owing to the dreadful 
ravages made by cholera ; the disease was first brought by a 
workman from Paris ; it soon spread to eight towns, and in 
Diekirch, destroyed over one hundred persons, in three days, 
out of a population of two thousand. Pettenkofer thought 
he had traced the origin of cholera in Munich, in 1854, to 
those who brought goods to the Great Exhibition. On July 
17th, cholera-diarrhoea commenced among them, and by the 25th, 
thirty cases occurred daily ; one himdred and forty-four cases 
in all were reported in July, five hundred and forty-nine in 
August, two hundred and thirty-six in September, and thirty- 
nine in October. From these persons and the privies of the 
Crystal Palace, and those of the houses in which they boarded 
(for two hundred and fifty-three of them lived in no less than 
two hundred and forty-two dwellings, situated in one hundred 
and ten different streets), the disease is supposed to have 
spread through the city. Cholera occurred in no less than one 
hundred and twelve dwellings out of one hundred and seventy 
occupied by this class of persons, and it was also noticed that 
the disease almost always commenced three of four days ear- 
lier in them, justifying the opinion that it originated there. 
The first case of cholera had been preceded by diarrhoea for 
eight days. Again, in the prison at Ebrach, in Bavaria, a man 
named Lorenz Grassl, was brought from Munich, with cholera- 
diarrhoea, after being detained several days in a police-station 
where cases of cholera had occurred. In a few days he came 
under treatment for severe diarrhoea, which progressed to 
cholera, but from which he recovered perfectly. The privies 
which extended through every story of the prison, were in a 
most disgusting condition, and it is supposed that the dis- 
charges from this one cholera patient infected the whole 



DISTRIBUTION BY INDIVIDUALS. 55 

offensive mass, so that a severe epidemic soon commenced 
and killed fifteen per cent, of the prisoners. The disease 
was not confined to the men, for in a very short time it 
appeared among the female prisoners, who were entirely 
separated from, and had no direct comnmnieation with, the 
males ; but a woman, named Anna Maria Hefer, washed 
Grassl's clothes, and she was the first to be attacked among 
the women. No efficient disinfectants were used. About 
the same time another Bavarian prisoner was taken from 
Munich to Kaisheim ; he did not sicken for twenty-two 
days, and then died of cholera in seven hours. Disinfec- 
tants were thoroughly employed, and the disease was con- 
fined to this one case. Dr. Sayre asserts that in 1849, the 
epidemic in New York did not originate in Baxter street, but 
proceeded from an infected person who escaped from quaran- 
tine, and I have heard of two persons in the first stage of chol- 
era who escaped quarantine inspection this year. Dr. Atlee 
of Pennsylvania, asserts that one day in 1854, a car load of 
emigrants came from Philadelphia, to Columbia, Pennsylvania ; 
two or three of the passengers ill of cholera were put out on 
the platform at the railroad station ; four gentlemen seeing 
them there at the point of death, carried them to a shed and 
waited upon them ; in forty-eight hours not one of these was 
living, and in two or three days more, cholera prevailed exten- 
sively in Columbia. A few days after the outbreak in Colum- 
bia, an emigrant reached Lancaster, ill with cholerine ; shortly 
after two or three cases occurred in Lancaster. The same 
train carried the cholera to Pittsburgh. Dr. C. A. Lee reports 
the case of a gentleman who had been exposed to cholera in 
Buffalo in 1832, returned to his home at Mount Washington, 
Massachusetts, one thousand five hundred feet above the 



56 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

ocean, and died there ; of eight neighbors who nursed him, six 
were attacked and four died ; there were no other cases with- 
in fifty miles, and there seems to be no doubt the gentleman 
brought it with him, and distributed it to his friends. From 
similar and other cases, Dr. Niemeyer has come to the follow- 
ing conclusions : 1st. That cholera properly belongs neither 
to the class of contagious, nor to that of non-contagious dis- 
eases. 2d. While it is certain that cholera is often not com- 
municated directly from one person to another, even under 
circumstances of the greatest intimacy ; on the other hand, it 
is equally evident that it is spread only by patients afflicted 
with the disease. 3d. The disorder is propagated by the evacu- 
ations of individuals infected with cholera, 'probably in all, 
certainly in most cases. 4th. By means of one infected per- 
son, in whom the disease has manifested itself only by a 
seemingly insignificant diarrhoea, cholera can be conveyed to 
distant and hitherto healthy localities. 5th. This person may 
travel on and recover without further serious development of 
the disease in himself, but he may have left behind him in 
several or many waterclosets, a substance which may give rise 
to most deadly epidemics. It is thus no longer inexplicable 
why the cholera in its wanderings takes no defined course 
at times, but spreads now with the wind, and now against it : 
how it always follows routes of travel, and since the building 
of steamboats and railroads, has been able to spread more 
quickly than before ; why it follows only one or a few 
tracks across the ocean, but takes a hundred roads on land. 
Although it should have been evident many years ago, the 
portentous fact now stands out more prominently this year 
than ever before, that a great length of time may elapse be- 
tween the departure of passengers by ship,' wagon, or rail, 



DISTRIBUTION BY INDIVIDUALS. 51 

and the outbreak of cholera. In May, 1854, the epidemic 
broke out in Chicago and Detroit before it did in New York, 
where the cholera subjects landed. Many emigrants passed 
through New York, from infected ships, and were in passably 
good health at the time. Detroit and Chicago are in the line of 
the principal emigrant travel ; cholera had been in neither city 
since 1849, and none but emigrants from infected ports in 
Europe, and from infected ships at New York, were attacked 
at first. It is evident that some of them must have had 
cholera-diarrhoea, or cholerine, or carried about with them in 
their clothing and baggage a poison capable of regenerating 
itself and spreading abroad an influence that produced a 
general epidemic in the warm months. On board the New 
York and Swanton, in 1849, we have seen that the disease de- 
layed its outbreak for sixteen and twenty-six days after the 
sailing of these vessels. As early as 1853, Pettenkofer 
proved that the period of incubation might be extended to 
twenty-one days. Finally, it is well known that cholera has 
lingered in South G-ermany, Saxony, and along the Rhine, dur- 
ing the last winter ; thence infected emigrants were brought 
by rail and steamboat, to be shipped from Rotterdam to 
Hull, on the east coast of England, then conveyed by rail 
to Liverpool, and reshipped by the England, Virginia, Helve- 
tia, and other vessels to New York. Cases of cholera have 
already occurred at Bristol, Hull, and Liverpool, and the Eng- 
lish authorities are at last becoming painfully aware of the 
comparatively great length of time which can elapse between 
the departure of infected persons and things from the con- 
tinent, and the outbreak of cholera in England, or at sea. De- 
pots of cholera are now established at Rotterdam and Ant- 
werp, for on the Helvetia, which was sent back to Liverpool, all 

4 



58 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

the earliest cases are found to have been Dutch, not Germans, 
as their names, Evert de Boer, Peter Relpet, Neisen Gow, 
Coserline Bosake, undoubtedly prove. But there can be no 
doubt that the German emigrants who have been pouring 
through Rotterdam for nearly a year, originally brought the 
disease there. Since writing the above we learn that there 
have been 180 cases and 84 deaths at Antwerp ; 724 cases and 
431 deaths at Leyden ; 706 cases and 433 deaths in Rotterdam ; 
305 cases and 169 deaths at Utrecht ; in all, up June 13th, 
there have been 2,449 cases and 1,438 deaths in Holland. 
In Prussia it has declared itself in Berlin, Stettin, and seven 
or eight other towns. In France, at Amiens and Nantes. 
The caravans to Mecca have suffered much more severely this 
year than in 1865. 

(e.) DISTRIBUTION BY CLOTHES. 

After cholera matter has passed into the dried state, healthy 
men may carry it about in their baggage. Numerous and 
well-authenticated examples of this have been published, but 
the most extraordinary instance of the conveyance of cholera- 
vapor, or " cholera-dust," was furnished by the postal depart- 
ment at Marseilles, in 1865. The clerk who opened the 
despatches from the East, fell sick, with cholerine, another was 
put in his place, and the same effect followed up to the fifth. 
Of nine clerks in the bureau of arrival, eight were taken sick, 
and one died ; of twenty-two clerks in the bureau of depar- 
ture, there was not one case of sickness. In 1848, two vessels, 
the S wanton and the New York, left Havre, the one on the 
31st of October, the other on November 9th ; the one destined 
for New Orleans, the other for New York. Both vessels car- 
ried a large number of German emigrants. On the one, cholera 



DISTRIBUTION BY CLOTHES. 59 

appeared when sixteen days out ; on the other, in twenty-six 
days ; or, nearly on the same day in the two vessels, which at 
that time were one thousand miles apart ; the one in a low, 
the other in a high latitude. Some days before the outbreak 
on the New York, a very cold wind sat in, and there was a 
general ransacking among the baggage for warm clothing. 
On board the S wanton, just before the occurrence of the epi- 
demic, the weather was excessively warm, and the passengers 
searched for lighter clothing, and also rummaged their baggage. 
In both vessels there were passengers who had left infected 
places, and Dr. Clark infers that it is far more probable 
that the poison was carried in their baggage, than to sup- 
pose that two different atmospheric currents of cholera struck 
these two vessels a thousand miles apart. As regards 
the ship New York our information is minute. Among the 
passengers were a number of German emigrants who came 
from a place where cholera prevailed. One of them had a 
chest of clothing that belonged to a person who had died of 
cholera. Near Cape Sable the weather became cold and 
boisterous ; the chest was opened and the clothing used ; by 
the 22d of November five persons died of cholera on ship- 
board, and twelve were landed sick with it at the Staten Island 
Quarantine. — In 1854, cholera passengers came to the vicinity 
of Lancaster, Pennsylvania ; their clothes were sent to a high 
and healthy location at Lancaster ; the relatives, who washed 
these articles, died of cholera. A sailor died in Europe of 
cholera in 1832 ; a chest containing his clothing was sent home 
to a small village in Maine, and was opened on arrival ; the 
inmates of the house were suddenly seized with cholera and 
some of them died. The venerable Dr. Mussy, and Dr. 
Reacle are responsible for the above. — At G-uadaloupe, in 1865, 



60 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

the whole country became infected from clothing which had 
been sent ashore from a Marseilles ship to be washed ; and 
10,806 died out of a population of 149,107. — Vomero, one of 
the most considerable heights at the back of Naples, is the 
residence of a great number of laundresses, where a large 
quantity of clothing is washed. Nineteen of these poor women 
were attacked in 1865, and five died. The height and healthy 
air of the Yomero seemed to preclude the possibility of 
cholera ascending to it, but it was discovered that the linen 
of some who had died, or been attacked by the malady, had 
been sent up there to be^cleansed. A man who had recovered 
from cholera in 1865, sent his clothing to be washed in his 
native town of Rovegno, where no other cases of cholera oc- 
curred, except those of three women in his family who 
washed the clothing, all of whom died. A peasant perished 
in 1865 of cholera, not far from Marseilles, in an isolated 
place and his wife also. He had not visited Marseilles where 
the cholera prevailed, but his wife was a laundress and had 
received a bundle of linen from a person recently arrived from 
Egypt. The husband opened the bundle and unfolded all the 
pieces, which were denied with cholera discharges. We may 
almost agree with Dr. Marsden, of Canada, that all clothing of 
cholera patients should be destroyed. 

(/.) DISTRIBUTION BY MASSES OF FILTH. 

Accumulations of offal of many kinds may excite disease 
similar to Asiatic cholera, but cannot originate the real mal- 
ady unless true cholera filth has been introduced among them. 
There can be no question that the carelessness with which 
cholera evacuations are emptied into common privies, gutters, 
sewers, or upon heaps of manure, greatly promotes the sudden 



DISTRIBUTION BY MASSES OF FILTH. 61 

and rapid extension of the disease, and causes most violent 
and fatal epidemics. There can be as little doubt that many 
of these disgusting masses are quickly converted by a species 
of fermentation into huge quantities of "cholera matter." 
During the Crimean war, in 1854 and 1855, the French troops, 
who came from Algeria, where cholera was devastating the 
country, had scarcely disembarked at Gallipolis, when the dis- 
ease broke out among the people ; thence it followed the 
French to Varna, where it decimated the inhabitants ; then 
almost subsided. But immediately after the battle of the 
Alma, owing, it is believed, to the army halting for two days 
on the field, where hundreds of putrid carcasses of horses were 
scattered about, and the surface of the ground was polluted 
with ordure, from its occupation by the Kussians, cholera, 
which had previously been in abeyance, increased with great 
rapidity ; especially as the troops were greatly fatigued, their 
food indifferent, and the water scanty. From the Alma it was 
carried to the allied camps before Sebastopol, and caused great 
losses of men. Both the French and English fleets were also 
seriously affected. — At the outbreak of the disease in Wheel- 
ing, in the spring of 1833, the market-place was in a state of 
unprecedented filth ; the mud, the sweepings of the market, 
and other impurities had accumulated to the depth of several 
inches over the whole square. Hard rains, succeeded by a 
hot sun, had beaten down the dirty mass and baked its surface 
into a firm, dry crust. A meeting of the common council was 
called to determine what should be done with this immense 
accumulation of filth, and the physicians who were consulted, 
advised that it should remain undisturbed until the disappear- 
ance of the epidemic. But this advice was disregarded, and 
the dirt was at once gathered into heaps and carted to the 



62 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

edge of the river bank, a short distance off. The wind at the 
time blew directly in a line from the pile of dirt to a thickly 
settled part of the town ; and between midnight and daylight 
of the next morning, nearly every member of two families, 
living in the house nearest to the new heap of filth was seized 
with cholera, and not less than three or four died. Other 
persons in adjoining houses, and in dwellings in the same 
row on the opposite side of the street, were attacked at nearly 
the same time ; while all the houses fronting on the market 
square became the centre of a most fearful mortality. These 
few days constituted the greatest period of terror experienced 
during the epidemic in Wheeling, and Houston says the cause 
was too palpable not to be recognized by every one., — At 
Wakefield in England there are three prisons in one enclosure. 
One of these is near a sluggish stream on flat and marshy ground ; 
the sewers of the prison run into it, and the water from the 
stream is pushed back at times into the drains, and the soil 
thus often becomes infiltrated with noxious fluids. The venti- 
lation was also imperfect in this building. In the other two 
prisons the opposite condition prevailed ; the ventilation was 
good, and the drains led outside the grounds. Cholera prevail- 
ed extensively in the first-mentioned establishment, and not in 
the latter ; hence whatever be the cause of cholera, it is inten- 
sified and multiplied by insalubrious and foul emanations. — In 
1849, cholera raged to an almost exterminating extent, in Reed 
street, Philadelphia, from the east side of Front street down to 
the Delaware. The dwellings were well built, and well venti- 
lated, but a few yards only from the door of the last of these 
houses, the Reed-street culvert emptied its foul matter, and at 
its mouth was a morass of many acres, which at high tide was 
covered with water, and at low tide exposed to the rays of the 



DISTRIBUTION BY SOIL. 63 

sun. The sewer drained a distance of ten squares or about 
half a mile ; the county prison was cleared, as it is now, by 
this drain, of its entire filth, that of water closets included. 
The feculence which passed through this culvert was poured 
out on the marsh, underwent a festering putrefaction, and 
generated an atmosphere which had much to do in increasing 
the excessive mortality which marked the epidemic at this 
spot. These foul gases did not originate the cholera, but 
greatly intensified it in 1849. But in 1854, the culvert was 
extended to low-water mark, the morass was filled up and the 
drainage made complete ; and Reed street, in the epidemic 
of that year, did not suffer more than other parts of the city. — 
The western side of Beyroot is usually more healthy than the 
eastern, but, in 1855, the refuse excrements of the city were 
transferred there ; the cesspools of Beyroot run from the houses 
into receptacles in the streets, and their deposits are removed 
by a class of men called " zibbals," who carry away the filth in 
large panniers on the backs of donkeys to the dumping 
ground. Nearly all these men died of cholera, which also 
prevailed with much greater violence on the west side of the 
city, than on the east, which is low, marshy, the abode of 
fevers, and generally more unhealthful. 

(g.) DISTRIBUTION BY SOIL. 

Pettenkofer, of Munich, has paid much attention to the char- 
acter of the soil and the quantity and quality of sub-soil water 
which favor the development of cholera ; but, with little prac- 
tical result, if one can form a judgment, after carefully peru- 
sing his work, twice, in the original text. He concludes that 
cholera is propagated by human intercourse, and never with- 
out this ; not by contact with diseased persons, or their ex- 



64 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

cretions ; but by means of certain changes which the latter 
undergo after they have penetrated beneath the ground, 
when the soil is light and porous, i. e., permeable to air and 
water ; especially of sub-soil water, already impregnated with 
the products of organic decomposition, of excrementitious 
or faecal origin, is present within a certain distance of the 
surface, say, within five or fifty feet. This filthy sub-soil 
water beneath habitations he regards as far more injurious 
than that of more or less distant marshes, or low banks of 
rivers. The germs of cholera are supposed to be contained in 
the discharges of cholera patients, but these do not become 
poisonous so as to reproduce the disease in others until they 
have penetrated through the earth down to the sub-soil water. 
The nearer this sub-soil water lies to the surface, and the more 
it is contaminated, previously, by drainage from cess-pools, 
sewers, privies, middens, &c, the more rapid and extensive 
will be the reproduction of cholera. There may be some little 
truth in this ; but soil or earth is the best disinfectant, and 
when rain is poured copiously upon, and sinks down into it, 
it carries oxygen and dissolved air with it, and begins an 
action so extensive, that by it, we may say, nearly all the puri- 
fication of the world is performed. But if rain falls and re- 
mains on or near the surface, it soon loses its oxygen, purifica- 
tion ceases, and vapors arising carry up some of the injuri- 
ous gases with it. This is the case with marsh miasm ; and 
if water does not flow freely beneath the soil by means of 
natural or artificial drains, the earth will not destroy the poi- 
son, which will be liberated in full strength when the ground 
is turned up. Hence, clay bottoms and rocks a small distance 
beneath the surface may retain moisture enough to cause dis- 
ease ; but light porous soils will prevent it. The principal 



DISTRIBUTION BY SOIL. 65 

proof which Pettenkofer produces in favor of his theory, is 
the freedom of the city of Wurzburg from cholera, which 
never has been able to attain a foothold there. Wurzbiirg lies 
high on a hill, all the sewers are hewn out of solid rock, or 
built of water-tight masonry, and run from ten to seventeen 
feet below the surface. The privies and their connections 
with the sewers are built of stone ; much of the water which 
falls on the roofs of houses is conducted down into the privies 
and flushes them into the sewers. The drains all empty into 
the river Maine, which has rocky banks, at least ten feet high, 
and its stream is rapid. Hence no impurity remains in houses 
or streets ; all is carried off by the river. The court-yards of 
the houses are paved with flagging ; hence nothing soaks into 
the earth from them. Of course, Wurzburg remains and will 
remain free from cholera ; it is a veritable place of refuge 
from it. Of all other cities, where Pettenkofer dwells about 
soil and sub-soil water, we have a record of disgusting surface 
filth ; foul, unpaved court-yards ; low grounds, saturated with 
offensive drainage from above ; offensive privies, unsupplied 
with water ; noisome drains running directly under the side- 
walks, and only scantily covered with loose boards; filthy 
" street-side conveniences ;" of manure heaps in back yards, 
where human ordure is cast from numerous houses which have 
no privies at all ; and of the general use of wooden tubs for 
water-closets. If these feculent things were rectified, soil and 
sub-soil water might be safely ignored ; it is scarcely neces- 
sary to look under the earth for minor evils, when such abom- 
inable nuisances obtrude on the surface and offend both eyes 
and nose at every step and breath. 

I feel no inclination to close this chapter without some no- 
tice of the strongest arguments of those who maintain differ- 

4* 



66 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

ent views ; and will at once give several in addition. 1st. As 
regards the diffusion of cholera by the air, I call attention to 
the fact, that a putrid organic liquid can be obtained from the 
atmosphere of an unclean place, by passing it through a tube 
artificially cooled. The same may well happen with the filthy 
air of Bengal and other cholera haunts. But gases soon be- 
come diluted by mixture with air, and harmless. Marsh 
miasm which cannot enter the closed windows of one side 
of the house, may become so weak before it can creep around 
to the other, where the windows are open, that no injury 
ensues. 2d. A heavy fall of rain often stops cholera, and we 
know that rain thoroughly washes the air of all its impurities. 
3d. A violent thunder-storm also prevents cholera, and we 
know that lightning absolutely seems to burn up all impurities 
of the air, as flax is burnt in fire. Still, I feel confident that 
the poison of cholera originates from filthy men and places on 
the surface of the earth, and that cleanliness and disinfection 
will prevent all contamination of the atmosphere ; and that 
even if cholera be introduced into a place, cleanliness and 
disinfection will check it promptly. 4th. Dr. Yandeveer, in 
his account of the Franklin street cholera hospital, says that 
each ward, twenty-five feet by thirty, generally contained 
twenty-five patients. Physicians, nurses, and attendants, to 
the number of twenty, occupied adjoining rooms, with free 
communication and doors frequently open. Post-mortem ex- 
aminations, to the number of seventy-eight, were made, and 
the hands of the physicians were freely bathed in the cholera 
fluids ; the dead, for want of rapid transportation, were some- 
times piled in coffins, one on top of the other, to the number 
of ten or twelve. Yet only one of the physicians and nurses 
was attacked with cholera. But in the recent epidemic at 



ARGUMENTS AGAINST CONTAGION. 6*1 

Ancona, fourteen physicians lost their lives, and the Sisters of 
Charity were decimated. 5th. Great stress is laid upon the fact, 
that a man in Munich, while in a state of intoxication, drank 
a large beerglassful of the rice-water-vomit of a cholera pa- 
tient without subsequent injury ; and that some of the physi- 
cians of Munich freely tasted, and even swallowed, cholera 
discharges with like impunity. But, there is a well-authenti- 
cated case in which a Parisian dog devoured a large quantity 
of the alvine dejections of a cholera patient, and died with all 
the symptoms of the disease ; and Dr. Robin has injected 
rice-water-vomits and the thinner portions of the blood of 
cholera patients into the windpipes of healthy dogs, and found 
them to produce vomiting, liquid evacuations, chills, and 
speedy death. 6fch. Persons have slept in the beds, and 
worn the clothes previously used by cholera patients, and 
even suffered agonies of childish fear for many weeks subse- 
quently, and yet have not contracted the disease ; others have 
died from similar imprudence or folly. From eighty-four 
communications about washerwomen, Bally and Gull con- 
cluded that they were not much more subject to the disease 
than others. We should recollect, in this connection, that the 
number of careful and cleanly persons liable to cholera is 
always very small ; it has been variously estimated from 
thirty-seven to sixty-one, at the lowest, and five hundred and 
thirty-five, in ten thousand, at the highest. The susceptibility 
varies so much, that one may die from eating a few cherries ; 
on the other hand, during the last epidemic, in a small town 
in Kentucky, nine young men employed themselves in nursing 
the sick and burying the dead, and as melons were in season 
and abundant, they all ate freely of them the whole time, and 
none of them suffered with any symptom of the disease, 



68 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

although a large number of the inhabitants were attacked. 
Dr. Salisbury even thinks that cider, sulphur-water, and cer- 
tain classes of ripe fruit and vegetables, are preventives of 
epidemic cholera. Again, Dr. Houston, who does not believe 
in the communicability of cholera, cites his experience at 
Bridgeport, near Wheeling ; it contained only two or three 
hundred inhabitants, was situated on an island ; but more or 
less communication was kept up with Wheeling by means of 
ferry-boats, and the place was very filthy. The disease com- 
menced in Wheeling about the 15th of May, and did not ap - 
pear in Bridgeport until the last week in June, or, in about 
five weeks ; then it broke out in the night, and in thirty-six 
hours not less than twenty-two of the inhabitants had fallen 
its victims. But, cholera is always preceded by diarrhoea 
and cholerine, and it may be days or weeks before real cases 
of cholera show themselves. Again, in the Massachusetts 
state-prison, in 1832, the first case of cholera occurred in a 
man under solitary confinement ; in the course of an hour 
four more were attacked in different remote parts of the 
prison, and in the space of forty-eight hours, two hundred 
and five inmates of the building had the disease. It is said, 
triumphantly, " This certainly does not look like contagion." 
But it does. Cholerine had certainly been at work in that 
prison, silently but efficiently, until an explosion took place. 
I have intentionally cited the apparently sudden outbreak in 
Constantinople in 1865, but in every case it was traced to im- 
portation ; and excessive filth furnished the other factor of a 
sudden outbreak. In proof of the above, it is sufficient to 
cite the conclusions of Jules Guerin, which are now generally 
adopted by the profession, to prove that the causes of cholera 
must have been at work in Bridgeport and in the Massachu- 



ARGUMENTS AGAINST CONTAGION. 69 

setts state-prison long before the outbreak, and that the per- 
sons who imported it had escaped observation. Previous to 
1832, it was supposed that cholera attacked its victims in a 
very sudden manner ; but Jules Guerin first noticed that most 
of the cholera subjects had been laboring for several days, or 
even weeks, under a disturbed condition of the digestive 
organs, which did not appear sufficiently serious to deserve 
careful attention. Some were so careless upon this point, 
that they could only give a satisfactory answer after .having 
been questioned three or four times. Of six hundred patients 
five hundred and forty had shown symptoms of cholerine, or 
premonitory diarrhoea ; of five hundred other subjects, almost 
all had been previously attacked by choleraic diarrhoea of ten 
or twelve days' duration ; and the rice-water discharges were 
always preceded by others of a different, though unhealthy 
character. Of three thousand nine hundred and two addi- 
tional cases, not one was found without prodromic diarrhoea ; 
of one hundred and forty-two more, there were only six with- 
out preceding symptoms ; in ninety-five other cases, the diar- 
rhoea had lasted two, three, four, and even a greater number of 
days ; of nine hundred and seventy-four cholera patients, 
seven hundred and forty had been attacked with premoni- 
tory diarrhoea, and the rest were exempt, or unable to 
give exact evidence. Jackson's case, in which the disease 
is stated to have suddenly occurred in a neighborhood, 
twenty-six miles from Philadelphia, and where the only person 
who had been in the city when cholera prevailed, and who 
might be supposed to have carried the contagion, escaped, 
proves nothing ; except, that this or some other person doubt- 
less did bring the disorder, in the shape of cholerine, and that 
other more susceptible individuals suffered far more severely 



70 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

than the one who imported it. We all know what severe at- 
tacks of scarlet fever and measles may follow exposure to 
persons who have either been very slightly sick themselves, 
or have apparently entirely recovered, so as to be able to go 
to business, school, or church. — Finally, the apparently sudden 
and extensive outbreak which cholera sometimes makes, does 
not accord, it is supposed by some, with the slow and gradual 
spread which the disease ought only to advance, if it arose by 
contact from person to person. But we have seen that the 
seeds of cholera are always sown slowly, although the outbreak 
may seem sudden. Besides, the communicability of the dis- 
ease does not correspond with the time when the dejections 
are voided ; but is only developed a few days subsequently, 
and seems to be exhausted at the end of fifteen to twenty-one 
days. This peculiarity has been traced to the fact that the 
rice-water discharges only become poisonous after a while ; 
for the first few days they are innocuous ; then, as decomposi- 
tion proceeds they become morbific, and capable of re-produ- 
cing the peculiar disease of which they were the product. 
And still more strangely, after a few days more, when decom- 
position has reached a farther stage, the contagious property 
of the evacuations cease. These great facts account for the 
impunity with which careful and cleanly persons may wait 
upon those sick with cholera ; for the mysterious and sudden 
outbreak of the disease, and for its equally sudden subsi- 
dence. These points have been proved, in the following inge- 
nious way : pieces of filtering paper, soaked in the rice-water 
discharges have been given to mice, mixed with their food, 
and it was found that papers steeped in the very recent, and 
others dipped in the older discharges, proved alike harmless. 
But of thirty-four mice that ate papers impregnated with excre- 



ARGUMENTS AGAINST CONTAGION. tl 

tse of an intermediate date, thirty became sick, and twelve died ; 
while the symptoms and appearances noticed after death, are 
declared to have been similar to those that are proper to 
cholera as it is seen in the human subject. 

The sudden cessation of cholera is often cited as a proof 
that it depends, not on contagion, but upon some general in- 
fluence in the air, which is blown upon us like a whirlwind, 
rages as destructively, and ceases as suddenly. But, if the 
process by which cholera discharges become poisonous ceases 
spontaneously in a few days or weeks, the epidemic must 
die out in the places where it first originated as suddenly 
as it commenced, although it may spread to other parts of the 
same city or country. 



72 ASIATIC^ HOLERA. 

NATURE. 

It may reasonably be inferred, from all that has gone before, 
that the poison of cholera is somewhat similar to that which 
arises from offensive sewers and privies, and to which night- 
scavengers are subject until they become acclimated. In fact, 
it somewhat resembles the so-called septic cholera, which was 
formerly best seem in the new visitants to the old-fashioned, 
badly ventilated and equipped dissecting rooms. In former 
times very few medical students escaped ; the symptoms were 
a profuse diarrhoea with but little pain, followed by quick ex- 
haustion ; the discharges were thin, like dirty soap-water, 
without flocculi, shreds, or bile ; there was some nausea, but 
not often severe vomiting. Or, cholera is comparable to the 
sewer-disease, of which cases enough are to be found in this 
city, but of which Naples sometimes furnishes pregnant ex- 
amples. In Naples, the public drains empty themselves on 
the sands in front of the Villa Reale, which is the most fash- 
ionable promenade ; heavy rains often flood the streets and 
flush the sewers and sluices of their accumulated abominations 
down to the sands and the sea. The waves and surf frequently 
drive these back, again and again, on the shore ; while the 
winds rushing up the open culverts force back the fetid gases 
through the rain openings in the street, and through the open 
water-closets into the houses, so that the smell through the 
entire lower part of the city is often awful, and a considerable 
portion of the population may be suddenly affected with nau- 
sea, colic, diarrhoea, and even dysentery. — Watson records the 
sudden outbreak of a violent disorder, a sort of cholera, among 
the boys in a large school at Glapham ; nearly a score of 
them were all at once attacked with the most alarming symp- 



NATURE. T3 

toms, and two of them died, in consequence of the opening of 
an old cesspool behind the house, and the distribution of its 
foul contents over a garden adjoining their play-ground. Sub- 
sequently two hundred and ten out of four hundred and twenty 
inmates were affected, and it was found that the drainage 
of the building was imperfect, the sinks and water-closets 
not properly trapped, and an old drain under the house was 
choked. It was then recollected that there had been a strong 
sewage smell in some of the rooms before the outbreak. The 
first case reported as Asiatic cholera this year (1866) in New 
York was doubtless one of septic cholera. We learn that 
Mrs. Jenkins, aged thirty-five, had been engaged for some days, 
and at the time of her attack, in removing the contents of an 
old privy and spreading them as a fertilizer upon a lot of 
ground, in order to raise a crop of potatoes. She sickened 
May 1st, at ten a. m., and died in twenty hours ; the post-mor- 
tem examination revealed lesions similar to those of Asiatic 
cholera. Although the cellar of the house was partially filled 
with stagnant water, and the remainder of the building was 
filthy, and four other families lived in it, no one else sickened 
or died ; showing that it required the concentrated power of 
the faecal emanations to produce a fatal attack. 

Dr. Read, of Boston, believes that there are three diseases, 
or varieties of cholera, very much resembling each other, each 
of them capable of producing a fatal result, but radically dif- 
ferent. All of them are characterized by excessive action 
of the alimentary canal, and in proportion as the attacks 
increase in intensity, may bring out the peculiar features of 
collapse, viz., the cold, clammy, wet, blue skin ; the pinched 
features ; husky and often sepulchral voice, and the cramps in 
the limbs. They are each dependent on different and peculiar 



14 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

exciting causes. The first, is the septic cholera, or that arising 
from exposure to poisonous gases ; second, common cholera, 
or cliolera morbus, or endemic hepatic cholera ; and third, the 
epidemic-intestinal, or true Asiatic cholera. The first, he as- 
sumes, affects those who are exposed to animal effluvia, whether 
from dissecting-rooms, or abattoirs, offensive privies and sew- 
ers, or noxious gases in general. The second arises from a 
bilious condition ; or use of improper 'food in the summer 
time, such as unripe melons, cucumbers, cherries, spoiled 
crabs, lobsters, fish, &c. ; or from sudden changes of tempera- 
ture, causing a check of perspiration ; or frequently from all 
these causes combined. These two are not contagious in 
the slightest degree, nor capable of being generated ex- 
cept by the operation of the original exciting causes. 
In the case of Mrs. Jenkins, in New York, he also sees no 
reasons for looking beyond septic cholera, for the cause of 
sickness and death, for she was attacked as many persons 
engaged in removing night-soil are, when they first begin 
this occupation and, are not inured to the sickening, filthy 
odors which then assail them. In the Home for Aged Females 
in Boston, twenty-seven of the inmates were attacked in 
1865, in one night, with septic cholera, but only one died. 
In Edinburgh this form of cholera is not uncommon ; the 
water supply is good, and brought from a distance in pipes, 
and not contaminated by sewage ; wells and pumps are not 
used. The street dirt, and all that is offensive is removed, 
once or twice daily, by an efficient corps of scavengers, so 
that large profits are realized by the sale of street manure. 
But the sewerage is inadequate, and the water-closets, 
except a few that are well constructed and trapped, are often 
noxious and most disgusting nuisances, and insidious sources 



CHOLERA MORBUS. T5 

of disease, owing to the ascent of noxious gases from the 
sewers, for which they act as ventilators. This is prevented, 
in some cases, by conducting pipes from below the traps 
up above the roofs of the houses. Dr. Eead has neglected 
to include cholera infantum among the diseases which re- 
semble, and may be suddenly changed into, true cholera. It 
is well known that in " cholera times" the first cases are often 
noticed among infants. In fact, the name of cholera is 
given to any complaint in which the prominent characters are 
simultaneous and repeated vomiting and purging, with painful 
spasms of the stomach and bowels, and occasional cramps of 
the external muscles ; and true Asiatic cholera may ally itself 
to all these. Five varieties have been observed, so different 
in the circumstances of their occurrence, as well as in their 
symptoms, progress, and results, as to merit distinct con- 
sideration. These are: first, cholera morbus; second, septic 
cholera; third, bilious cholera; fourth, cholera infantum; 
and fifth, Asiatic cholera. 

1. CHOLERA MORBUS. 

Hot weather, long continued, strongly predisposes the 
system to cholera morbus, and may itself occasion the dis- 
ease, without any other cause. Wood says the same may 
be said of marsh miasmata, for it often precedes the break- 
ing out of miasmatic fevers, as if from the operation of the 
same cause. Most commonly, however, the immediate at- 
tack is brought on by some well-known exciting cause, such 
as exposure to cold when the body is heated and per- 
spiring ; the use of certain indigestible and irritating articles 
of food or drink, such as cucumbers, melons, various unripe 
fruits, fat pork, lobsters, crabs, sour and incompletely fer- 



16 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

mented liquors, putrid water, excesses at table, and the use of 
ice or very cold drinks in excess. Wood has seen the 
operation of calomel in some instances so exactly like cholera 
morbus, that the most experienced physician could scarcely 
distinguish them. In cholera morbus the pulse is usually 
feeble, countenance pale and shrunken, skin cool and damp, 
urine scanty or suppressed; and in some cases there are 
often very painful cramps of the muscles of the abdomen 
and legs. The vomiting and purging may become almost in- 
cessant, extremities cold, and extreme exhaustion occur. 
The vomits may become colorless after a while, but often 
are sour or acrid. In some instances, when all the indigesti- 
ble and ordinary foecal and biliary matters have passed off, 
the evacuations may become colorless or whitish, as in epi- 
demic cholera. When true cholera prevails, this disease may 
be rapidly transformed into it. Lankester thinks that a certain 
amount of the diarrhoea and cholera morbus of summer may 
be attributed to the decomposition of animal and vegetable 
matters, which are directly taken into the stomach in the 
shape of stale, spoiled, or partly decomposed vegetables and 
meats. They cause a like corruption of the rest of the 
intestinal contents, and form a fit nidus for the development of 
true cholera. 

2. BILIOUS CHOLERA. 

Watson says, there is a complaint of which diarrhoea is one 
prominent symptom, but which is something more than mere 
diarrhoea ; it occurs in England and in this country, more or 
less, every autumn or summer. It is rightly enough called 
cholera, for it is attended with, and consists mainly, of a re- 
markable flux of bile. The symptoms are vomiting and purg- 
ing of liquid matter, deeply tinged with and principally com- 



BILIOUS CHOLERA. tt 

posed of bile ; violent pains in the stomach and bowels ; 
cramps of the legs and abdominal muscles ; great depression of 
the vital power, and a tendency to syncope or collapse. The 
attack is generally sudden ; at first the contents of the alimen- 
tary canal are evacuated ; and then a quantity, an enormous 
quantity sometimes, of a turbid, yellowish, acrid fluid is ex- 
pelled with violence, both from the bowels and by vomiting. 
As the vomiting and purging go on, clonic spasms of the legs, 
especially of the calves, occur ; the surface of the belly is 
drawn up into knots and after a while the patient exhausted 
by the pain and spasms, and still more by the copious dis- 
charges, grows cold and faint. Actual syncope sometimes 
happens, and occasionally death, but rarely. 

3. CHOLERA INFANTUM. 

This disease occurs in all our largest cities, during the sea- 
son of greatest heat, attacking children between four and twenty 
months of age. The first symptom is usually a profuse diar- 
rhoea, the stools being very fluid, and generally of a very 
light color, though often curdled, or pale yellow or green. 
To the diarrhoea is soon added extreme irritability of the 
stomach. After a while the discharges are often composed 
entirely of a perfectly colorless and inodorous fluid, contain- 
ing minute mucous flocculi, and discharged without effort. It 
is produced by the action of a heated, impure, damp, and 
stagnant atmosphere, directly upon the lungs and blood, and 
indirectly upon the skin, and digestive mucous surface ; it 
becomes more frequent and fatal with the rise of the ther- 
mometer, and declines with the first appearance of cool 
weather in the autumn. The worst cases occur among the 
children of the poorer classes, inhabiting small, damp, and ill- 



18 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

ventilated houses, in narrow confined lanes, courts, and 
alleys, or in situations abounding with accumulations of filth. 
In all cases the cure will depend very much upon our ability 
to remove the patient from the influence of the impure, damp, 
and heated atmosphere, by which the disease is kept up. 

4. ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

Omitting for the present the consideration of cholerine, or 
premonitory diarrhoea, we turn our attention to the character- 
istic phenomena and the nature of Asiatic cholera. The 
choleraic diarrhoea is attended with very little pain, showing 
great torpor of the nerves ; soon the bowels act by the stimu- 
lus of distension alone, as there is a paralytic condition of 
their muscular coat, and the dejections become frequent and 
copious, and pass off in a full stream with very little effort. 
They quickly become watery and serous, and at last present 
that appearance which has by common consent been called 
rice-wetter. They resemble this more than anything else, and 
are composed exclusively of the serum or watery part of the 
blood, intermingled with an immense amount of epithelium 
and some flakes from the mucous membrane. 

After a shorter or longer period of diarrhoea, suddenly, with- 
out much nausea, vomiting commences, of a similar watery 
fluid to that discharged from the bowels. The skin also be- 
comes covered with a cold clammy sweat, which at times is 
very profuse. Condie justly remarks, that this copious per- 
spiration is generally not dwelt upon with sufficient emphasis 
for it is a source of great exhaustion ; it sets in early in 
the attack, and becomes excessive towards the close of fatal 
cases. 

In consequence of this drain of fluids from the system, in- 



ASIATIC CHOLERA. 19 

tense thirst is experienced, and seems to prevail in direct ratio 
to the quantity of watery fluid which has been poured out by 
the discharges, and to depend on them. It is based upon an 
instinctive desire and urgent demand for a supply of fluid to 
make up the waste and drain from the system. Condie has 
even known patients attempt to allay it by swallowing the 
fluids they had just before vomited, if they could get no other 
drink. 

The loss of fluids is so great that the whole body shrinks ; 
the features become contracted and pinched; the hands 
and feet are shrivelled, corrugated, and greatly shrunken, 
and lose at least one third of their bulk. 

When much serum has been poured out, the blood becomes 
so thick that it no longer traverses its accustomed rounds with 
facility, but collects in undue quantity in the right side of the 
heart, in the vena cava, in the portal and emulgent veins. In 
fact, the whole venous system is found turgid with black, co- 
agulated blood. In twenty cases in which cholera-blood 
was left to stand for some time, not one drop of serum sepa- 
rated from it. 

The thickness of the blood is such that it does not flow in the 
usual channels which expose so great a surface to the action 
of the air, throughout the minute and abundant capillaries of 
the lungs. Air enters the lungs, but respiration is labori- 
ous, and attended with a sense of suffocation from the changed 
condition of the blood, that resists the full vivifying influ- 
ence of the air upon it. Ultimately, the proper changes of 
the blood in the lungs, from merely being imperfectly effected, 
are entirely suspended ; and that portion which reaches the 
left or arterial side of the heart, becomes similar to that sent 
to the lungs from the right, or venous side. The propulsive 



80 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

power of the heart soon becomes enfeebled ; the general circu- 
lation almost suspended ; and the dark color of the blood pro- 
duces a blue or bronzed hue of those parts in which the thin- 
ness of the skin permits its color to be seen. 

The circulation being almost suspended, animal heat can no 
longer be generated in sufficient quantities, and the body be- 
comes not only blue, but cold. 

The most painful and distressing phenomena of this de- 
structive malady, viz., the cramps and spasms, are ushered in 
almost simultaneously with these profuse evacuations from 
the stomach, bowels, and skin, and apparently are intimately 
connected with them. At times a similar spasmodic irritation 
extends to the heart and arteries, and the pulse instead of be- 
coming soft and feeble, may be hard and wiry, while the heart 
struggles violently. 

Finally, collapse occurs ; the watery evacuations and spasms 
cease, and the patient lies indifferent, apathetic, fearless, and 
only craves for drink. 



PHYSIOLOGICAL THEORY. 81 



THEORIES. 

(a.) PHYSIOLOGICAL THEORY. 

Comparatively late discoveries in physiology make it quite 
plain how easily the immense quantities of fluid discharged in 
the evacuations of cholera can take place. The normal quan- 
tity of water poured out daily and hourly by the mucous mem- 
branes is very great. If we turn down the lower lip before a 
mirror, and wipe it quite dry, we may see and feel a number 
of seed-like little glands studding the surface all over. In a 
few moments each one of the protuberances will be headed by 
a tiny drop of dew, which grows rapidly larger, till, in a short 
time, the whole lip is covered with moisture as before. Reck- 
oning the extent of the gastro-intestinal mucous surface at 
twenty-four square feet, the square inch we were looking at 
must be multiplied by 3,456 to get a correct idea of this great 
secreting surface. The immense amount of water poured out 
daily, by the mucous membrane of the stomach and bowels, is 
not naturally destined to be wasted ; bat in cholera it is. In 
health we see how quickly it exudes, and we know by the 
amount of our fasces, in the normal state, that it does not natur- 
ally pass off by the bowels into which it is thrown. What 
becomes of the several gallons a-day which is secreted from 
this active source ? We know that however well the mucous 
membrane may be constructed for purposes of secretion, it is 
still better constructed for absorption ; that water, however 
quickly it is supplied, will be rapidly taken up, and is ab- 
sorbed, indeed, with a rapidity very closely proportioned to 
its quantity. The intestinal canal naturally drinks up not only 
the fluids which we swallow as food, but also those which it 

5 



82 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

pours out so copiously for its own digestive processes. What 
the amount of these is will best be seen by a tabular sketch of 
the probable (say maximum) quantities of each secretion 
poured out directly or indirectly from the gastro-intestinal 
mucous membrane. An adult man is calculated to secrete in 
twenty-four hours, weights approaching nearly to the under- 
mentioned : Of saliva, three to four pounds, avoirdupois ; of 
bile, three to four pounds ; of gastric juice, fourteen to six- 
teen pounds ; of pancreatic juice, half a pound ; of intestinal 
juice, half a pound; thus making a grand total of from twenty- 
one to twenty-five pounds of fluid ; of which only so much 
passes away from the bowels normally, as will prevent the 
faeces from becoming too solid. 

The clearest notion we can gain of the business performed 
by all this ten or twelve quarts of water which naturally ex- 
ude on the mucous membrane of the intestinal canal, and 
should be taken up by the same membrane again, is by view- 
ing it as a circulation. In health, it is constantly going its 
rounds like an endless chain, finding and taking up inside the 
solid structure of the body substances which ought to come 
out, and be got rid of ; and meeting in the alimentary canal 
with nutriment which the body wants, and conveying it in. In 
cholera this immense exudation takes place, but almost all ab- 
sorption is stopped ; consequently, profuse liquid, serous, or 
almost white discharges must occur. 

The appearances in the stomach and bowels after death are 
thought to accord with this view of the disease, The 
stomach often only presents a pale or yellowish appear- 
ance ; or scarcely any change, except, that it is somewhat 
contracted and thickened. The small intestines are fre- 
quently found pale and ©edematous. But the most common 



PHYSIOLOGICAL THEORY. 83 

alteration consist in an enlargement of the solitary glands, 
from a serous fluid or granular matter deposited in them. 
The epithelium which naturally covers the mucous mem- 
brane, is always found partially or wholly removed. These are 
justly regarded as the great pathological features of cholera. 
As the epithelium is everywhere remarkably endosmotic, 
the removal of so much of it must interfere greatly with 
absorption ; and as the villi are the principal agents of 
absorption of the nutritive elements resulting from the di- 
gestion of food, their functions must be much impeded by 
the removal of their covering epithelium. As the intes- 
tinal glands are greatly enlarged, they probably pour out 
a much greater quantity of fluid than natural. 

It is rational to suppose that all the essential elements of 
a true theory of cholera are contained in the above well- 
authenticated facts, and that all the phenomena of the dis- 
ease can be explained by them. Thus Dr. Snow has com- 
puted that, in a healthy adult of average size, it is only 
necessary that five pints of serous fluid should be poured 
out, in order to reduce the blood to the condition that 
obtains in the collapse of cholera. In the less acute cases, 
where the evacuations exceed the above quantity, he infers 
that some of the fluids drank pass off by the bowels ; or 
assumes correctly that absorption is not altogether sus- 
pended ; experiments having shown that absorption, although 
diminished in attack of cholera, does not always cease ; for 
iodide of potassium, administered during the algid stage, 
has sometimes been detected in the blood and urine. 

The indications of treatment, according to this view, are 
to use tonic astringents, especially iron alum, sulphate of 



84 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

iron, simple alum, gallic acid, muriate tincture of iron, elixir 
vitriol, sulphuric acid, &c. 

(b.) GLAND THEORY. 

As the solitary glands of the intestinal canal are very 
much enlarged in cholera, so as to be very distinct and 
prominent, causing the surface of the bowel to resemble 
a nutmeg-grater in roughness ; and as the glands of Peyer 
are also, in most cases, exceedingly distinct and conspicu- 
ous, so that the inner wall of the intestines seems fretted 
with separate or aggregated granular protuberances, Dr. 
Isaac Hayes has selected these facts for the formation of 
a theory of cholera. He thinks the first step in the dis- 
ease is an orgasm of these follicles ; they increase in size, 
and their secretions are augmented in the same way that 
that of the mammary glands is. He infers that this exag- 
gerated exudation from the follicles has been preceded by 
an active flux towards them, and by that state of turges- 
cence of the secretory organs which is an attendant upon 
most augmented exhalations. Thus is caused the serous 
diarrhoea, which is the first stage of cholera, and which 
quickly drains from the blood a large portion of its white 
fluid or serum, and the saline matter which it holds in 
solution. As soon as this has gone on for a while, the 
peculiar choleraic symptoms appear, such as debility, cold- 
ness of the extremities, feebleness of the pulse, and op- 
pressed respiration, which are the immediate results of all 
sudden losses of blood. Next, the blood, deprived of its 
serum by the profuse discharges from the bowels, becomes 
thickened, and in proportion as it is rendered viscid, the 
propulsive power of the heart is enfeebled, and the circu- 



ELIMINATION THEORY. 85 

latioxi is diminished. Less blood is carried to the lungs, 
and the respiration becomes embarrassed; the oxygen of 
the inspired air cannot effect those changes which it ordi- 
narily produces, and more carbonic acid is retained. Fi- 
nally, all the blood becomes venous, and the symptoms of 
cholera asphyxia arise. This view is almost as satisfactory 
as the physiological one we have already given. 

The indications of treatment, according to this theory — 
which is based on the well-known law, ubi irritatio, ibi 
fluxus — are to use sedative astringents, such as opium, acetate 
of lead, digitalis, &c. 

(c.) ELIMINATION THEOEY. 

Dr. George Johnson, and many other physicians, believe 
that the cholera stools contain some poisonous materials, by 
which the disease is not only multiplied in the human sys- 
tem, but can be communicated to others ; and assume that 
it is also probable that the discharges into the digestive canal, 
together with the vomiting and purging, are as much parts 
of the natural process of cure as is the eruption on the skin 
in small-pox. They oppose the commonly-received opinion 
that the worst symptoms of cholera are mainly due to the 
drain of serum from the blood by the vomiting and purging. 
They say if this theory be erroneous, it is of incalculable im- 
portance that it should be discarded ; for it is unquestionable 
that it has had an immense influence on the treatment of 
cholera, as well as on the estimate which men have formed 
of the effect of various modes of treatment. Let a practi- 
tioner be thoroughly persuaded that the essential cause of 
choleraic collapse is a drain of liquid from the blood, and it 
will be difficult to convince him that opium and astringents 



86 A SIATIC CHOLERA. 

can do harm, or that emetics or purgatives can do good. 
The symptoms of cholera result from a poison which may 
enter the blood either through the lungs, or by way of the 
gastro-intestinal canal, and its most constant and characteristic 
effect is to excite a copious excretion from the mucous mem- 
brane of the stomach and bowels. Vomiting and purging 
constitute the means by which the morbid particles are re- 
moved from the blood and alimentary canal. Hence the pro- 
cess of ehmination takes place by two successive stages. 
First, there is an excretion of fluid from the blood into the 
stomach and bowels ; and second, the morbid contents of these 
viscera are ejected by vomiting and purging. Johnson asks : 
Can we do anything to assist the natural process ? and answers, 
unquestionably we can, by emetics and purgatives. A purga- 
tive may be useful by removing two conditions which often 
obtain in cholera, viz., over distention of the bowels by liquid ; 
and an accumulation of offensive viscid and semi-solid secre- 
tions. 

Johnson gives mild emetics and copious draughts of plain 
or salt water ; but prefers castor oil as a .laxative, because he 
thinks the object of a purgative is not to remove the poison 
from the blood and increase excretion into the stomach and 
bowels ; but simply to expel the morbid secretions which 
have already been poured out into the alimentary canal. 
"Wilson prefers charcoal, from its controlling and corrective 
power over all ferments, acescent and putrefactive. He 
believes that foul, morbid fermentation in the stomach and 
bowels is one of the most constant attendants, and not the 
least of aggravating causes, in the progression of the disease ; 
for he invariably found, in post-mortem examinations, not- 
withstanding the gallons of watery fluid which had passed 



PARALYSIS THEORY. 81 

off, that the contents of the bowels were most offensively 
feculent. After using this remedy a few days, he gave a 
dose of oil, in order to remove the accumulated charcoal and 
the putrid matter it had absorbed ; for he found, until he did 
so, his cases of relapse were frequent, and sometimes fatal. 
Billings prefers epsom salts and tartar emetic ; Jephson, large 
doses of croton oil. The homoeopathists rely upon ipecac, 
tobacco, veratrum, hellebore, tartar emetic, mercury, &c. 

(d.) PARALYSIS THEORY. 

In many or most cases of cholera, the bowels are said to 
act one or more times largely, and then all power of absorp- 
tion from the stomach and bowels is supposed to be gooe. 
The vessels and nerves which preside over absorption are 
inferred to be paralyzed, and, by continuity, this paralytic 
condition is thought to extend to the ganglionic or great sym- 
pathetic nervous system, which governs and regulates capillary 
circulation everywhere, but more particularly in the alimen- 
tary canal. This paralysis of the nerves and capillaries al- 
lows the blood to become drained of its serum and saline 
particles, just as an exhausting perspiration occurs from a 
debilitated skin. 

When the poison of cholera first obtains entrance into the 
body by being inhaled into the air tubes, it is assumed that the 
great gastro-pulmonary or pneumo-gastric nerve becomes 
wholly or partially paralyzed. Then the sfer which is drawn 
into the lungs is expelled again in the same state in which it 
was taken in, except that it has been exposed for a short time 
to a moist animal surface ; the air remains cold, and there is 
no elimination of carbon from the lungs, so that this essential 
part of respiration is in abeyance ; little or no oxygen is in- 



88 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

troduced into the system, and the symptoms of asphyxia 
arise. The blood becomes black and venous, and the skin 
assumes a blue color, although the muscles of respiration con- 
tinue and even increase their action. The breathing is almost 
always doubled in frequency, rising from sixteen or eighteen 
to twenty-eight or thirty-four per minute ; still it is almost al- 
ways costal, and the oppression of the chest may be great. 

The indications of treatment, according to this theory, are 
to use tonics and stimulants, such as strychnine, nux vomica, 
veratrine, ammonia, camphor, phosphorus, phosphoric acid, al- 
coholic stimulants, quinine, &c. 

(e.) FIRST SPASM THEORY. 

This commences with the assumption that the cholera poison 
is generally inhaled from the atmosphere into the lungs, thence 
passes into the blood, and that it is irritant in its nature, as is 
shown by the painful cramps which it subsequently occasions 
in the muscular tissues. This poisoned blood excites spasmodic 
contraction of the muscular walls of the minute pulmonary 
arteries ; the effect of which is to diminish and, in fatal cases, 
entirely to arrest the flow of blood through the lungs. In the 
first and second stages of cholera, it is assumed, without suf- 
ficient proof, that there is a surprising contrast between the 
almost constant presence of an extremely anozmic or blood- 
less condition of the lungs, from which scarcely even a few 
drops of blood will flow when the tissue is cut, and the Jiyper- 
cemic or congested state of all other organs. The passage of 
blood through the lungs, from the right to the left side of the 
heart, is said to be in a greater or less degree impeded ; for, in 
the large majority of cases, in the earlier stages of cholera, 
the right side of the heart and the pulmonary arteries are 
filled, and sometimes distended with blood; while the left 



FIRST SPASM THEORY. 89 

cavities of the heart generally contain only a small quantity. 
The arteries are so empty that vessels of considerable size have 
been opened without the escape of blood, as has been done 
both to the temporal and brachial arteries during life. John- 
son thinks this condition of things arises not from arrest of 
blood in the capillaries, but from spasm in the branches of the 
pulmonary artery, before the capillaries are reached by the 
blood. He says, we know that the walls of the arteries are 
muscular, and have the power of contracting on their contents 
under the influence of a stimulus, such as cold, electricity, and 
mechanical irritation, and that no physiologist of the present 
day will deny that spasm of the arteries is as real a fact as 
spasm of the muscles. He assumes that arrest of the blood 
in its passage to the lungs is the true key to the pathology of 
choleraic collapse, and one which will account for all the most 
striking chemical phenomena of the disease in a simple yet 
complete manner, viz., for the imperfect aeration of the blood, 
the fall of temperature, the dark and thickened appearance of 
the blood, and the suppression of the bile and urine. He 
says it is obvious that the stream of blood from the pulmonary 
capillaries to the left side of the heart is the channel by which 
the supply of oxygen is introduced into the system ; and a 
great diminution in the volume of this will lessen the supply 
of oxygen in a corresponding degree. Again, the combustion 
of those constituents of the blood which are normally sub- 
jected to the action of oxygen will be diminished in propor- 
tion to the deficiency of that gas. The constituents of bile, 
urine, and carbonic acid, are all results of oxidation, and none 
of them can be formed without a large supply of oxygen ; 
hence suppression of bile and urine during the stage of col- 
lapse is a necessary consequence. The amount of carbonic 

5* 



90 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

acid expired during collapse is also much diminished; and, 
consequently, an excess is retained, not only in the lungs, but 
in the system in general. Plausible as this and the subsequent 
theory may appear at first sight, we can scarcely believe that 
they will be found consistent in all their parts, or to afford a 
a satisfactory explanation of the leading phenomena of cholera, 
or to serve as a safe basis for its rational and successful treat- 
ment. They seem to account for cholera asphyxia rather than 
the colliquative form, and are much less satisfactory than the 
physiological explanation. 

If this theory be true, I would suggest the use of conia, or 
the active principle of the conium maculatum, for it produces a 
rapidly-increasing paralysis, first of the voluntary, then of the 
respiratory muscles of the chest and abdomen, and finally, of 
the spinal marrow. Acetate of lead will probably prove the 
next most useful remedy. 

(/.) SECOND SPASM THEORY. 

Bell and Braithwaite adopt a somewhat different spasm 
theory. They think the subtile poison of cholera acts prima- 
rily through the blood, and specifically upon the pneumo-gastric 
nerve, and subsequently on the great sympathetic nerve, which 
supplies contractile power to the arteries, intestinal canal, 
and organs of respiration. A kind of tetanic contraction is pro- 
duced of all the arteries, thus emptying the contents of all the 
capillaries into the great central veins. Braithwaite says we 
all know how small a portion of stryclmine will act on the 
voluntary muscles, and asks why a similar effect should not be 
caused by the virulent poison of cholera, but on rather differ- 
ent parts of the nervous and muscular systems from those 
specifically acted upon by strychnine. He accounts for the 



SECOND SPASM THEORY. 91 

intestinal phenomena of cholera by assuming that the portal 
circulation is at first impeded by meeting the reflux current 
from the vena cava, and presently becomes reversed, so that the 
blood is forced back into the mesenteric veins, till it distends 
their extreme ramifications upon the mucous membrane of the 
bowels, where its watery portions find a species of vent, just as 
dropsy takes place from obstruction in the heart, liver, or kid- 
neys ;1 from this surface the repellant force squeezes out the 
serous or watery portion of the blood, carrying with it the mu- 
cous epithelium, thus constituting those serous or rice-water 
evacuations which are regarded as characteristic of cholera. 
These are declared not to be real secretions, but mechanical effu- 
sions or exudations, which are quite the reverse of vital actions. 
The kidneys also become mechanically congested, the return- 
ing current of blood from the kidneys is stopped, and a first 
effect of this is a cessation of the secretion of urine. The 
hepatic circulation is affected in like manner, thus suspending 
or impeding the secretion of bile. 

Bell assumes that the so-called collapse of cholera is differ- 
ent from the collapse of haemorrhage ; the first is active or 
dynamic, while the latter is passive or adynamic ; the pulse 
in haemorrhage becomes slower, softer, and feebler, till it 
ceases, but in cholera it is contracted, small, and wiry, as long 
as it can be felt. The heart in cholera is heard and felt to be 
struggling in an extraordinary state of excitement, and in the 
active endeavor to overcome spasmodic obstruction, it is found 
to be churning as if it would burst, causing a sound which it 
is difficult to describe, but which once heard can never be for- 
gotten. 

The first indication, according to this theory, is to bleed. 
When the sound and action of the heart convey the impres- 



92 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

sion that it is laboring hard with unabated vigor of reaction, 
Bell thinks the lancet cannot be nsed too promptly. But when 
the attack has lasted four or five hours, and the purging is less 
copious, and the heart, instead of keeping up a continuous 
struggle, appears to be roused up to reaction at intervals only, 
then withhold the lancet awhile. If there is a decided re- 
newal of distress, bleed again, till the thick tarry blood that at 
first could only be squeezed out and kneaded from the arm 
with difficulty, flows freely from the orifice and changes to a 
fair florid hue. Braithwaite relies mainly upon the inhalation 
of chloroform to overcome the spasm of the capillaries. 
Opium, assafoetida, and antispasmodics, belladonna, conium, and 
especially conia, should prove useful remedies. 

It seems perfectly transparent that Johnson, Bell, and Braith- 
waite, have mistaken the secondary spasm of the pulmonary 
arteries, vascular system in general, and of the heart, for a pri- 
mary disorder. (See page 80, line 12.) 

(g.) CONGESTION THEORY. 

George Hamilton infers that profound passive congestion is 
obviously present in nearly every violent attack, as is evident 
from the coldness of the extremities, ears, nose, and some- 
times of the tongue ; the purple color of these parts, and small 
feeble pulse. The congestion of cholera is of too much sig- 
nificance, he thinks, to attempt to sever its connection, how- 
ever obscure, with the exhausting serous discharges. As long 
as the heart, lungs, and spinal marrow, remain passively con- 
gested, so long must almost every portion of the organism 
partake of this condition. The blood in the arteries becomes 
almost identical in its dark and carbonized appearance with 
that contained in the veins. 



CONGESTION THEORY. 93 

The first indication is to produce reaction of the vascular 
system, restore a normal fluid to the arterial system, and thus 
replace lost nerve power, lost temperature, lost secretion, and 
lost function of every kind. To accomplish all this, Hamilton 
says we must bleed. For to suppose that the abstraction of a 
few ounces of blood, so carbonized as to be almost unfitted for 
the purposes of life, if not positively deleterious, would de- 
press the strength of the patient, is both illogical and contrary 
to experience. Before or after venesection, he gives an emetic 
of ground mustard, to stimulate the arterial circulation and re- 
store animal heat ; then relies on carb. ammonia and alcoholic 
stimulants ; and keeps the feet and skin warm. There is gener- 
ally an excessive cold perspiration, which further depresses 
the already wasted vital power ; it should be wiped constantly 
away with heated flannels, and the limbs rubbed incessantly by 
strong hands and willing hearts. To arrest the exhausting dis- 
charges and alleviate the cramps, Hamilton thinks, is no easy 
task while a profound congestion exists ; but he uses morphia 
in camphor-water liberally, or pills of opium and camphor, or 
aromatic tinctures, or creosote. A large dose of calomel, fif- 
teen to twenty grains, he says, is often necessary, and will 
promptly arrest both vomiting and purging. 



94 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 



PREVENTION. 

The three great means of prevention against a general epi- 
demic are, Quarantine, Cleanliness, and Disinfection. 

1. QUARANTINE. 

As cholera is always brought to this country and city in 
ships, a long-continued and most rigid quarantine should be 
maintained. There is every reason to suppose that that of 1866, 
severe as it has been, was not sufficiently so. Three weeks' de- 
tention in quarantine after the last case is none too long, even 
when coupled with the most perfect disinfection of clothing 
and baggage. In Europe, the general impression is that 
cholera cannot be excluded by quarantine ; still, there are not 
a few instances which prove that it may. At Sarepta, on the 
Volga, there is a settlement of Moravians, which, during three 
several epidemics, of the whole surrounding country, remained 
untouched. In addition to their proverbially good and cleanly 
habits, these thoughtful people maintained a perfect system 
of quarantine. Again, there have been fourteen epidemics of 
cholera at Staten Island, and only four have reached New 
York. It cannot then be said that quarantine, 'even in the 
careless and inefficient manner in which it has, for the most 
part, been heretofore enforced, has been altogether a failure 
here. But recent occurrences prove that it must be very 
rigid to be successful. On the 14th of July, 1866, Mrs. McCoy, 
a hospital nurse from the quarantine ship Falcon, visited 
Ward's Island, and was attacked with cholera ; her two chil- 
dren, who had spent the greater part of the previous day with 
her, were next attacked. On the 16th, Mrs. Burns, a very 
healthy woman, and companion of Mrs. McCoy, sickened and 



QUARANTINE. 95 

died in twelve hours. The woman who washed the clothing 
of Mrs. Burns was the next victim, being attacked on the 18th, 
and dying after an illness of less than twenty-four hours. 
The outbreak then became general in the wash-house build- 
ing, and has since spread to other wards and the lunatic asy- 
lum. In the course of nine days, thirty-one cases and seven 
deaths occurred, and in two days after eleven more were re- 
ported in a dying condition. 

Recruits newly enlisted from among emigrants who arrived 
in cholera ships, brought the disease to Hart's and Governor's 
Islands, among the United States troops assembled there, and 
thence it was carried by them, per the San Salvador, to Tybee 
Island. In less than a month, of four hundred and seventy sol- 
diers, only eighty answered at roll-call ; ninety-five have died, 
over one hundred have deserted, eighty-seven are in hospi- 
tal, and the rest were more or less sick. It was common to 
see ten buried before breakfast, and the same number before 
supper. The statistical reports of the United States army from 
1839 to '59, contain many similar instances. Thus, in 1848, it 
was carried by United States troops from New Orleans to Texas, 
and thence spread far up into the Indian country and to Mexico. 
From 1848 to 1854, the effects of the Swanton epidemic were 
regularly carried to Forts Laramie and Leavenworth. Fort Lara- 
mie is on the route to California and Oregon, and often overrun 
by emigrants. The cholera was confined to the road, and car- 
ried along by the emigrants ; many Indians lingered along the 
line of march, from curiosity and for the purpose of begging, 
but they paid a terrible penalty. Fort Leavenworth is a general 
depot of supplies, and a starting point or rendezvous for troops 
on the march to New Mexico, and to the stations on the Great 
Plains. The disease was brought to it by troops from St. Louis, 



96 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

and most of the commands also suffered in ascending the Mis- 
sissippi and Missouri rivers. 

For a week or two, emigrants with supposed cholera mor- 
bus were admitted into the Bellevue Hospital, in July, 1866 ; 
but soon the disease took the shape of genuine Asiatic cholera, 
and by the 25th, nineteen cases had occurred. It has lately 
been ascertained that the first outbreak this season on Ward's 
Island originated among passengers from the Atalanta. 

2. CLEANLINESS. 

Watson says some of the causes of cholera are beyond hu- 
man control. We cannot regulate the temperature of the air, 
nor determine its barometrical pressure, nor influence, on any 
large scale, its movements. But we can remove decomposing 
filth. We can have the streets cleaned, not merely swept care- 
lessly ; even if the contractors, like those of New York, claim 
that their agreement is to sweep the streets, not to clean them. 
We can open up close and crowded neighborhoods, and exert a 
rigid guardianship over the condition of tenement houses ; we 
can clean the sewers and docks, and remove all nuisances. 
Most of these essential points have been attended to in New 
York, but the sewers and docks have not been reached. 
From the reports of the surgeons of the Board of Health we 
learn that some of the sewers in the best portions of the city 
are in a deplorable condition ; many were built by contractors 
ignorant, or indifferent to the simplest principles of sewerage, 
so that not a few of them run up hill. Thus, the sewer in 
Twenty-sixth street, between Second and Third avenues, has an 
ascending grade of three feet two inches to be overcome by de- 
posits accumulated from behind, before any flow can occur ; in 
Thirty-fourth street, between Fifth and Madison avenues, the 



CLEANLINESS. 9t 

sewer ascends two feet, in two hundred and fifty ; in Madison 
avenue, between Thirty-second and Thirty-third streets, it rises 
eleven inches in two hundred feet ; the sewer in Thirteenth street, 
between Sixth and Seventh avenues, also runs up-hill, and is 
always nearly seven eighths full of drain-muck, which is forced 
back to, and up and down, the Sixth avenue, thence into Four- 
teenth street, along and past Union square. Nineteenth street, 
between Sixth and Seventh avenues, is in the same condition. 
The numerous connections between these overcrowded and 
noisome sewers and the houses, by means of water-closets, 
bath-rooms, and wash-stand waste pipes, become so many 
channels to conduct foul air into the very centres of our dwel- 
lings. In most of the lateral rains, except during the progress 
of a heavy rain storm, the actual flow in the pipes is reduced 
to a mere driblet, and these appalling masses of filth underly- 
ing our city, exhale their mephitic vapors into our very sleep- 
ing chambers ; in fact, our water-closets, bath-tubs, and sta- 
tionary wash-stands, act as ventilators to the sewers ; and the 
more completely a house is provided with the modern conve- 
niences, the more deadly a habitation it may become. Persons 
living in the immediate vicinity of the obstructed sewers are 
not the only ones to suffer ; for, if once a sewer becomes 
wholly or nearly closed, the poisonous gases which are often 
rapidly and continuously disengaged, are forced back through 
the connecting pipes into far distant houses. No plumber's 
trap yet invented can prevent the passage of the foul air, the 
effect of which is so decided that butchers in London are 
obliged to avoid the vicinity of ventilating holes and culverts, 
because their meats soon become tainted. Fortunately the 
remedy is comparatively easy ; it is only necessary to connect 
with the waste or soil pipe, just below the lowermost trap, a 



98 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

small tube which must be led up through the roof and out into 
the upper air. In London, connections have been made with 
the flues of manufacturing establishments, and it is proposed 
to erect immense chimney stacks for this sole purpose. In ad- 
dition, in London, in 1859, £20,000 were expended in flushing 
the sewers with fresh water ; and one hundred and ten tons of 
lime, and twelve tons of the chloride, were thrown in every 
day, at a weekly cost of £1,500. It is to be hoped that during 
the next winter the grade of our most faulty sewers will be 
changed ; but in the meantime, solutions of copperas, or chlor- 
ide of lime, or carbolic acid, should be poured into the pipes 
of wash-stands and bath-tubs, as well as those of water-closets. 
As a further precaution, a piece of cotton may be placed over 
each outlet at night, for it has been observed that when meat 
is exposed to air which has been passed through cotton, it 
will not putrefy for months ; it is clear that cotton takes up 
something injurious from the air. 

DOCKS. 

Many of our sewers open into bulkheads instead of the tide- 
ways, and others even into vacant lots. Our docks, like the 
Thames, are converted into common sewage receptacles. Foul 
with the daily and hourly influx of abominable filth, they are 
offensive to the senses, and a cause of added foulness to the 
incumbent atmosphere. Glaisher says that, during the summer 
months, the night temperature of the Thames is considerably 
above the minimum temperature of the air, and that its vast 
area is simmering all night long, and throwing off clouds of 
noisome and noxious vapor, causing the special unhealthiness 
of those quarters of the town which lie nearest its banks. The 
same is the case with our North and East Rivers. 



DISINFECTION. 99 



PERSONS. 



Personal cleanliness is very important, for there is every 
reason to believe that foul skins and clothing, reeking with 
unremoved and decomposing filth, create an atmosphere about 
each of the " great unwashed," that may be quickly converted 
into a nucleus of cholera poison, if the least contact with the 
disease takes place. 

If the owners of emigrant ships would rigidly enforce the 
cleansing and disinfection of the persons and baggage of their 
passengers before they are allowed to proceed on board, there 
is every reason to suppose that not only cholera, but ship- 
fever and other analogous disorders, would be imported into 
this country far less frequently than they now are. 

3. DISINFECTION. 

In Europe the general impression is that cholera cannot be 
excluded by quarantine, but that it may be " stamped out" by 
disinfection. The Board of Health of Hull, a city that is daily 
exposed to imported infection, enforce no external regulations 
against cholera ; but the city and railway authorities take good 
care to send all German emigrants forward to Liverpool and 
elsewhere by special trains, and thus avoid any intercourse 
with them. But cholera has now not only broken out in Hull, 
Liverpool, Bristol, and London, but in many towns in Lanca- 
shire and Wales. Southampton is again suffering severely, 
although the sanitary authorities treat every case and locality 
of cholera by prompt medical treatment and instant disinfec- 
tion. Pettenkofer, the chief apothecary to the king of Ba- 
varia, thinks that the facility of transmission of the disease is 
so great, and such the uncertainty and inconvenience of any 



100 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

universal prohibitory restraint upon commercial intercourse, 
that it is futile to depend upon the isolation and quarantine of 
entire towns and districts ; but that it is far better to rely 
upon disinfection of houses, grounds, and the evacuated fluids 
of the sick. Thorough disinfection and cleansing are declared 
to be the best means of protection against cholera. All putres- 
cent and decaying matter, and very particularly all excrement 
and whatever has received the choleraic discharges, must be 
disinfected by powerful antiseptics. Sulphate of iron or cop- 
peras, in strong solution, is thought to be the most efficient 
and potent. Carbolic acid, and other coal tar preparations, are 
next, and nearly equal in power. Wunderlieh insists upon the 
vital importance of complete and frequent disinfection of every 
privy and filthy place in every diarrhceal district, both before 
and during cholera epidemics ; for if cholera discharges get 
into them, the whole accumulation may be changed into a mass 
of cholera poison. 

As early as 1854, Dr. Wm. Budd, of Bristol, proved the effi- 
cacy of immediate disinfection of the cholera discharges. In 
1849, cholera was brought into the Bristol workhouse by a 
woman coming from an infected quarter, and not less than one 
hundred and thirty died out of not quite six hundred inmates. 
In 1854, immediate disinfection was tried, at the suggestion of 
Dr. Budd, and although the pestilence was introduced three 
separate times, the total number of attacks was under thirty, 
with only eight deaths. We have already stated that the mor- 
tality at Ebrach was fifteen per cent, of three hundred and 
fifty prisoners, where no disinfectants were used ; while at 
Kaishaim only one case died out of a thousand men, where 
these were relied upon. At Traustein, in Bavaria, in every 
case in which the rice-water discharges were disinfected with 



DISINFECTION. 101 

sulphate of iron, the disease was confined to the first person 
seized. The New York Health Board have adopted the dis- 
infecting plan wisely and efficiently, and would have quickly 
checked the numerous outbreaks of the distemper if they had 
been properly seconded by officials and individuals ; although 
places like the Brooklyn plague district must always be diffi- 
cult to manage. Thus, in the neighborhood of Yan Brunt and 
Wallace streets, where the deaths have been most numerous, 
the ground is low and marshy ; the houses are small and dirty 
tenements, in which many families swarm. Waste pipes have 
not been laid through the streets, and more than three hun- 
dred families, and over fifteen hundred people, are dependent 
for washing, drinking, and cooking water upon the scanty 
supply from one dilapidated soil pump. The low, nasty sur- 
face of every back-yard, is still further befouled by numerous 
surface privies, and by drainage from many shanty stables, in 
which horses and hogs are crowded. It is no wonder that the 
disease has become fatal and concentrated, for the air is 
freighted with contagion, and the ground from which the in- 
habitants draw and drink their water is impregnated with the 
quintessence of the disease. 

It is well to be acquainted with the proceedings and recom- 
mendations of the New York Health Board : Freshly-prepared 
lime and charcoal, in the proportion of two parts of the for- 
mer to one of the latter, ground together in a coarse powder, 
have been used in vast quantities to disinfect out-door privies, 
the contents of which could not be safely removed until win- 
ter. It is supposed that an ordinary house-pailful of this mix- 
ture, thrown over the surface of the contents of a sink or cess- 
pool once a week, or even once in two weeks, will render 
them quite innocuous. This so-called carbo-calx mixture has 



102 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

been thickly sprinkled over defiled surfaces and places, such 
as cellars and yards. 

Chloride of lime, saturated solutions of sulphate of iron, 
(copperas), carbolic acid, coal tar, and other acids, have been 
lavishly applied to disinfect waste pipes and house drains. 
Ten pounds of strong chloride of lime are directed to be 
thoroughly mixed in half a barrel of water, and a small portion 
of it poured daily down kitchen sinks, soil pipes, and all others 
from which offensive gases arise. But Carbolic acid is the 
most powerful of deodorizers, preservatives, and disinfectants. 
Chloride of lime merely removes the smell of decomposing 
matter, while carbolic acid actually prevents decomposition. 
A piece of putrefying meat, soaked in a solution of carbolic 
acid containing one per cent, of the acid, does not lose its 
offensive smell for two days, when it will be replaced by a 
faint odor of carbolic acid, and no further decomposition will 
take place for a month or more. Chloride of lime removes the 
bad smell immediately, but decomposition goes on quite rap- 
idly. House drains and cesspools, soil pipes of water-closets 
and privies, and all foul drains, according to Dr. Harris, should 
receive a dose of carbolic acid or coal tar, every day or two. 
After these places have been flushed with a large quantity of 
water, and a few pints of coal tar have been poured down 
them, then a teacupful every two or three nights will be suffi- 
cient, not only to keep down all putrefaction and sink smells, 
but will maintain constant disinfection. If carbolic acid or 
coal tar cannot be procured, the same quantities of a thick, 
creamy solution of chloride of lime, and a pint or two of a so- 
lution of copperas, in the proportion of ten pounds to a pail of 
water, may be relied upon. To render the disinfection as com- 
plete as possible, a pint of this solution of copperas should be 



DISINFECTION. 103 

poured into each water-closet and privy-seat every night, and 
a small quantity down each bath-tub and wash-stand drain. It 
is highly probable that strong solutions of coarse salt and salt- 
petre will be found to be almost equally efficacious. 

In private houses, in addition to the free use of lime, 
chloride of lime, or lime and charcoal, in cellars, the use 
of coke as fuel, and the presence of a chaldron or more on 
the premises, will be of great service as a preventive of the 
disease. 

As ozone is deficient in the air in cholera times, steps should 
have been taken to supply it ; for ozone is a vital element of 
the air, and oxygen cannot be assimilated by the system with- 
out its presence. It gives to oxygen its life-supporting prop- 
erties, but is rapidly destroyed in large towns and in crowded 
and filthy localities. During periods of great heat of weather, 
it also loses its active powers. In the absence of ozone, offen- 
sive products are increased ; wounds become unhealthy and 
heal slowly ; and diseases which show a putrefactive tendency 
are influenced injuriously. Fortunately, it can be readily sup- 
plied to houses and hospitals. Moffatt has used phosphorus 
for the production of ozone as a purifier and disinfectant, thus : 
Take a quart bottle with a wide mouth, into which put rather 
more than half a pint of water ; on a piece of cork floating on 
this fluid, place a flat piece of phosphorus with a clean-cut 
surface ; close the mouth of the bottle either loosely with a 
cork, or tightly with a perforated cover. This should be done 
night and morning, or several times a day. Squibb directs half 
a stick of phosphorus to be laid upon the flat surface of an or- 
dinary breakfast plate, and water poured upon it sufficient to 
immerse two thirds of the stick, leaving the remainder exposed 
to the air ; the plate is then to be placed upon the mantel- 



104 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

piece, out of the reach of accident or disturbance. At night, 
more water is to be poured upon the plate, till but a narrow 
line of the stick is exposed above the surface ; for great 
evaporation will take place before morning. When the de- 
sired disinfection has been accomplished, the plate should be 
filled with water until the phosphorus is entirely covered. 
There are several objections to the use of phosphorus : first, 
from its easy inflammability, it is a dangerous substance at best ; 
second, the vapors from it at night are lurid and disagreeable 
to the sight of nervous persons ; and third, if too much is 
allowed to burn, the phosphorous acid irritates the air-tubes. 
But, in careful and intelligent hands, it is exceedingly useful, 
and, to cholera patients, somewhat curative. 

Bromine is an excellent disinfectant, and evaporates spon- 
taneously and so rapidly, that the simple removing the stopper 
from a narrow-necked bottle will soon deodorize the atmo- 
sphere of a room. The bottle should not be left open too long, 
but be closed from time to time. 

DISINFECTION OF WATER. 

In all places where water from springs, wells, or pumps, is 
used, if there is the slightest danger of impurity, means of pu- 
rification should be used. It has been fairly proved that even 
water, contaminated with choleraic matters, loses its infectious 
properties by being boiled and filtered. But boiled water 
should be allowed to become thoroughly cold, and allowed to 
absorb air in place of that which has been expelled by heat, 
before it is drank. An excellent filter for the poor is one of 
the largest-sized common red flower pots, suspended at a con- 
venient height of a few feet, in a shady place, and having the 
hole in its base plugged with a sponge, so as to permit only an 



DISINFECTION OF WATER. 105 

exceedingly fine stream of water to pass through ; the sponge 
must, of course, be washed frequently. A good filter should 
be attached to every faucet from which drinking water is 
drawn, and a thick flannel bag makes a good substitute until 
a better can be procured. Every traveller should supply him- 
self with a small bottle of the saturated solution of permanga- 
nate of potash, for it has been found, in India, that at stations 
where the water was turbid, and tasted and smelled of decay- 
ing organic matter, the addition of a few drops of this solution 
rendered the water as clear and sweet as spring water in a few 
minutes. The permanganate is innocent in character, and re- 
moves the most putrid odors as if by magic. It is an excellent 
disinfectant, and may be put in the foulest water, or the most 
repellant mixtures, and the sense of smell will cease to be 
offended ; while we may be sure, also, that all injurious sub- 
stances will be destroyed. 

The Peroxide of Hydrogen is still more efficient. It looks 
like water ; but if we pour it on the filthiest substance, the 
smell of putrefaction ceases, and in many cases a sweet odor 
or fragrant perfume, created in an instant, arises in its place. 
It was formerly dear, and there were but few places where it 
could be had cheaply, and then only in small quantities ; but 
Professor Schoenbein has discovered that it may easily be 
prepared, by shaking violently, for a few seconds, amalgamated 
granulated zinc with a little distilled water contained in a 
large bottle. 

Finally, Dr. Thomas Spencer has discovered that the black 
oxide, or so-called magnetic carbide of iron (prepared by heat- 
ing together haematite, or red oxide of iron ore, with sawdust), 
frees water from nearly all its organic impurities. If ordinary 
river water, even the more impure kinds of it, is made to per- 



106 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

colate a layer of magnetic carbide some inches thick, it is not 
only filtered, but deprived of much of its soluble organic im- 
purities. The water becomes bright, loses its yellow color, 
and is free from smell or taste of any kind. If a few drops of 
a solution of permanganate of potash be well mixed in this fil- 
tered water, its pink color will remain, while impure water will 
destroy the beautiful tint of the permanganate. Filters, pre- 
pared with the magnetic carbide, will last for seven or ten 
years, without requiring cleansing, or refitting. 



Since writing the above, the principal causes of the malig- 
nancy of the epidemic at Hart's Island, among the United States 
soldiers have been ascertained. The place had been previously 
defiled by thousands of Southern prisoners ; emigrant recruits 
brought the disease, and the special poison of cholera was 
multiplied suddenly and extensively. The soil was so saturated 
with old filth that the drinking water also became contami- 
nated. The island has wisely been abandoned, as it was im- 
possible to disinfect the ground and water. 

Cholera has broken out suddenly in the Kings county jail, 
which is a model of cleanliness ; thirty-eight inmates were 
attacked in one night. About one mile off are extensive pig- 
geries, offal fields, and swill establishments, of the most offen- 
sive character, which poison the air for acres around ; still 
none of the pig, swill, or offal men have as jet been affected 
with cholera. It will soon be found that one or more cholera 
subjects have been introduced into the jail, but that none have 
gone to the piggeries. 



TREATMENT. 107 



TREATMENT. 

MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS AND NURSES. 

In a case of cholera of any severity, the carpets should be 
taken up ; the room stripped of all unnecessary furniture and 
ornaments ; the bed — which had better be a single one — should 
be placed in the middle of the room, for free ventilation and 
ready access on all sides, and should also be guarded with 
an India-rubber sheet. All discharges must be received in 
basins, chamber-vessels, or bed-pans, in which a tablespoonful 
of the solution of copperas and a tablespoonful of chloride of 
lime, or a mixture of salt, magnesia, and dilute sulphuric acid, 
have been put. The air of the apartment, the neighborhood of 
the bed, the vessels themselves, and the dejections, will thus 
be thoroughly deodorized, disinfected, and rendered harmless. 
At the same time, the waste and soil pipes will be put in an 
improved condition, for the greater the number of the dis- 
charges, the more frequently will the drains and sewers be 
supplied with disinfectants. Very careful persons may, in ad- 
dition, pour a pint or two of the solution of copperas in the 
water standing in the privy-seat, and sprinkle a teacupful of 
the carbolate of lime, or chloride of lime, or of the carbo-calx 
powder, over its sides, whenever cholera discharges have 
been passed through them. 

Bed and body linen, and toweling used by cholera patients 
and their nurses, should be immediately put into a tub, in 
which one ounce of permanganate of potash has been dissolved 
in every six or eight gallons of water. Or a pint of Labar- 
raque's solution of chlorinated soda may be used for the same 
purpose, in a tub of water. Either of these solutions may be 



108 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

used in cleansing the soiled parts of the bodies of sick or dead 
persons. 

Nurses should cleanse their hands, and those of cholera 
patients, frequently, in water in which a few drops of the sat- 
urated solution of permanganate of potash has been mixed ; 
and should never partake of food without first carefully wash- 
ing their hands. 

With these precautions, there is not the slightest danger to 
those who attend cholera cases. If sickness should occur 
among them, it may be safely assumed that they had con- 
tracted it previously, and that the germs were lying dor- 
mant in their systems. There should be a sufficiency of 
nurses, so that none of them may become greatly fatigued 
or distressed, and that each shall have an abundance of sleep 
and rest, with time for leisurely and regular attendance at 
meals. Attendants must, of course, be very careful about 
their food, but should eat sufficiently of plain beef, mutton, or 
poultry, rice, farina, hominy, bread, toast, and similar staple ar- 
ticles. Green tea is the best beverage when there is a ten- 
dency to looseness ; coffee, chocolate, or black tea, may be 
used when costiveness is present. Salt should be eaten freely, 
as it is one of the best of tonics and disinfectants. Beaman 
thinks that a somewhat weakened state of the stomach and 
bowels predisposes to cholera, and that this is removed by 
eating freely of salt at meals ; he believes that at least three 
fourths of all cases of cholera could be prevented by this sim- 
ple means. Adults may consume from one half to a whole tea- 
spoonful at each meal, and in two days it is supposed that the 
majority of persons will be no longer susceptible to the dis- 
ease. Its daily use in smaller quantities should, however, be 
persisted in as long as the epidemic prevails. The moderate 



TREATMENT. 109 

use of condiments, such as black and red pepper, French or 
English mustard, or Worcestershire sauce, or of cinnamon, nut- 
meg, allspice, &c, is often useful, for all these articles are anti- 
septic as well as stimulant. Ginger syrup, with plain or soda 
water, is a good beverage. Isinglass, one-quarter 6unce, sugar, 
two lumps, in a small tumbler of boiling water, with half a 
wine-glass of brandy, or a wine-glass of sherry, or two wine- 
glasses of claret, and a little nutmeg or cinnamon, is a capital 
nightcap for one who is very much fatigued and afraid of 
cholera. 

Or a wineglass of the following mixture may be taken occa- 
sionally : spirit, vini gallici, |iv. ; aquas cinnamoni, |iv. ; vitel. 
ovorum, No. 2 ; olei cinnamoni, m. v. — Brande. 

If there is any fear from inhaling the breath of a cholera 
patient, twenty-four grains each of hypermanganate of potassa 
and hyperoxydate of barium, should be rubbed up with sugar 
and glycerine, and divided into one hundred and forty-four 
lozenges ; the patient should use them frequently, and the at- 
tendants may also. Every ill-smelling mouth will become en- 
tirely odorless by their use. 

Nurses should wear a broad band of flannel around their 
persons, and should dress and sleep rather warmly. A check 
of perspiration, or a chill at night, is especially dangerous. 
They should not allow themselves to remain costive, but may 
occasionally take one or two simple non-drastic pills at night. 

Aloes socrotine, two grains ; soap, in fine powder, 2 grains ; 
ext. nux vom., one quarter grain. 

Or, rhubarb, three grains ; soap, one grain; ext. nux vom., 
one quarter grain. Or sulphate of iron may be substituted 
for the soap. 

If fatigue and distress cause loss of appetite and indigestion, 



110 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

one half or a whole teaspoonful of the compound tincture of 
gentian, or simple Stoughton's bitters, may be taken in a little 
sweetened water before each meal; and one or two teaspoonfuls 
of pepsine wine after each repast. Fatigue and debility may 
be removed by wine of iron or bark, or sherry and water, or 
spirits and gum-arabic water, or claret and water. If debility 
and diarrhoea commence, a small teaspoonful of the following 
powder may be taken at each meal time : ferri lactici, 5 SS ~3j- ; 
calc. phosphatis, 3j. ; calc. carbon, 3\j- > sacch. lact., §ss.-§j. ; 
pulv. cinnam., 5j ; niix and make a powder. 

Or a pill consisting of one or two grains. each of sulphate of 
iron and extract of gentian, and one quarter grain of extract 
of nux vomica, may be taken two or three times a day. 

Or a tablespoonful of a solution consisting of: quinine, six- 
teen grains ; sulphate of iron, twelve grains ; aromatic sul- 
phuric acid, one drachm, in six ounces of water, may be taken 
several times a day. 

The sulphate of iron is an astringent, tonic and disinfectant, 
and will not only brace up the system, but destroy any germs 
of cholera which may have obtained access to the system. It 
will probably prove the best preventive and curative remedy 
against Asiatic cholera. 

PRODROMIC DIARRHOEA. 

Gull says that the diarrhoea premonitory of the severer 
symptoms of cholera is often feculent and bilious, and presents 
no characteristics whereby it can be certainly distinguished 
from other forms. The number of discharges that precede an 
explosion of cholera varies considerably. Frequently there are 
hot more than two or three in twenty-four hours ; at other 
times as many as twenty, continuing for days, and even weeks. 



PRODROMIC DIARRHCEA. Ill 

As cholera prevails in the months and seasons in which 
attacks of diarrhoea, cholera morbus, and other bowel com- 
plaints, are most frequent, it is not only extremely probable, 
but absolutely certain, that the majority of those cases have no 
relation whatever to true cholera. They may and should be 
regarded with the same equanimity as in more healthy sea- 
sons, and only require the treatment which has been found 
efficacious in ordinary times. In fact, the greater number 
would recover without any medicine, if rest in bed and care 
in diet were maintained. For the remainder, very simple 
treatment is often sufficient. 

We append a number of simple but reliable prescrip- 
tions, from which any intelligent physician can easily make a 
choice : 

1. Dr. Bowerbank generally found a little ginger-tea, with a, 
few grains of carbonate of soda, and an equal quantity of com- 
mon sense about diet and absolute rest, quite sufficient. 

2. Other physicians recommend the patient to go to bed , 
keep warm, and drink several cups of hot green tea, or of 
herb or mint tea — the object being to produce perspiration. 

3. Peppermint-tea is recommended by Parisian physicians, 
in quantities of a cupful every quarter or half hour, quite hot 
and sweetened ; with or without the addition of a tea or table- 
spoonful of old rum or brandy, and twenty drops of tincture of 
cinnamon, till perspiration is caused and diarrhoea checked ; 
which generally happens in three hours. If it causes vomit- 
ing, it should be discontinued. 

4. Physicians of all schools rely much upon camphor in the 
treatment of cholera. In 1832, the Edinburgh homoeopathists 
used over five gallons of the tincture. It is said to have 
saved fifty-four persons out of sixty-five, and is also supposed 



112 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

to destroy the contagion of the disease, so that the sick person 
is no longer dangerous to his attendants after he has taken a 
few doses. Dr. Rubini, of Naples, claims to have treated five 
hundred and ninety-two cases without a single death, with the 
saturated spirits of camphor. We presume that he did not 
make it six hundred, on the same principle as the boy's father, 
who killed ninety-nine ducks at one shot, refused to make it 
one hundred from fear of telling an untruth. Rubini uses alco- 
hol, sixty degrees above proof, and says he is able with it to 
dissolve its own weight of camphor. This preparation is nine 
times as strong as the one in ordinary use, and twice as potent 
as that used by the homoeopathists. He gives four drops every 
five minutes ; but in severe cases increases the dose to five or 
twenty drops, or even a small teaspoonful. Ordinarily, in from 
two to four hours, an abundant perspiration will break out, and 
a cure soon follows. As a preventive, he recommends five 
drops three or four times a day. These doses should always 
be taken on lumps of sugar, and not in water. In the United 
States army, from two to four, or even seven and eight grains 
are often given in a teaspoonful of Hoffman's anodyne. 

5. From a tea to a tablespoonful of paregoric has often 
proved sufficient. Equal parts of compound spirits of laven- 
der and paregoric are often relied upon with confidence. 

6. One or two drachms of alum dissolved in five ounces of 
water, with the addition of one ounce of syrup of ginger, 
makes a palatable and useful medicine, in doses of one or 
several teaspoonfuls, frequently repeated. Iron-alum may be 
prepared and used in the same way. 

7. Syrup rhei. aromat., §j.; aquae menth. pip., |iv. Dose, 
one or two teaspoonfuls in diarrhoea, vomiting, cholera mor- 
bus, and cholera infantum. 



PRODROMIC DIARRHCEA. 113 

8. Carbonis ligni, §j. ; theraicse, gj. Dose, one teaspoonful 
from two to four times a day, in diarrhoea from faecal fermen- 
tation. 

9. Tinct. cinnamomi, §ss. ; spir. ammon. aromat., §ss. ; de- 
cocti hsematoxyli, §v. Dose, one quarter part, after every loose 
motion. 

10. Pulv. carb. ammon., 3ij» > a( l- menth. pip., §iv. Dose, 
one to three teaspoonfuls every half, one, or more hours. 

11. Velpeau recommends absolute rest in bed, and three or 
four drops of laudanum every one or two hours, until vomit- 
ing and diarrhoea pass away. He also advises very small in- 
jections of starch, with seven or eight drops of laudanum in 
each. 

12. Ammon recommends potass bicarb., 3j»; aq. menth. 
pip., §vj. Dose, a spoonful every hour. 

13. Bismuthi nitratis, 5ij« ; pulv. opii, gr. i.-ij. ; pulv. 
cinnam., 5ij« Make eight powders, and give one every two or 
four hours in incipient cholera. — Ammon. 

14. Bismuth mixture, prepared exactly like the officinal 
chalk mixture, is an excellent preparation, and most efficient 
when there is much distress in the stomach. 

15. Simple chalk mixture, prepared with half an ounce of 
prepared chalk, a quarter of an ounce of loaf sugar and gum- 
arabic powder, and eight ounces of cinnamon or other aromatic 
water, is very useful in diarrhoea. To render it more astrin- 
gent, one ounce of tincture of catechu, or kino, is often added. 
The dose is one or two teaspoonfuls, to as many tablespoonfuls 
for adults. It is supposed that the chalk is not only an astrin- 
gent but a disinfectant. If there is much distension of the 
bowels, one ounce of aromatic powder may be added to the 
mixture. 



114 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

16. Others rely on the aromatic powder, composed of cinna- 
mon and ginger, each two parts ; cardamom seeds and nutmeg, 
of each one part. Dose : ten to twenty grains, in water. The 
addition of twenty grains of prepared chalk makes it a very 
efficient medicine in diarrhoea. 

17. Sodae bicarbonatis, 9j. ; sulphuris praecipitati, 9j. ; tinct. 
lavand. comp., gss. ; aquae, giij.-v. Dose : one or two table- 
spoonfuls every two or three hours in ordinary diarrhoea pre- 
ceding cholera. — Grove. 

18. Infus. acori calami, giij. ; gum acaciae pulv. gj. ; sac- 
chari albi, 3ij- Dose : a tea to a tablespoonful every one or 
more hours. 

19. Tinct. rhatany, gj. ; aquas calcis gv. One to three spoon- 
fuls after every passage. 

20. Bismuthi nitratis, 5j -5ij- ; elect, catechu, 5ij- Make four- 
grain pills, and take from one to three every hour in choleriform 
diarrhoea. 

21. Monesiae, 5j-> aluminis, gr. xxiv. ; confect. aromaticae, 
3ss. ; syrupi, q. s. Make twenty-four pills, and take two after 
every passage. 

22. Acidi sulphurici diluti, 3ij- ; tinct. cardamomi co., gss. ; 
aquae menth. pip. ad, gvj. ; sacchari albi, gss. Dose : one- 
fourth part every two or four hours. 

23. Tinct. gallae, gss. ; mist, amygdalae, giss ; mist, acaciae, 
gss. ; aquaefontis, gv. Dose : one tablespoonful after every 
liquid passage in colliquative diarrhoea. — Neligan. 

24. Ext. haematoxyli, 3j« ; decocti cinchonas, giij. ; aquae cin- 
namomi, gss. ; syrupi aurantii, gss. Dose : one or two teaspoon- 
fuls every hour in cholera infantum. — Ure. 

25. Decocti haematoxyli, gviij. ; aluminis pulv., 3ss. Solve 
for an astringent enema. — Eeece. 



CHOLERAIC DIARRHEA, 115 

26. Ext. nuc vomicae, gr. ij.-vj. ; Aquas mellissae, §vj. ; rnu- 
cilag. acaciae, §ss. Dose : two spoonfuls every two hours. 

27. Creasoti, 5j ; ext. glycyrrhizas, 5ss. ; galbani colati, 3ss. ; 
althaeas rad. pulv., 5y» Make sixty pills, and take two or three 
from three to six times a day. — Reecke. 

28. Ferri carbon, saccharati, 3ss. ; pulv. myrrhae, gr. xxiv. ; 
pulv. aromatici, 5 SS - Make twelve powders, and give one 
every two or four hours in protracted and obstinate diarrhoeas 
of children. — Neligan. 

29. Ferri sesquioxidi, 3j« ; pulv. cinnam. co., 3j« ; syrupi 
Aurantii §j. Make an electuary, and give a spoonful from 
three to six times a day. — Joy. 

30. Ferri sesquioxidi, gr. x.-xx. ; pulv. aromatici, gr. v. ; 
syrupi zinziberis, q. s. Make a bolus, to be taken from two to 
four times a day. — Copland. 

31. Misturas ferri compos. |iss. ; aquae cinnam., |ss. The 
whole to be taken from two to six times a day in the diarrhoeas 
of feeble and exsanguine persons. 

32. Ferri et aluminae bisulphat. (iron-alum), gr. v.-x. ; aquae 
cinnam., §iss. To be taken every two or three hours.— 
Mukray. 

33. Pulv. kino, 3v. ; pulv. aluminis, 3ij- ; pulv. cinnam., 3ij- ; 
syrupi, q. s. Make an electuary, and take one or two tea- 
spoonfuls occasionally. — Savory. 

34. Bismuthi, 3\j- ; cretae prep., 3\j- ; pulv. cinnam., 3ij- ; 
sacch. alb. §iss. Make a powder, and take from one quarter to 
a whole teaspoonful every two, four, or six hours. 

CHOLERAIC DIARRHCEA. 

Le Segue says this is liquid, serous, watery, abundant, and 
more or less colored. The stools succeed each other every 



116 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

hour or two, or sometimes oftener. After the second or third 
they become whitish, like very thin paste, are voided without 
pain, and cause no sensations of burning or tenesmus. In the 
interval there is an occasional rumbling. When, after five or 
six stools, the appearance of the matters passed is unchanged, 
and the dejections are no more watery nor paler, it is a favor- 
able symptom. The evacuations are not followed by that sen- 
sation of sinking so frequently associated with smaller dis- 
charges, The vomitings are sometimes green long after the 
discharges have become exclusively serous. It is generally 
supposed that this form of diarrhoea is not more difficult to 
treat than the ordinary form. But this is not quite true ; it 
does not yield very readily, and soon becomes a source of great 
clanger, Burrows says the facility with which the serous 
diarrhoea may be checked, depends mainly upon the period of 
the epidemic when the treatment is adopted. Those remedies 
which are powerless at the height of the epidemic, will prove 
efficacious towards the decline. Cases of serous diarrhoea, 
with symptoms of exhaustion, short of collapse, appeared to 
him, in spite of unremitting attention, to be quite uncontrolla- 
ble in the month of July ; while cases of equal urgency, in 
September, were controlled with a facility which often aston- 
ished him. 

In the treatment of this disorder it is best to commence at 
once with the most efficient and specific remedies. These I 
believe to be sulphate of iron (or copperas) ; iron-alum ; nux 
vomica ; kreosote, which is a pure carbolic acid ; the prepara- 
tions of lime and bismuth ; chloroform, &c. I append a num- 
ber of prescriptions : 

1. Sulph. ferri, gr. ij.-iij. ; ext. nuc vomicae, gr. ^-± ; ext. 
gentian, gr. j., make a pill, to be given every one, two, or four 
hours. 



CHOLERAIC DIARRH(EA. 117 

2. Ferri. sulph., 3j- ; acid sulph. dilut, 5j. ; aq. pur. ©iss. 
Dose : half or whole wineglass full every quarter, half, or one 
hour. — Bell. 

3. Ferri. sulphatis, 5j-ij- > sacchari, §j. > aquae cinnamomi, 
gvij. Dose : a tablespoonful every one, two, or three hours. 

4. Ferri. sulphatis, 9j~9ij. ; acidi sulphurici, 3ss.-3j. ; sac- 
chari, 5ij- ; aquae, §iv. Dose : one or more teaspoonfuls every 
quarter, half, one, or more hours. 

5. Ferri sulphatis, gr. v— x. ; acid, sulph. aromat, 3ss-3j ; 
aquae, Jj. Dose : one or two teaspoonfuls in water. 

6. Acidi sulphurici diluti., 3i v - ; syrupi aurantii corticis, 
|iss. ; aquae cinnamomi, §j. Dose : one or more teaspoonfuls 
every half, one, or more hours. 

7. Acidi galliei, 9iss. ; ext. gentian., gr.x. ; ext nuc vomicae, 
gr. v. ; make ten pills. Dose : one pill every one, two, or 
more hours. 

8. Acidi galliei, gr. v. — xx. To be taken in a wineglassful 
of brandy and water every half, one, or more hours. 

9. Extracti geranii mac. fluidi, $vi. ; tinct. cinnam., §ss. ; 
syrupi rosae gallicae, §ij. Dose : a dessertspoonful every half, 
one, or two hours. 

10. Olei. terebinth, 5j. ; aetheris sulphurici, 3iij- Dose : 3ss.- 
3j. in barley-water every one, two, or more hours. 

11. Olei. terebinth, |ss. ; mucilag. acaciae, gss. ; tinct. lavand. 
co., §ss. ; aquae cinnam., giiss. Dose : one to three teaspoon- 
fuls in water every two or more hours. 

12. Olei. terebinth, m. xv.-xxx. ; aq. menth. pip., §j. To be 
taken every one, two, or four hours. 

13. Olei terebinth, m. xv.-xl. ; mucilag. acaciae, 3^j« ; spir. 
lavand. co., 5\j« To be taken every two, four, or six hours. 

14. Quinae disulph., gr. x-xx. ; ferri. sulph, 9j-9ij. ; aq. pur. 



118 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

©is3. ; tinct. nuc vomicae, §ss. Dose : one to three tablespoon- 
fuls every half, one, or two hours. 

15. Creasotii, m. xx. ; tinct. cardam. co., §ss. ; nxucilag. aca- 
ciae, §ss. Dose : ten to thirty drops in a wineglass half or 
quite full of water, every quarter, half, one, or two hours. 

16. Creasoti gutt. x.-xx. ; syrupi tolutani, §ss. ; tinct. car- 
dam, co., §ss. ; aquae anethi. vel, cinnamomi, giij. Dose : a 
tea to a tablespoonful every one, two, or three hours, in chole- 
raic diarrhoea. — Richardson. 

17. Chloroformi, 5y»; tinct. camphorae fort., 5iss. ; tinct. opii, 
5iss. ; olei cinnamomi, m. viij. ; alcohol, 5nj» Dose : five to 
thirty drops. — Horner. 

18. Chloroformi, x.-xx. ; spts. vini. gallici, 3iij- ; syrup orgeat, 
3ij. ; aquae, §ss.-§j. To be taken repeatedly. 

19. Chloroformi, §ss. ; sol. magend., |ss. ; tinct. capsici, |ss, ; 
syrup zinziberi, §ss. Dose : ten to sixty drops. 

20. Squibb's mixture is much recommended. Tinct. opii, gj. ; 
tinct. camphoraa fort., gj.; tinct. capsici, Jj. ; chloroformi, 5iij. ; 
alcohol, ad. §v. Dose : for infants, one to ten drops in a few tea- 
spoonfuls of sweetened water, syrup of gum-arabic, or orgeat ; 
for persons two to six years of age, ten to thirty drops ; from 
six to ten years old, thirty drops ; ten to fourteen years, half a 
teaspoonful ; fourteen to eighteen, a small teaspoonful ; all 
persons over eighteen years, one or two teaspoonfuls. The 
doses to be repeated after every movement. 

21. Tinct. opii, |ss. ; spts. camphor ae fort., gss. ; liq. ammo- 
niae, gss. Dose : ten to thirty drops. 

22. Tinct. opii, |ss. ; tinct. camphoraa fort, gss. ; tinct. cate- 
chu, §ss. ; cinnam., §ss. ; tinct. capsici, co., gss. ; mucilag. aca- 
ciae, §iss. Dose : one or two teaspoonfuls in water as often as 
necessary in the first stage of cholera. — Houston. 



FULLY-DEVELOPED CHOLERA. 119 

23. Acid, sulph, dilut, m. x. ; aq. pur., vel cinnam., §ss. To 
be taken every one, two, or more hours. — Braithwaite. 

24. Acid sulph. dilut., 5ij- ; tinct. cardam. co., 3ij- ; aq. des- 
tillat. §v., ss. Dose: one or two tablespoonfuls every four 
hours regularly, and after every liquid stool or vomit. — 
Miller. 

25. The missionaries at Constantinople relied upon : tinct. 
opii, tinct. rhei., spir. camphorge, equal parts ; thirty to sixty 
drops per dose. They claim to have lost but thirty cases out 
of six hundred, and attributed their great success somewhat 
to their careful nursing and unremitting devotion, as they 
remained at the bedsides of the sick for hours, or until all 
danger had passed. 

26. Quinias sulphatis, gr. xij. ; ferri sulph. exssic., gr. xxiv. ; 
pulv. opii, vel ext. nuc vom., gr. iij. ; make 12 pills. Dose : 
one or two every two, four, or six hours. 

27. Quinise sulph., 9j. ; ferri sulph. exssic, 9ij. ; pulv. cap- 
sici, 9j. ; make twenty pills. Dose : one or two every one, 
two, or more hours. 

FULLY-DEVELOPED CHOLERA. 

After a longer or shorter period of diarrhoea, the symptoms 
of the second stage are added. Suddenly, without much nau- 
sea, vomiting commences. At first, the ingesta are ejected ; 
then follows, at diminishing intervals, a serous fluid similar to 
that discharged from the bowels, but without the admixture of 
chyle. The powers of hie now rapidly fail ; the skin becomes 
cool, the thirst intense, the pulse loses its force and increases 
in frequency, the whole surface of the body is bathed in a 
profuse perspiration, the features shrink rapidly, and the whole 
expression of countenance is changed ; the voice sinks to an 



120 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

almost inaudible husky whisper ; cramps of the extremities set 
in, and finally extend to the trunk ; the sensibility is rapidly im- 
paired, being scarcely aroused by the most violent muscular 
spasms, and the patient evinces a remarkable indifference, as 
well to his present condition, as to his future fate. This is 
incipient collapse. During all this time, many patients suffer 
less pain than is generally supposed. The intense thirst, the 
frequent vomitings and calls to stool, are sources of much dis- 
comfort ; but the only cause of actual pain is to be found in 
the cramps. Even the pain of these is often much less than in 
cases of ordinary cholera morbus and cramp colic. 

In this stage the quantity of fluid pouring out from the mu- 
cous membrane of the stomach and bowels is so great, that all 
food and medicines, are swept along and away with it. Little 
or no absorption takes place, and the largest and smallest 
doses of the most active and the mildest medicines are alike 
powerless. Brandy and red pepper are as innocuous as water ; 
half-ounce doses of calomel and laudanum are as innocent as 
the thirtieth dilution of chamomilla ; five-drop doses of Croton 
oil are as harmless as so much oil of olives. 

Macpherson's directions are : secure the best hygienic con- 
ditions possible for your patients ; give them abundance of 
water to drink and ice to suck ; correct cramps and inordinate 
vomiting by the internal and external use of chloroform. 
Apply external warmth and extra bedclothes, if these are 
grateful to the patient, but if they make him restless, do not 
press them, for it is unwise to submit him in any way to a dis- 
agreeable heat, which materially adds to his sufferings and 
danger. If the perspiration is excessive, wipe him dry from 
time to time, disturbing him as little as possible, for excessive 
rubbing is useless, and exhausting to patient and nurses. But 



FULLY-DEVELOPED CHOLERA. 121 

the abdomen and limbs, according to Magendie, may be rubbed 
occasionally with a mixture of tinct. mix vom., §ij. ; linimen. 
saponis, vel ammonise, vel ehloroformi, §ss. Still Macpherson 
asks whether it is a judicious measure to apply heat externally ; 
to cover up the patients with blankets ; to stimulate the sur- 
face with counter-irritants, such as mustard, turpentine, &c. 
He has done all these things, and questions whether much is 
gained by them ; he is quite sure that they are very distaste- 
ful to nine patients out of ten, and their instinctive prompt- 
ings is worth something ; he knows that it is so in the matter 
of drink in cholera, and he thinks it is so in the question of 
food, clothing, and frictions ; where they are grateful they 
may be used, but ought not to be insisted upon when the 
reverse is the case. There is a greater tolerance of blanket- 
ing in Europe than in India. 

As soon as the rice-water evacuations commence, Dr. John 
Gason, of Ireland, places a towel, very tightly rolled up, so as 
to be nine or ten inches long and one and a half or two inches 
thick, directly between the buttocks, so that the orifice of the 
bowel comes directly on the middle of this roller, which 
should be sprinkled with a solution of chloride of lime, or 
some other disinfectant. If properly made and placed, it is 
said, no evacuation can possibly take place, not even as much 
as will stain it. Together with this, a broad flannel bandage 
should be tightly carried around the whole body, three or four 
times, and the part next the skin, especially that portion over 
the bowels, should be well sprinkled with chloroform. This 
flannel roller is as important to a cholera patient as a bandage 
is in uterine haemorrhage after confinement, for the bowels are 
completely relaxed and paralyzed, and require support. 

The regulation of the food and drink of the patient is of the 



122 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

greatest importance. When Macpherson first went to India, 
it was a common practice to withhold water, especially cold 
water, from cholera patients ; the objection was, that it 
increased vomiting and so exhausted the sufferer. Following 
the routine of the day, he acted in this way, but was taught 
the cruelty and folly of it by personal experience. When a 
person has been drained for an hour or two by rice-water 
purging, the desire for water is urgent and instinctive ; the 
system craves and demands it. Do not then be guilty of the 
cruelty of withholding water, but give it often and give it 
cold, for hot drinks are not relished by cholera patients. 
There is no necessity to give large draughts ; but let not the 
fact that a portion of almost every supply is vomited lead you 
to withhold it entirely. Let your patients have as much ice 
as they please. Macpherson never saw a cholera patient to 
whom ice was not grateful. In his own case, he took no 
drugs, but drank freely of iced soda-water, to his infinite com- 
fort and refreshment. When he vomited, which he did often, 
he drank again ; when too feeble to speak, at a look or a ges- 
ture, his faithful nurse replenished his glass again and again. 
He then formed the fixed resolution, never since departed 
from, never to withhold a cup of cold water from a cholera 
patient. Seltzer, Vichy, or carbonic acid water, with the addi- 
tion of a little iron, or some iron-water, like Pyrmont, may be 
used with advantage. Champagne and water, or iced cham- 
pagne, may be taken occasionally, or a wine or claret glass of 
green tea punch, made as follows : 

Infusi thaes3 virid. fort, ©ij, ; succi. limonis, gj. ; spir.vini 
gallici, giv. ; sacch. alb., giv. 

It is worse than useless to attempt to feed cholera patients. 
The mildest nourishment only adds to the feeling of oppres- 



TREATMENT OF COLLAPSE. 123 

sion and general distress, from which only the act of vomiting 
gives immediate relief. Still, beef-tea, or consomme, well sea- 
soned with salt, may be tried from time to time ; or a little 
arrow-root, or solution of isinglass, or gum-arabic, with brandy ; 
or a few spoonfuls, from time to time, of milk and lime-water, 
in equal parts ; or milk punch, made with milk, lime-water, 
and brandy. As a general rule, however, these articles are 
more useful at a later period. 

As the stomach should be allowed to rest as much as 
possible, injections of two ounces each of strong green tea 
and brandy ; or of strong solutions of sulphate of iron, or of 
creosote or turpentine, may be tried with hope of success. 

Simple soda powders will often relieve the vomiting better 
than anything else, although full doses of creosote in mucilage 
and tincture of cardamoms, are often useful. 

Hypodermic injections of morphine will often prevent or 
remove cramps, allay vomiting, check diarrhoea, and produce 
general comfort. 

COLLAPSE. 

The preceding stage is usually of short duration ; and with 
the subsidence of the active symptoms, the patient sinks into 
the third, or cold, or algid stage. The vomiting and diarrhoea 
cease ; the secretions are all suspended, especially that of 
urine ; the shrivelled skin partially relaxes, and presents the 
coldness of death ; the pulse is no longer to be felt, and the 
beating of the heart is scarcely to be felt or heard. 

TREATMENT OF COLLAPSE. 

Macpherson says in the stage of collapse he knows no drug 
worthy of the smallest confidence. The remedies are either 
vomited, or, if retained, are inert ; and if given, as they often 



124 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

are, in excessive quantities, they become a serious cause of em- 
barrassment, interfering especially with nutrition. Some — and 
in severe epidemics, unfortunately, a great many — patients will 
die ; but such cannot be saved by pouring drugs into them in 
the collapse of this terrible disease. 

Houston asks, when the patient reaches a state of profound 
collapse, does anything remain to be done — can the resources 
of our art furnish any relief? He feels constrained to give a 
negative reply. Many have recovered from this algid state ; 
but, under his observation, a larger portion recovered of those 
who were left to the efforts of nature than of those who were 
actively treated. The patient may lie for many hours equally 
balanced between life and death, and, if kept warmly covered 
in the recumbent posture, in rare cases, the skin will gradually 
lose its deathlike feeling, the dampness of the skin will dry up, 
the thread of a pulse will be occasionally felt at the wrist, and 
the face will gradually assume the expression of life. These 
feeble indications of reaction must be severely left alone ; for 
the brightening spark may easily be extinguished. Nature 
must be left to finish her own work ; an early recourse to stim- 
ulants at this critical period has, in many instances, been fol- 
lowed by a speedy return to collapse, and death. Small doses 
of any grateful cordial, such as curacoa, chartreuse, absinth, 
&c, frequently repeated, may be admissible ; but the principal 
reliance should be placed on a continuance of diluents and on 
nourishment. These diluents are of prime importance in the 
latter stages of the disease. The blood has been rapidly de- 
prived of its more fluid constituents by exosmosis, and diluents 
are important, not only to allay thirst, but also to arrest exuda- 
tion, and convert it, if possible, into endosmosis. Hot green 
tea sometimes comes in play here. 



REACTION. 125 

Bowerbank says, in the prisons and hospitals of Jamaica, 
when the patients refused to snbmit to treatment, or to take 
the medicines ordered, the rule was to put the mattress on the 
floor and to lay the patient there, placing by his side a bucket 
filled with ice-water and a tin pannikin. For the most part, 
these patients received little or no further care ; certainly they 
were not rubbed and covered up with blankets, as the more 
tractable were ; but the majority of those left to their own re- 
sources got well. Dr. Hutchinson practised during the epi- 
demics of 1849 and 1854. He has seen a number of patients 
who, left to themselves, went through the collapse and reacted 
without any treatment, while in a number of other cases the 
same good result followed the use of ice and beef tea only. 
Under these circumstances, even the highest dilutions of the 
homoeopathists may honestly be supposed to be useful. 

REACTION. 

Macpherson says : If opium, lead, calomel, and other severe 
drugs, have been abstained from, nature starts fair in the stage 
of reaction, which he is sure is not the case when over- 
weighted with one or the other ; or, as he has often witnessed, 
with all of them. He has seen dangerous reaction, i. e., high 
fever, with cerebral symptoms and coma ; but only when art, 
coming, not to aid, but to thwart Nature, has interfered with 
her eliminatory processes, by the too free use of opium, 
astringents, and such like remedies. In such cases, he resorts 
to free purgation with calomel, applies ice to the head, and 
restores the action of the skin by the wet sheet, cold sponging, 
and the like. When the secretion of urine is long delayed, he 
has seen good result from the free use of chlorate of potash, 
and the application of turpentine stupes over the region of the 



126 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

kidneys. Houston prefers strychnine, gr. j., dissolved in tinc- 
ture of cantharides, §j. Sweet spirits of nitre, and small doses 
of nitrate of potash, are important remedies against the reac- 
tionary fever. 

Macpherson says, as soon as the vomiting ceases, you must 
support the patient by proper nutriment. At first he usually 
begins with thin arrowroot, well boiled, and flavored with a 
little aromatic, only a teaspoonful at a time, giving every now 
and then a teaspoonful of brandy in it, and never overloading 
or over distending the stomach. Instead of water, he now 
quenches thirst with milk, containing lime-water, and flavored 
with a few drops of curacoa ; or the milk may be given in 
soda-water. 

As reaction proceeds, he substitutes strong beef-tea, or, 
better still, essence of meat, using it in the same cautious way, 
spoonful by spoonful, at proper intervals. Later still, eggs 
beaten up with a little brandy, and flavored as before, with 
curacoa, is often relished. 

The greatest caution is required not to disgust the patient ; 
not to re-excite vomiting ; not to overstimulate, and bring on 
cerebral symptoms during the febrile reaction. 

When patients are thus carefully nursed, it is seldom that 
reaction is excessive. Nothing but mischief may be expected 
from over-anxiety to hasten convalescence by too freely pres- 
sing food and stimulants on the weakened stomach. It requires 
a great deal of coolness and patience to understand this, and 
many cases go wrong from over-anxiety. In many cases of 
cholera in Jamaica, after the patient had battled through the 
disease, he died from the effects of a heavy meal of greasy 
soup. 

But it is a great mistake to assume that the severe febrile 



ALLIANCE WITH FEVERS. 127 

reaction which often follows the collapse of cholera is always 
caused by the abuse of stimulants and opiates. Fever and 
raging delirium are apt to occur when cold water alone has 
been used during the whole course of the disease. 

ALLIANCE WITH FEVEP.S. 

In the fourth stage of cholera, or that of reaction, the 
patient is apt to suffer with a severe form of fever, which* 
Aitkin says, is in no respect dissimilar to, and not less fatal 
than, the typhoid form of typhus fever. These typhoid symp- 
toms, which are so common in Europe and America, are un- 
known, or nearly so, in India, where, if a secondary fever 
ensues, it assumes the form of the remittent fever of that 
country. But, in a few mild cases, it takes on an intermittent 
type, sometimes of a quotidian, at others of the tertian kind. 
Hersch says, it is a well-known fact, that malarial fever has 
preceded outbreaks of cholera, not only in single places or 
particular regions, but in an almost pandemic distribution, and 
there is every reason to believe that malaria and cholera de- 
vastate the same ground. Some physicians believe that cholera 
is in some strange way mixed up with intermittent and 
remittent fevers in India and the East ; and with typhoid fever 
in Europe and the West. Others have even gone so far as to 
describe cholera as an inverted typhoid fever ; it commences 
with profuse discharges, and the latter is apt to end with 
them ; the one has collapse before the fever, and the other 
afterwards, &c. : the causes of both are said to be similar 
with the difference of climate only. 

Lankester also says : There is an endemic and epidemic 
fever which is supposed by high sanitary and medical authori- 
ties to originate in the spontaneous decomposition of organic 



128 ASIATIC CHOLERA, 

matters in drains and sewers ; hence it has been called drain or 
sewer fever, but it is generally better known by the name of 
gastric or typhoid fever. That this disease is generated by a 
specific poison, has been demonstrated by Dr. Budd, of Bristol, 
and should it be capable of demonstration that this disease is 
really developed de novo by the matters of drains and sewers, 
it would be an interesting fact, as showing the possibility of a 
contagious disease being produced afresh. Tanner and Mur- 
chison wish to change the name of abdominal typhus, or 
typhoid enteric fever, into night-soil fever, or pyihogenic fever 
(literally, " born of putridity"). Tanner says, it is generated 
by putrifying animal matter ; the effluvia from foul drains, 
or the contamination of drinking-water, from decomposing 
sewage making its way into wells, are frequent sources of this 
disorder. There are many facts which show that enteric or 
typhoid fever often arises from bad drainage ; the danger is 
greatest when the drain or sewer becomes choked up, and the 
sewage stagnates and ferments ; there are numerous instances 
of enteric or typhoid fever appearing in houses having no 
communication by drains with any other dwelling, e. g., in 
isolated country houses. Tanner continues : Allowing, there- 
fore, that enteric fever is generated spontaneously by the de- 
composition of sewage and f cecal matter, we should expect to 
find it most prevalent after the long heat of summer. The 
attack may occur immediately on exposure to the miasm, 
especially where the latter is concentrated, with vomiting and 
purging, so that such cases have sometimes given rise to a 
suspicion of poisoning, as in the case of the National hotel at 
Washington, D. C. Even in milder cases, there is a tendency 
to both sickness and diarrhoea in the early stages ; but almost 
always there is diarrhoea, which generally increases towards 



ALLIANCE WITH FEVERS. 129 

the end of the second week, so that there may be then eight 
or ten stools a day, which are also remarkable in being alka- 
line (instead of acid as healthy ones are), of a putrid character, 
and for containing a large quantity of ammoniao-magnesian 
phosphate. 

Some medical men have supposed that occasionally an alli- 
ance takes place between yellow-fever and cholera. They 
both arise in hot climates, but the one from the decomposition 
of vegetable, the other of animal matter. Both affect the 
blood profoundly ; yellow-fever the red particles, and cholera 
the white blood. The hemorrhagic form of yellow-fever has 
been called the hcemo-gastric pestilence, from its tendency to 
profuse simultaneous effusions of blood from various parts 
and organs. Cholera has been termed the Jiydrorrhagic or 
sero-intestinal pestilence, from the profuse discharges of the 
serum of the blood, primarily from the bowels, and subse- 
quently from the stomach and skin, which characterize it. 



130 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 



SPECIAL REMEDIES. 

ICE. 

Cold checks cholera, and is a preservative and disinfectant. 
Bodies greatly cooled cannot decay, and animal matter seems 
capable of being preserved to endless time by cold ; witness 
the frozen elephants and mammoths of Northern Russia, which 
have remained for ages. Ice has proved highly efficacious 
in cholera. When employed alone, the mortality was only 
thirty per cent., which is very low, compared with cases in 
which stimulants and opiates were employed. It relieves, in a 
remarkable manner, the burning heat at the pit of the stomach 
and the insatiable thirst ; it arrests the vomiting, and contrib- 
utes greatly to excite reaction. Although it is a remedy of the 
highest promise, it will probably not prove as useful in America 
as in Europe, for we are accustomed to its daily use. In ad- 
dition to chewing and sucking it frequently, a bit should be 
swallowed immediately after each dose of medicine. 

Johnson says there is no evidence to prove that the appli- 
cation of ice to the spine has been useful in any case. It is 
only certain that some patients will recover in spite of it. 

COLD WATER. 

This was first proposed and carried into practice by Dr„ 
Shute, of Gloucester, from whose experience and that of others 
it seems certain that the free internal use of cold water is pro- 
ductive of the most beneficial effects, and that when it is with- 
held, the rate of mortality has been much higher than when it 
is allowed. Wherever cold water formed the base of the 
treatment, the ratio of deaths was very much lower than when 



HOT WATER AND DRINKS. 131 

stimulants, and, in fact, any other remedies, have been employed. 
Dr. Shute says, under the cold water system the state of col- 
lapse is sometimes prolonged to two, three, or four days ; and 
others have remarked that during* the reaction a paroxysm of 
raging delirium is apt to occur. It is not, therefore, an inopera- 
tive system. The cold water is supposed to act by supplying to 
the blood the serum it loses by the intestinal evacuations ; also 
by taking up the urea, determining to the kidneys, and reliev- 
ing the blood of the presence of this poisonous agent. When 
water is used it should be as cold as procurable, and preferably 
iced; it should be taken in large and repeated draughts, and 
although for the first four or five times it may be rejected, its 
use should be persevered in. It soon remains on the stomach, 
and when this is effected, a beneficial change in the state of 
the patient is soon observable. The intense thirst which 
usually accompanies cholera, would alone justify the adoption 
of this treatment. Whatever other treatment is adopted, cold 
water in copious draughts will prove a valuable auxiliary, 
perfectly safe, agreeable to the patient, and likely to be pro- 
ductive of the best effects. 

HOT WATER AND DRINKS. 

Ice water relieves the sensation of heat, and it has a pow- 
erful influence in checking vomiting before and during im- 
pending collapse, but are these sufficient reasons for giving 
iced water to a patient mfull collapse ? In Johnson's opinion 
they are not. He is sure that vomiting, when not excessive, is 
beneficial, and he believes that ice-water lessens the vomiting 
and the burning sensation in the stomach by diminishing the 
vascularity of the mucous membrane, and thus interfering with 
the excretion of the morbid poison, upon the ejection of which 



132 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

the patient's recovery depends. For these reasons, he believes 
that the administration of ice-water to a patient in collapse is 
injurious. In most cases he would allow an unlimited quan- 
tity of water of the temperature of the room ; but in extreme 
collapse, he would persuade the patient to drink hot liquids, 
with a view to add some warmth to the blood. Hot fluids 
should then also be injected into the bowels ; and if the kidneys 
act scantily, or not at all, the bladder may be injected full, from 
time to time, with warm or hot fluids. In deep collapse, Stev- 
ens' saline solution, heated to one hundred or one hundred and 
twenty degrees, has often been injected into the veins; always 
with temporary, and occasionally with permanent benefit ; 
although the interior of the body in full collapse is so chilled 
that when these injections return they are quite cold. The 
stools and vomits in full collapse are quite cold ; and when Cae- 
sarian section is performed immediately after, or just before 
death, the foetus and uterus are found equally cold. Hence the 
use of hot fluids and injections seems rational. I would sug- 
gest very hot injections of a strong solution of sulphate of iron. 
This is one of the best disinfectants, tonics, and astringents, 
and will also tend to remove the deeply venous and asphyx- 
iated condition more than any other remedy. Hot green tea, 
with brandy or rum in it, has been successfully used in Paris. 

HEAT. 

The royal committee say, the application of heat to the sur- 
face in various ways has been largely tried, and it appearstobe 
the uniform experience of the profession, that in collapse this 
means is of but little value. The whole tendency of the evi- 
dence yet acquired for the treatment of this stage is towards 
a more restricted use of poweful excitants of this kind. 



HEAT. 133 

Annesley declares that the warm bath does more harm than 
good ; the fatigue arising from going in and coming out of it, 
and from rubbing and dressing the patient, exhausts him. 
Christie found the bath injurious. Parkes did not see a sin- 
gle case in which the warm bath appeared beneficial, and he 
has seen a man walk firmly to the bath with a pulse of tolera- 
ble volume, and a cool, but not cold skin, and seen the same man 
carried back in five or ten minutes with a pulse almost imper- 
ceptible, and a cold clammy surface. Johnson says, while the 
hot-air bath appeared to relieve the cramps and sometimes im- 
proved the pulse, yet on the whole the patients appeared to 
be distressed rather than comforted by it. Still there can be 
no question that to thoroughly warm a patient in collapse is 
often a real benefit, for the pulse, temperature, and color of the 
skin, and the expression of the features, all improve simulta- 
neously. A very convenient and safe way of keeping up the 
warmth of the body is by the application of hot bottles, hot 
dry flannels, and hot sand-bags, to various parts of the surface. 
Slacking several pieces of quick-lime placed on plates in the 
bed, is a rapid, convenient, and the most efficacious way of 
producing great warmth without disturbing the patient or 
injuring his skin. Macpherson says most emphatically that 
the parboiling system has had its advocates, and hundreds 
of living East Indian practitioners can testify to the fatality, to 
say the least, of this method, even when mustard has been 
added. To take a man in the collapsed and pulseless stage of 
cholera, out of the horizontal position, where alone there is 
hope of safety, and to plunge him in this condition into a 
bath heated to the highest bearable degree of temperature, 
short of scalding, to which mustard in large quantities has been 
added to make it more stimulating, is about the surest method 



134 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

that can be taken to exhaust the little remains of vitality left. 
Experience has abundantly proved this ; for so many men have 
actually perished in the baths that the practice has long since 
been abandoned in India. But all dirty patients, even if deeply 
collapsed, should have one thorough salt or chlorine bath to 
thoroughly cleanse and disinfect their hair and skin. Still the 
patient should never be allowed to assist himself. He should 
be lifted in and out, and helped in every possible way. Flan- 
nels soaked in hot mustard-water may then be wrapped around 
his body and limbs. 

SALT WATER. 

Bowerbank, of Jamaica, thought he saw more good from the 
use of Stevens' powders than from any other mode of treat- 
ment; in fact, in 1854, he confined himself chiefly to these. 
Having read of the use of sea-water in the treatment of cholera, 
and from the difficulty of getting the powders, Br. Campbell 
and him? elf concluded to give sea-water a trial among the 
prisoners of the general penitentiary at Kingston, Jamaica. 
They had buckets of sea-water brought from a distance from 
the shore, and this well iced ; it was doled out in small quan- 
tities to the sufferers, who drank it greedily, and, strange to 
say, of seventeen cases who took it, all recovered. Unfortu- 
nately it was not tried till towards the decline of the epidemic. 
In almost every case, after the fourth or sixth dose, the alvine 
discharges became tinged with bile, as also the contents of the 
stomach vomited. From the results of this experiment, he 
has made up his mind to give sea-water another fair trial if he 
ever witnesses another epidemic. In fact, if attacked himself, 
he would rely on the saline treatment and sea-water well iced. 



SALT. 



135 



SALT. 

This is one of the best antiseptics and disinfectants. Waring 
thinks there is but little doubt that salt is of the highest value 
in cholera ; but says the fact must not be overlooked that cold 
water ad libitum was allowed in addition ; and in all cases in 
which cold water was used freely the mortality has been les3 
than when it was withheld. The patient may be placed in a 
hot bath at one hundred and twenty degrees, in which four- 
teen to twenty pounds of salt is dissolved. Injections of hot 
salt water into the bowels are said, by Stevens himself, to be 
more reliable than injections into the veins, in full collapse. 
Stevens, Yenables, Pidduck, Hastings, Goodrich, and others, 
gave two tablespoonfuls of table salt, dissolved in four to eight 
ounces of cold water, repeated every quarter of an hour, until 
free vomiting was produced, and then cold water in large 
draughts was advised to allay the insatiable thirst and heat of 
the stomach caused by the salt. Beaman gave three table- 
spoonfuls in half a pint of cold or tepid water. It restored 
the secretion of bile, diminished the cramps, increased the 
fulness of the pulse, and the voice became stronger and the 
strength greater ; but in twenty or thirty minutes the pulse 
may begin to flag, strength decrease, and cramps come back, 
when the salt must be repeated a second or third time. The 
latter is rarely necessary. Thus given, salt often produces 
vomiting in less than one minute. Of six hundred and seven 
cases treated in this manner only one hundred and twelve 
died, or about twenty per cent. Hastings lost sixteen cases 
out of sixty-two under the salt treatment, and double that num- 
ber when he used opium and stimulants ; but G-oodrich lost the 
whole of twelve cases in deep hopeless collapse. Pidduck 
gave as much as from four to eight ounces of table salt in a 



136 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

small quantity of water, or nearly a saturated solution, in 
eighty-six cases of full collapse, with a loss of only sixteen. 

SALINES. 

The saline treatment is based upon the attempt to restore to 
the blood the fluids and salts which have been poured out in 
the profuse cholera discharges. It is evident that at best this 
can be but palliative and auxiliary. All the water and salines 
which are drank, and injected into the bowels, bladder, and 
veins, will be simply poured out again until the hydrorrhagia 
from the stomach and bowels is controlled. It is not until 
absorption begins again that any good can result from their 
employment. 

ALKALIES. 

One of the most striking features of cholera is, that all the 
discharges are acid — none have ever been found to be alkaline ; 
the stools are acid as well as the vomits ; and the blood itself, 
which is naturally alkaline, becomes neutral, and even acid. 
Wakefield treated upward of one hundred and fifty cases of 
choleraic diarrhoea, with thirty grains of sesquicarbonate of 
soda, in a wineglass of strong mint tea, every half hour. He 
says no fatal case occurred — the disease was arrested with al- 
most magical rapidity ; and he rarely had occasion to administer 
more than three doses before the nausea, vomiting, and diarrhoea, 
were arrested. The patient was confined to a diet of beef tea, 
cocoa, or arrowroot. No solid food — not even bread — was 
allowed. We have already quoted Bowerbank's experience 
with soda and ginger. 

Beaman gave carb. soda, one half drachm, in two or three 
ounces of water, with the addition of four or five teaspoonfuls 



ALKALIES AND ACIDS. 13t 

of fresh lemon juice, taken while effervescing, every hour, 
for three or four doses ; then every four hours. For forty- 
eight hours he gave no other medicine. Generally, on the day 
after the attack, the patient passed a small faecal evacuation, 
containing bile ; if he did not, a few grains of rhubarb, aided 
by the sulphate of manganese, may be administered ; or inspis- 
sated ox-gall, or aloes. The patient may drink as much water, 
or toast water, cold or tepid, as may be wished, and no other 
beverage. For the next twenty-four hours, Beaman gave only 
weak black tea and thin arrowroot ; on the next day, broth or 
light meat. 

The saline treatment is almost similar to the alkaline. Ste- 
vens gave : sodas carb., 3ss. ; sodii chlorid, 9j ; potass chlorat., 
gr. vij. ; every fifteen or sixty minutes. The quantity of chlor- 
ate of potash is ridiculously small. 

ACIDS. 

Notwithstanding the acid condition of the blood and all the 
secretions in cholera, the treatment by acids, especially sul- 
phuric acid, is almost the fashionable mode now. Fuller first 
introduced it in the treatment of English cholera, in which 
it is doubtless more useful than in the Asiatic form. Still, 
McCormac put a stop to an epidemic in the Belfast Asylum by 
administering a daily dose of a drachm of dilute sulphuric 
acid in an ounce of peppermint water. No subsequent cases 
occurred. Dr. Worms, chief of the military hospital at Gros 
Caillou, in Paris, relied altogether upon it in 1865, in half- 
hourly doses. It may be given in barley water, thin arrow- 
root, or syrup of raspberries, lemons, or ginger. It is apt to 
injure the teeth, unless the mouth is rinsed immediately with 
a solution of soda. Elixir vitriol, and the muriate tincture of 

7* 



138 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

iron, given in glycerine, or syrup of ginger, are said to have 
succeeded when the other failed. Still, I think alum or iron- 
alum will be found far more safe and useful, although sul- 
phuric acid is said to be not only a disinfectant, but a styptic, 
and to cure the white-blood haemorrhage of cholera in the same 
way that it does red-blood haemorrhage. Phosphoric acid is 
more pleasant and useful, and does not injure the teeth. 

EMETICS. 

These are rarely given until the stomach is involved, and 
then they are washed away by the outpouring tide of serum. 
The large doses of ipecac, and tartar-emetic given by some 
physicians are generally as harmless and useless as the small 
ones given by the homoeopathists. At one time Mustard 
emetics were much employed, but were soon discarded, as 
experience proved their injurious influences in the stage of 
collapse, for then they frequently failed to produce vomiting, 
and their retention during the stage of reaction, in the form of 
an internal mustard-plaster on the delicate lining membrane of 
the stomach necessarily produced much evil. Table salt is far 

preferable. 

Ipecac. 

Ipecac, has been given in quarter grain, or small nauseating 
doses. Some homoeopathists give one twentieth grain, or like 
Vehsemeyer, from four to ten drops of the tincture every 
quarter, half, or one hour ; others, like Reil, say, it is useless 
against the premonitions of cholera. Waring says, the mor- 
tality has been very large under its use, when given in full 
emetic doses. Others say, it has been given successfully in 
five or ten grain doses every five or ten minutes. It causes 
violent attempts at vomiting, but after three or four doses 



EMETICS AND PURGATIVES. 139 

tolerance is established. In the Paris hospitals, in 1865, ten 
to twenty grains of ipecac, were given whenever there was 
much vomiting. 

Tartar-Emetic, 

This remedy has been used in cholera, although Wood, and 
Surgeon Mills, U. S. A., say, the symptoms are more like those 
produced by an overdose of tartrate of antimony than anything 
they can compare them to. Kurtz, and other homceopathists, 
use teaspoonful doses of a solution of one-grain, in one or two 
ounces of water. Others says, that one grain doses every 
twenty minutes have been given successfully ; or tablespoon- 
ful doses every half hour, of a solution of four or five grains 
in four ounces of water. Billings, and others, gave three- 
grain doses every hour, followed by one grain, of opium, and 
claim that they only lost four cases out of twenty-one, or nine- 
teen per cent. ; while under calomel the loss was thirty-six per 
cent.; and under stimulants, fifty-eight per cent. Littleton 
gave five-grain doses every twelve minutes till the vomiting 
ceased ; then forty to fifty grains of calomel. When the full 
flood of the disease is going on these dangerous doses are 
washed away and do neither harm nor good. But when this 
tide is stopped they become deadly ; thus, in Colonel Pearie's 
French regiment of one thousand men, seven hundred died in 
six days, under full doses of tartar-emetic. 

PURGATIVES. 

Dr. Davey assumes that purgatives do not act as such in 
cholera, but restrain the diarrhoea, and effectually check the 
intestinal discharges ; they act as restoratives of the normal 
character of the secretions, and establish healthy faecal dis- 
charges. He prefers calomel and ext. coloc. co., taken fre- 



140 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

quently and alternately with a mixture of castor-oil and tur- 
pentine. Aitkin says, the action of cholera most nearly 
resembles that of Elaterium, or the squirting cucumber. 
Thus, during the period of transudation, which only lasts 
about thirty-six hours, the water of the blood passes off be- 
fore the solids of the serum ; then the salts, before the organic 
solids, such as albumen and fibrin ; the chlorides, before the 
phosphates ; the salts of soda before those of potash. It is 
interesting to note that this order of expulsion is very much 
the same as that caused by the action of elaterium. Very- 
soon after the constituents of the serum, or white blood com- 
mence to run off, an important change takes place in the red 
blood ; the contents of the red globules transude into the 
serum, the water passing out first, then the salts, then the 
chlorides and soda salts, and lastly the phosphates. The 
blood globules are left shrivelled and dark. 

One would suppose that purgatives would be carefully 
avoided in this disease. But McGregor has given three doses 
of five drops each of Croton oil, combined with three-grain 
doses of opium ; he says the vomiting and purging will cease, 
the cold and clammy skin become warm and moist, and the 
tongue and expired air will no longer be cold. Thorne re- 
gards Croton oil, combined with opium, as an invaluable 
remedy, which will arrest many cases of vomiting, purging, 
and cramps, at onoe. McPherson says Croton oil and opium 
pills were once regarded as infallible : they are not so now. 
As turpentine enemas were also used, it is to be supposed that 
they and the opium prevented the otherwise deadly effects of 
the Croton oil. But the tolerance of such large doses only 
proves how low the vitality of the stomach and bowels sinks 
in severe cases of cholera and collapse. No one, not even the 



PURGATIVES. 141 

homceopathists, have ventured on the use of elaterium. The 
latter rely upon veratrum, although Yehsemeyer says it is 
useless, both when given in dilutions and massive doses. 
Schweick lost ten cases out of thirty-three, with it. 

Castor Oil 

George Johnson claims to have cured twelve cases out of 
fifteen, in collapse, with §ss. doses of castor oil, every half 
hour, till twenty-two or fifty-four ounces had been given ; but 
other physicians lost eighty cases out of one hundred and 
eight. As the tongue is cold in collapse, and the sense of 
taste not very acute, there was no difficulty in giving it in ice- 
water. But he gave cold water ad libitum; also, an occasional 
emetic of salt, which seemed to rescue some of the castor oil 
patients from an almost fatal lethargy ; and two-drachm doses 
of spirits of turpentine occasionally, as a wholesome stimulant 
during the stage of icy coldness ; and applied large mustard- 
poultices over the abdomen. 

Calomel 

This has been given because it was assumed that there is a 
suppression of bile in cholera. But the gall bladder is always 
full in this disease ; and Parkes and Simon have found that 
bile is always present in the cholera evacuations, but in a 
modified form ; heat and nitric acid together will always ren- 
der it manifest. Stillson, of Malta, gave twenty-grain doses 
every half or one hour during the stage of collapse ; in all, he 
administered eighty-seven thousand grains to three hundred 
and seventy-three patients. One man took eleven hundred and 
sixty grains and recovered ; but the mortality was fifty-two 
per cent., or about the same as if no medicine at all had been 



142 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

taken. Drs. Ayre and Peacock gave one or two grains, with 
from one to five drops of laudanum, every five, ten, or fifteen 
minutes, and lost three hundred and sixty-five cases out of 
seven hundred and twenty-five. Macpherson says calomel has 
been used to fulfil every indication in turn, according to the 
peculiar belief of the prescriber. Some gave it as a purgative, 
others as a sedative, and not a few as an alterative ; or to 
stimulate all, or many of the secretions ; or to stop the vomit- 
ing. Then a numerous class gave it for no reason in particu- 
lar. It was the so-called trump card in their hands, and, like or- 
dinary whist-players, when in doubt, as men are apt to be when 
dealing with cholera, they played trumps, i. e.,gave calomel. He 
has seen it given in every conceivable way, and for every possi- 
ble and impossible end ; in grain doses every half or one hour, 
and in scruple doses, again and again. It is of no use during 
the collapse, but by-and-by, when the powers of life begin to 
revive again, the first thing the system has to do is, to contend 
with and dispose of more or less calomel. One of the first 
results is very often vomiting of that green paint looking 
matter, which is so hard to stop ; or bilious diarrhoea is excited, 
which may soon bring the case to an unfavorable end. At the 
best, it disturbs the stomach and interferes with nutrition at 
the very time when nature needs the wisely cautious helping 
hand of the physician to assist her when struggling for exist- 
ence, and when she should not be searched and goaded with 
powerful drugs, prescribed no matter with what intention. 
If given during the collapse it accumulates like water behind 
a barrier, and when the functions begin to be restored, and 
the barrier gives way, nothing but harm results. Why, says 
Macpherson, concentrate all our attention upon the bile ? 
Why not stimulate the kidneys also ? Is the biliary secretion 



ASTRINGENTS. 143 

any more in abeyance than this, or any other secretion? 
Macpherson thinks these pertinent questions ; and recom- 
mends all, to put them to themselves, when tempted in moments 
of doubt, or enthusiasm to prescribe wildly. If given at all, 
it should be combined with large doses of camphor. 

ASTRINGENTS. 

Macpherson says, no class of remedies have been more used in 
cholera ; the great anxiety has ever been to restrain the evac- 
uations. Yet he is persuaded that mere purging rarely kills, 
and in the most fatal form of cholera there is no purging, or 
very little. He might as well assume that no one ever bleeds 
to death ; and he knows full well that internal hydrorrhagia is as 
fatal as internal haemorrhage. Still he thinks that nitrate of silver 
deserves a more extended trial, for in one epidemic he found 
it exceedingly useful as an astringent in excessive purging. 
Some of his native pupils used it extensively during the same 
epidemic in Hyderabad, and with so much success as to gain 
for themselves considerable reputation. He used it again in 
the following year with disappointing results — another proof 
of the varying constitution of epidemics. Garlike used, suc- 
cessfully, injections of sixteen grains of nitrate of silver in 
four ounces of water, thrown high up into the colon by means 
of a flexible tube. Others, give one grain of the nitrate in a 
pill, with or without a quarter of a grain of opium every hour, 
for four or six doses. 

Tinct. Ferri Muriat. 

Hancom says the principal effect produced by cholera poi- 
son appears to be an atony of the secretory and excretory 
ducts and mucous folhcles ; it therefore follows, as a natural 



144 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

indication, to restore power and tone to these vessels as 
speedily as possible, and this is best effected by the adminis- 
tration of styptics. His sheet anchor in real Asiatic cholera 
was the muriate tincture of iron, in as concentrated a form as 
possible, given immediately after every dejection ; its immedi- 
ate effect in reducing the quantity of fluid ejected was truly 
astonishing, and this gradually diminished after every dose, 
until it ceased altogether, and a cure was effected. The evacua- 
tions become black after a while. He also used a liniment of 
strong sulphuric acid 5j«, olive oil §iss ; and the hot air bath, 
by means of a small spirit lamp, and an apparatus under the bed 
clothes. He strongly urges the avoidance of brandy, and large 
doses of opium ; for they both do more harm than good. The 
agonizing thirst and intense heat in the hypogastric region, he 
thinks, is best allayed by the free use of iced soda water, and 
iced champagne, or small pieces of ice retained in the mouth 
and swallowed occasionally. 

Sir James Murray gave from five to ten grain doses of iron- 
alum in mint, or some other aromatic water. Sulphate of 
iron, pernitrate of iron, gallic acid, tannin, and matico, deserve 
attention. Tinct. matico in 5ss. to 5j- doses, is said to be very 
useful. Turpentine, and kreosote, and the aromatic elixir of 
ergot should not be forgotten. 

Acetate of Lead, 

Although the tonic astringents should commend themselves 
to every one, the sedative astringents have been far more fre- 
quently used. The latter may be allowable in the earlier 
stages of the disease, but become dangerous or useless in .the 
more advanced periods. Graves first recommended plumb, acet. 
9j. ; opii gr. j. ; and confect. rosse q. s., to make twelve pills ; 



STIMULANTS. 145 

one every hour. Thome found gr. ij-iij. of the acetate with one 
eighth grain of morphine, a most valuable remedy for checking 
the profuse watery dejections. Houston says, every practi- 
tioner is prone to settle down upon some favorite prescrip- 
tion, and the following is the one upon which he finally relied 
with most confidence, after having given a fair trial to many 
others : Acet. Plumbi, gr. xxiv. ; pulv. camphor 33 gr. xxiv. ; 
morphine gr. ij-iij. ; olie cinnamomi gutt. v. ; mucilage q. s. ; 
make twelve pills, and give one every two, three, or four 
hours. It is chiefly applicable to the premonitory stage, and 
it is asserted that nearly every case will recover under its use* 

Copper. 

Dupuytren relied on acetate of copper. Neligan recom- 
mended : 

Cupri sulphat gr. vj. ; myrrhae gr. xij. ; conserv. rosse 9ij. ; 
make twelve pills and give one every one, two, or six hours. 
Joy advises : 

Cupri sulph. gr. ss. ; opii pulv. gr. ss. ; confect. rosse q. s., to 
make one pill ; to be taken from three to six times a day. The 
homceopathists rely much upon small doses of copper, or cu- 
prum, especially in the spasmodic stage, although some of 
them give it in doses of one tenth of a grain. 

STIMULANTS. 

Waring says, these were formerly considered an indispensa- 
ble and invariable resource ; but of their real value many 
doubts are entertained at the present day. It appears certain 
that the indiscriminate use of stimulants, especially the more 
diffusible ones, as brandy, if given in very large quantities, 
and in a concentrated form, so far from being beneficial, are 



146 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

often actually injurious. Whenever excessive stimulation forms 
a prominent part of the treatment, the ratio of deaths is increased. 
Thus, under ipecac, alone, the deaths were fifty-seven per 
cent; when combined with stimulants, they rose to sixty- 
seven per cent. ; and in the case of ice, stimulants increased 
the mortality from thirty to fifty per cent. Excessive stimula- 
tion must tend to exhaust the diminished nervous tone ; and 
there are few points in medicine which require more care and 
discrimination than the selection of the proper cases and 
proper periods of administering stimulants in cholera. No 
rule can be laid down, except that it is certain they should not 
be given in the excessive quantities formerly prescribed and 
advised — they should be given more or less largely diluted ; 
and should not be trusted to alone. 

Macpherson says, stimulants, both of a medicinal and alco- 
holic kind, have been much resorted to in cholera, and very 
naturally. The prostration of the powers, both of the circu- 
latory and nervous systems, is so extreme that we cannot 
wonder that strenuous efforts been made to rouse and sustain 
them by the free use of remedies of this class. Yet, he thinks 
that those who have used them most, if observant and candid 
men, must admit they have not answered their expectations ; 
at the least, all must allow they require to be given with a cau- 
tious hand. They are useful when given at the proper time 
and in the right way ; he does not think they are of any use 
during the collapse, when at first sight or thought they might 
appear most appropriate or necessary. 

Houston says, when the patient is not seen until the com- 
mencement of the second stage, the symptoms seem to demand 
the use of the most powerful stimulants and anodynes, and it 
is here that the physician is called on to exercise all his for- 



STIMULANTS. 141 

bearance, and display all his decision of character. Having 
used himself, and having witnessed in others, the use of every 
variety of stimulants, and in all doses during the second stage, 
he was forced to the conclusion, that, as a general rule, they 
did no good, and in many cases did positive harm. Their 
effect often was to depress still further the already waning 
organic sensibility, and, even in the few cases where this sen- 
sibility was aroused by these means and reaction produced, it 
was too apt to end in fatal congestion of the brain. This 
happened in many cases ireated in the early part of the first 
. epidemic. When feeble signs of reaction from collapse occur, 
they should not be interfered with ; Nature having commenced, 
must be left to finish her own work. The renewal of stimu- 
lation at this period, has, in many instances, caused a speedy 
return to eollapse and death. The principal reliance should be 
placed on a continuance of diluents, and the introduction of 
liquid nourishment as soon as the appetite calls for, or the con- 
dition of the stomach will bear it. Bowerbank is quite certain 
that, in the epidemic of 1850, in Jamaica, he saw much mis- 
chief done by the use of spirituous stimulants and opiates, so 
that, in the epidemic of 1854, he almost entirely banished these 
remedies from his practice. George Johnson says, again and 
again, he has seen a collapse-patient grow colder, and his pulse 
diminish in volume and power, after a dose of brandy, and ap- 
parently as a direct result of the brandy. 

Yet all these physicians give stimulants occasionally. Mac- 
pherson prefers small quantities of brandy or curacoa ; Hous- 
ton, small doses of any grateful cordial, such as Absinth, or 
t Kiimmel, perhaps. In Paris, in 1865, green Chartreuse was 
largely relied upon. It is said that, in the Hotel Dieu and the 
Hospital Lariboisiere, one in three recovered after having 



148 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

reached a very advanced stage of collapse, before reception, 
under the free use of rum and hot tea ; in the proportion of one 
hundred and twenty-five parts of Jamaica rum to eight hun- 
dred and seventy-five parts of strong and hot green tea. 

In the earlier stages of cholera, small quantities of stimulants 
may or may not be used. As the disease progresses, the quan- 
tities may be cautiously increased, and should always be given 
in some vehicle, like gum-water, orgeat, milk and lime water, 
green tea, or beef tea. When the full tide of the colliquation 
is going on, the largest quantities and strongest varieties are 
swept away like water, and are neither useful nor injurious. 
In the full collapse, when all discharges have ceased, and ab- 
sorption has not commenced, brandy, hartshorn, and red pep- 
per, He as inert as flour and water. But, when reaction and 
absorption begin, if very large quantities of active stimulants 
have accumulated in the stomach and bowels, the patient will 
die, as if poisoned with pint (or quart) doses of alcohol ; his 
face will become turgid and livid, or deadly pale and sunken ; 
vomiting may follow, with involuntary discharges of urine 
and faeces ; the pulse may become small and frequent, or slow 
and laboring ; and general insensibility, an apoplectic sleep, 
spasm of the muscles, coldness of the extremities, hurried, ir- 
regular, or sterterory breathing, and all the signs of venous 
congestion and asphyxia will appear. 

Turpentine. 
As a stimulating astringent, Surgeon Major Mudge, of the 
Madras army, made a trial of turpentine, in an egg emulsion, 
with an aromatic ; and in a number of cases found it more than 
answer his expectations. It does not seem to have caused 
vomiting, or even nausea, although it is generally a nauseous 
medicine. 



TONICS. 149 

Ammonia. 
A Dr, Anderson claims to have cured over one thousand 
cases of cholerine and cholera, with drachm doses of the aro- 
matic spirits of ammonia, every half or one hour, in a claret- 
glass of seltzer, or some other sparkling water. If he had 
said ten cases, or one hundred, one would feel more inclined 
to believe him. George Johnson says, in a few cases he gave 
carbonate of ammonia with apparent benefit, and thinks it 
deserves further trial as a stimulant during the stage of col- 
lapse. Surgeon Abadie, U. S. A., says, that aqua-ammonise in 
drachm doses, diluted in a few ounces of brandy toddy, with 
sulphuric ether, proved advantageous. Dr. Burgess used 
Phosphorus successfully in several cases of the lowest collapse. 

TONICS. 

The best, are : quinine, sulphate of iron, nux vomica, and 

strychnine. 

Quinine. 

Von Graefe and Schlegel have used it successfully as a pro- 
phylactic. At Rangoon the treatment of cholera was by large 
and repeated doses of quinine, but without any encouraging 
success. The fact is, that while the vomiting is urgent, the 
quinine is only flushed away and wasted. But when the 
powers of life were just beginning to fail, small doses of quinine, 
washed down with iced soda-water, or an ordinary effervescing 
draught, appeared advantageous. When larger doses were 
given, the first few might be vomited away, and the patient 
seem in more or less danger for forty-eight hours, but then 
strong-smelling evacuations and discharges of urine would 
occur for the first time, followed by febrile reaction, with con- 



150 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

gestion to the head ; but a more or less speedy convalescence 
would ensue. Sargent treated seventeen collapse cases, with 
thirteen recoveries. 

Sulphate of Iron. 

In the earlier stages, and during convalescence, grain doses 
of quinine, with two or three grains of sulphate of iron, have 
been used successfully, when aided by two to four, or six 
ounces of beef broth occasionally. In collapse cases, grain 
doses of sulphate of iron four times a day will not suffice, as 
Sargent lost three cases in succession. 

Strychnine. 

C. E. Jenkins gave strychnine, gr. j., and conserve of roses 
sufficient to form eighteen pills ; one to be given every quar- 
ter of an hour, and washed down with copious draughts of 
cold water, which the patient will greedily and gratefully im- 
bibe. The first three or four pills will probably be ejected, 
but the subsequent ones retained, and their good effects 
speedily perceived. The strychnine being the most powerful 
tonic known, acts in that capacity on the prostrate nervous 
system ; and the cold water, in the first place, replaces the 
loss of the fluids, and in the next, by its coldness, constringes 
the papillse of the mucous membrane, thus suppressing their 
outpourings ; and, lastly, by its volume it distends and gives 
tone to the otherwise empty and flaccid intestinal tube. 

It was used in forty-seven cases by Dr. Lee ; in moderately 
severe cases, it controlled the discharges without producing, 
like opium and other stimulants, a subsequent violent re- 
action. 



TONICS. 151 

Nux vomica and strychnine may act in another way. George 
Johnson says if we carefully observe the condition of a patient 
in collapse, we will often find that the intestines are more or 
less distended with fluid ; and this, too, while perhaps there is 
a general torpor, and very little effort at expulsion. In this 
condition, those remedies which act so powerfully and spe- 
cifically on the muscular system, may stimulate the muscular 
coat of the bowels to contract, and not only force out of the 
body the fluids which have already been poured out of the 
blood-vessels into the alimentary canal, but may bring on a 
tonic contraction of the intestinal capillaries, and thus check a 
farther drain from the blood. 

In the collapse stage, Houston, of Eichmond, says there is 
one remedy on which, from past experience, he should be dis- 
posed to place much reliance in the future ; he alludes to a 
solution of strychnine, in tincture of cantharides ; one grain to 
the ounce. In the epidemic of 1847, he saw several patients 
apparently snatched from the brink of collapse by the use of 
this combination ; he gave ten drops, every five minutes, in a 
teaspoonful of brandy and water, till improvement occurred, 
and then at longer intervals. The effect was too prompt, and 
was produced too often, to be considered accidental. All 
remedies, to do good in cholera, must act either by putting a 
stop to the liquid drain from the blood and chyle bearing ves- 
sels, or by exciting to increased power and activity the 
great ganglionic centres. Now, strychnine, says Houston, is 
known to act more promptly and powerfully on the nerve cen- 
tres of animal life than any other article of the materia medica, 
and it is fair to presume that, either directly, or through the 
animal centres, it may produce alike powerful effect on the 
organic centres. 



152 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

When the looseness was troublesome and continuous, tend- 
ing to dysentery, as is so common after an attack of cholera, 
Bowerbank, of Jamaica, found strychnine of much service, 
either alone or in combination with iron. He generally gave 
Marshall Hall's formula. 

NARCOTICS. 

Opium. 

Large doses of opium change the arterial blood into venous, 
and produce that state of coldness, blueness, lividity, and 
asphyxia, which prevails in the collapse of cholera. Small 
doses, especially when combined with larger quantities of 
camphor, ammonia, oil of cajeput, tincture of cardamoms, 
capsicum, &c, may occasionally be allowed. 

Macpherson declares that no remedy has been more used 
or rather abused, than opium, and that most East Indian prac- 
titioners have abandoned it as treacherous and dangerous. 
He earnestly cautions against its use, for it is useless, even if 
retained, during the stage of collapse ; but when reaction sets 
in, the opium, previously inert, begins to be absorbed and act, 
and at once becomes a serious hindrance to the restoration of 
the secretions ; and if the quantity has been large, it often has- 
tens on cerebral symptoms, ending in coma. These are its dan- 
gers, without, so far as he knows, or ever could discover, a 
single compensating advantage. 

Mr. Ross says, either alone, or in combination with calomel, 
stimulants or antispasmodics were formerly regarded as indis- 
pensable in the treatment of cholera. This idea is now gen- 
erally considered as erroneous, as a very high rate of mortality 
has followed all those cases in which opiunr]forms a prominent 
part of the treatment. It has been given, observes Mr. Ross, 



NARCOTICS. 153 

with a view of relieving the cramps and spasms, but the 
internal congestion which it produces has undoubtedly proved 
injurious. The use of opiates has been carried too far ; they 
have locked up the biliary secretion, choked the capillaries of 
the brain with black blood, and overpowered and deadened 
the nervous sensibility, which ought to be sustained by every 
effort and appliance, as the only meaus left us, in the states of 
collapse, for rallying the declining powers of the patient. 
Blacklock regards it as poison in this disease. W. J. Cox says 
it is quite powerless to check the vomiting or purging, or to 
relieve the cramps, and is totally inadmissible in any stage, or 
any dose. Waring says the last opinion is perhaps too sweep- 
ing ; for in minute doses, as employed by Dr, Ayre, it appeared 
to have a beneficial effect ; but that it is positively injurious 
in large and frequent doses, either alone, or in combination, is 
a fact that few will be inclined to doubt, after the experience 
of the last few years. 

Waring says, in epidemic cholera the efficiency of opium is 
no better established than that of the greater number of reme- 
dies employed against this fatal malady. There is no evidence 
whatever that it is beneficial in very severe cases, and scarcely 
any of the manner in which it exerts its influence in those of a 
milder type ; or what symptoms it palliates, or how far it 
shortens the duration of the disease. Unquestionably opium 
has prevented the development of many a case of Asiatic 
cholera, by subduing those premonitory symptoms which 
have received the name of cholerine. For this purpose, indeed, 
its value is very great, yet not so much so, as to exceed that of 
camphor, with aromatic and diffusible stimulants and mild as- 
tringents, especially of the tonic kind, such as sulphate or per- 
nitrate of iron, and iron-alum. It is depended upon in a very 



154 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

small number only of cases of the fully-formed disease, and it 
would almost seem as if it ought to be omitted in the graver 
forms of Asiatic cholera. 

Morphine — Hypodermic Injection. 

Dr. Willis had recourse to the hypodermic injection of mor- 
phia as speedily as possible in all cases where the stomach was 
so irritable and the bowels so loose as to be incapable of re- 
taining anything ; he selected a point over the stomach and 
great ganglia. The most convenient solution is made by boiling 
five grains of acetate of morphia, in as much distilled water as 
will make a drachm when cold ; he injected twelve minims, or 
the equivalent of one grain of morphia, with a graduated 
syringe, repeated at such intervals and in such quantities as 
the cases required. It was of the greatest service in pre- 
venting intractable choleraic diarrhoea from running into col- 
lapse, which is not always so easy of accomplishment as 
most writers assume. Injecting the veins with warm water 
has a wonderfully reviving power, and although only temporary, 
enables the morphia to act in advanced stages of the disease. 
Medicated injections are not useless, and transfusion of blood 
may be beneficial. 

Cannabis Indica. 

In an epidemic of cholera in Calcutta, Dr. Goodeve employed 
cannabis very extensively, and his report upon it was in the 
highest degree favorable. Dr. O'Shaughnessy states that he 
knows no remedy equal to it as a general and steady stimulant, 
in 5ss. doses of the tincture. He has known the pulse and 
heat return, and the purging checked, by a single dose. It 
allays vomiting much more certainly than opium, and is not so 



ANTI-SPAS MODICS. 155 

likely to lead to cerebral congestion. Dr. Willemein, of Cairo, 
has related several cases successfully treated by the tincture, 
in repeated doses of from ten to thirty drops ; in one case of 
collapse, the patient revived immediately on taking the remedy. 
It stimulates the nervous centres when their influence is all 
but suppressed, thus actually preventing the extinction of life. 
Of course, it was not successful in all cases. It is best given 
in combination with tincture of cardamoms ; or in supposito- 
ries, combined with sulphate of iron and cocoa butter. 

ANTI-SPASMODICS. 

Chloroform. 

Braithwaite thinks this will prove the most important remedy 
in the spasmodic stage of cholera, as it has been found to be 
wonderfully efficacious in relaxing all kinds of spasmodic ac- 
tion, such as epilepsy, tetanus, hysteria, puerperal convulsions, 
&c, and, in his opinion, the pathology of cholera consists in a 
tonic rigidity, spasm, or tetanic contraction of nearly all the 
arteries of the body. 

To use chloroform effectually, place the patient in bed in 
warm blankets, not in cotton sheets, much less in linen ones ; 
give a glass of brandy in hot water, with sugar and spice ; 
apply friction to the body by means of warm flannels, and an 
embrocation of equal parts of linimen saponis comp., linimen 
camphorse comp., tinct. opii., and ext. belladonnas. Apply 
to the whole surface of the body bags filled with heated sand 
or bran. Then place the patient under the influence of chloro- 
form by inhalation, and keep him so, gently, as long as the bad 
symptoms recur, which they frequently do on its effects ceas- 
ing and his regaining consciousness. Give, in the intervals, 
small quantities of brandy-and-water and thin arrowroot, or 



158 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

milk, for nourishment, along with milk-and-water, or soda- 
water with a little brandy, for drink. Avoid everything else 
in the shape of medicine, and trust to the efforts of nature in 
rallying from the poison of the disease. Of course great cau- 
tion is necessary in administering the chloroform, and in not 
pushing it too far. In some instances the patient will sleep 
for twenty minutes or half an hour — in others, for several 
hours ; and on waking will again be seized with a return of 
the vomiting and cramps ; then the chloroform must again be 
resorted to, and the patient kept in a great measure under its 
influence till these symptoms abate. It may be resumed at 
intervals for twenty-four hours. The reaction after its use 
may be so great as to require moderate blood-letting,, as 
occurred to Dr. J. Hill, in two cases, both persons being of full 
habit of body. A small teaspoonful of chloroform poured 
upon a towel is sufficient for one inhalation. 

Others say, that chloroform should be given as an anti-spas- 
modic, and not as a stimulant ; nor too late, when collapse has 
too much set in. It is of most service in the spasmodic stage. 
Although the poison of cholera seems to act primarily on the 
ganglionic nerves, almost paralyzing them, yet at the com- 
mencement of the attack the heart and other muscles are in a 
state of almost tetanic spasm. But this continues a very short 
time, and if not relieved, is followed by a real collapse. Bleed- 
ing, chloroform, opium, emetics, and all other anti-spasmodic 
and exhausting remedies, ought only to be used when we want 
to effect relaxation of cramps and other spasmodic action of 
the arterial system. Hence, chloroform, if used at all, must be 
used early, and cautiously, and for a short time only. Davies 
gave it in twenty-two cases as soon as severe symptoms came 
on, in doses of seven to ten minims every hour, half hour, or 



ANTI-SPAS MODICS. 15t 

quarter hour, according to the severity of the symptoms ; four- 
teen recovered and eight died. In nine more cases, and thirteen 
very bad diarrhoeas, treated with chloroform, only one died. 
The diet allowed was nothing but cold milk-and-water, with 
some carbonate of soda in it, ad libitum. Of fourteen cases 
treated by Towers, one died. When the doses were given 
quite frequently, say every quarter or half hour, six cases died 
in succession ; when given only every one or two hours, seven 
recovered in succession. Chloroform was also given by inha- 
lation, with the effect of relieving the cramps in every instance. 
It was not carried so far as to produce perfect insensibility. 
Ultimately, Dr. Davies came to the conclusion that no re- 
liance could be placed on chloroform alone. Macpherson 
thinks chloroform is the only important addition to our stock 
of remedies made for some time : he affirms that the cramps 
are best relieved by the use of chloroform in doses of five or 
six minims (about fifteen drops) in a little water ; if the vom- 
iting be excessive, a little may be sprinkled on a pad of lint 
covered with oiled silk, or guttapercha tissue applied to the 
epigastrium ; or spongio piline may be used. He has given 
chloroform in this way, both externally and internally, and 
always with good effects. 

It has been successfully employed by Mr. Brady, of Harrow, 
Plummer, Boynton, and others, in doses of six to ten drops 
every half or one hour. Mustard poultices, and other counter- 
irritants, were applied externally. Sargent gave chloroform, 
camphor, and turpentine, in four cases, and none recovered. 
It often allayed the vomiting and cramps, but did not arrest 
the course of the disease. 

It was tried at the London hospital, given both by the 
stomach and by inhalation, but all the patients died. 



158 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

Some physicians think that the nsnal doses of chloroform 
in cholera are too small, and that fifteen, twenty, or thirty drops, 
or more, can be given at each dose, without danger. They as- 
sume that the impression of the remedy on the ganglionic cen- 
tres in cholera must "be rapid and energetic to he "beneficial, 
and, to this end, large doses should be given. 

Dr. Gason, of Ireland, gives only three-drop doses every five 
or ten minutes. 

Dr. Brady relied upon : chloroform, 3j- ; spir. terebinth, Jj. ; 
mucilag. acacias, §j. ; aq. pur., §ij. Dose: a large teaspoonful, 
containing about six minims of chloroform, and forty of spirits 
of turpentine. 

Dr. Henry Hartshorne's prescription is, perhaps, the best : 
chloroform, 3iss. ; tinct. opii., 5iss. ; spir. camph., 5iss. ; spir. 
ammon. aromat, 5iss. ; creasot.., gutt. iij. ; ol. cinnaim, gutt. 
viij. ; spir. vim gall., 3ij- Dose : one teaspoonful to be put in 
a wineglass of ice-water, and two teaspoonfuls of that given 
every five minutes, followed each time by a lump of ice. 

Clilorodyne* 

The wife of an English chaplain, in Paris, has recently ob- 
tained notoriety by administering chlorodyne in fifty or sixty 
cases of incipient cholera, successfully, Johnson thinks it will 
relieve the cramps^ and, by its narcotic action, somewhat re- 
tard the recovery of the patient, but concludes that it is much 
less dangerous than opium and strong astringents* 

BLEEDING. 

Braithwaite and Bell think cholera consists in a tonic 
rigidity, spasm, or tetanic contraction of all the arteries of the 
body, caused by some violent poison acting on the sympathetic 



BLEEDING. 159 

nerve, and all its branches and connections. The small termi- 
nal arteries and capillaries being thus spasmodically contracted, 
the blood is driven inward upon the great veins. When the 
congestion towards internal parts has reached to such a point 
as to oppress the action of the heart, yawning first, and then 
shivering, or a sense of suffocation and pain in the prsecordia 
are the indications of oppressed circulation, and of the com- 
mencing effort of the heart to overcome the mass of blood 
which is stiffing it. If by the application of tourniquets to the 
limbs, or by bleeding, part of the blood which is rushing from 
the extremities to increase this congestion, is prevented from 
reaching the great veins — then the heart, excited to increased 
action, is enabled by this relief more quickly to overcome the 
obstruction and restore the balance of the circulation, and the 
paroxysm passes off. If not thus mechanically aided, the 
heart, after a severe struggle to maintain the circulation dur- 
ing the period of spasm or constriction, is at length relieved 
by this cramp of the capillary circulation passing off itself ; 
and then the heart and arteries, so long excited by the strug- 
gle, maintain for a time their increased action after the obstruc- 
tion in the capillaries is removed, and produce apparent febrile 
action ; presently this excitement subsides, the vessels become 
relaxed, and sweat succeeds. 

All depends upon the period at which bleeding is resorted 
to. If early in the congestive stage, or just previous to its 
second accession, it is invariably successful ; if just as the 
congestive stage is passing off, when the pulse begins to ac- 
quire a little power, it is invariably fatal. Dr. "Bell explains 
these facts in the following manner. In the first stage the heart 
is excited to the utmost by distension of its cavities from be- 
hind, and opposition to its action by spasm of the capillaries 



160 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

in front ; bleeding gives relief from the pressure, a tergo, and 
probably aids in relaxing "the spasm, while at the same time, 
by relieving the congested state of the great secreting organs, 
it enlists their sympathies in support of the vital actions ; and 
the power of the heart being unimpaired, can now carry on 
the circulation with vigor. But in the second stage, the heart's 
energy is much exhausted, and its vital irritability impaired by 
long-continued distention ; hence syncope and relapse will be 
the probable effects of bleeding. 

George Johnson says, bloodletting has often afforded great 
relief in the stage of collapse ; he assumes that by lessening 
the over-distension of the right cavities of the heart, it in- 
creases the contractile power of their muscular walls. It is 
most useful when there is rapid breathing with an oppressive 
sense of suffocation, an almost entire arrest of blood in the 
lungs, and a cessation of vomiting and purging. Macpherson 
says, he saw bloodletting employed at one time ; he has now 
entirely abandoned it. 

HOMCEOPATHY AND CHOLEEA. 

In Ruckert's Clinique, or collection of all homoeopathic 
cures which have been reported in, or translated into the Ger- 
man language, from 1822 to 1850, we find that the homoeopa- 
thists depended upon thirty-five remedies in the treatment of 
cholera. Twenty-two of these are not homoeopathic in any 
sense, but act as alterative or antagonistic medicines, viz., 
liquor ammonia, nitrate of silver, arsenic, asarum europeeum, 
belladonna, camphor, chalk, conium, cantharides, charcoal, 
copper or cuprum, hyosciamus, ipecac, mercury, nux vomica, 
opium, phosphorus, phosphoric acid, prussic acid, acetate of 
lead, rhus toxicodendron, secale, stramonium, and sulphur* 



HOMEOPATHY AND CHOLERA. 161 

Most of these have been faithfully tried in the regular school, 
with what success the preceding pages will testify. With the 
peculiarly homoeopathic remedies, viz,, Tartar-emetic, Croton 
oil, and Elaterium, the regular school have made more experi- 
ments than the homoeopathists themselves. 

Knorre abandoned the homoeopathic remedies, and gave 
grain doses of carbonate of ammonia every half or one hour. 
Reil gave two drops of aqua ammonia every ten minutes. 
Kurtz gave it on the slightest appearance of approaching col- 
lapse, and attributes his principal success to it. Ebers gave 
six to eight drop doses every quarter of an hour in threaten- 
ing cases. Steart gave thirty-drop doses, and claims to have 
saved one hundred and forty-two cases. 

Arsenic is one of the most decided tonics, and greatly relied 
upon in the regular school in chronic and exhausting diar- 
rhoeas. 

Cuprum or copper, and acetate of lead, are astringents much 
in use in the regular school in diarrhoea, cholera, and dysen- 
tery. Fleischman says cuprum is not useful against the 
cramps, and Rummel preferred hyosciamus. 

Phosphorus is a tonic and stimulant like camphor and harts- 
horn ; and phosphoric acid is a tonic and astringent like sul- 
phuric acid. 

Secale is a styptic remedy which produces powerful con- 
traction of the capillaries, and has been much used by the 
homoeopathists in cholera. 

Rhus toxicodendron is an irritant and stimulant remedy like 
cantharides. 

It is fair to assume that all the so-called cures of cholera, 
with homoeopathic doses of allopathic remedies, were merely 
recoveries. 



162 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

If the spasm theory be true, belladonna, conium, opium, and 
stramonium, act as antagonistic remedies, and homceopathists 
must always fail with them, as their doses will always be too 
small. 

If the elimination theory be correct, there can be no greater 
objection to the use of hellebore, jatropha curcas, tobacco, 
and veratrum, than to tartar-emetic, ipecac, and mercury. 

We are not in want of remedies against diarrhoea and sim- 
ple cholera. It is in the algid, ataxic, and full collapse cases 
that help is required. In these forms, Fleischman and Tessier, 
who have had the largest homoeopathic hospital experience, 
say that homoeopathy is comparatively powerless. Fleischman 
says, he has tried every remedy again and again, but has little 
to say in praise of them. Tessier says, the number of deaths 
generally corresponds to the number of cases of black, algid, 
ataxic, or collapse cases. During the epidemic of 1849, he 
only saw one case of either of these forms get well. Hahne- 
mann's method seems to him to be limited to cases of diar- 
rhoea, cholerine, and simple cholera. Tessier says, it seems 
fair to treat the black and ataxic forms of cholera in the usual 
manner, inasmuch as homoeopathy fails completely in both of 
these varieties. 



APPENDIX. 



1.— NATURE OF THE CHOLERA POISON. 

The celebrated M. Robin and his assistants at the Histo- 
logical Laboratory of the Ecole de Medecine at Paris, have 
succeeded in producing cholera in dogs, by injecting the 
serum of the blood and the rice-water dejections of cholera 
patients into the veins, cellular tissue, and windpipes of these 
and other animals. 

If the rice-water discharges were recent, clear, and without 
color, and if the serum of the blood used for these injections 
was drawn during the collapse and algic period, the induced 
cholera symptoms were very marked ^ for vomiting occurred 
in twenty minutes, followed by diarrhoea, the expulsion of 
epithelial debris, coldness of the extremities, labored and 
anxious respiration, suspension of the urinary secretion, and 
by albuminuria. 

The introduction of a large quantity of these substances 
into the stomachs of dogs also caused the same symptoms. 

Richardson found that the poison of cholera escapes from 
the infected person in the form of watery vapor, and justly 
regards this as a discovery of the greatest importance ; for 
when the temperature of the air is low, the fluid excreta 
condense on the body and on the clothing of the cholera 

9 



164 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

subject, and the poison is confined and limited in its effects. 
But, when the temperature is high, the miasm is readily 
disseminated into the air. This is the reason why cholera 
always spreads most easily when the temperature is some- 
what high, and in crowded places ; and if these rooms and 
places be also filthy, the whole foul air may be converted 
into a cholera atmosphere. The great importance of free 
ventilation is thus proven, and still more so from the experi- 
ments of Legros and G-oujon, who were enabled, by means 
of an apparatus containing ice and salt, to condense the air 
of some crowded cholera wards in the Parisian hospitals, 
and thu3 procure a liquid which caused symptoms similar 
to those of cholera, when injected into the air-tubes of dogs . 

The discovery of this cholera poison or fluid, in the air 
of cholera hospitals, brings this disease more clearly in 
alliance with the infectious and contagious diseases. We 
know that not only the breath, but the dried perspiration, 
tears, nasal discharges, and even the furfuraceous scales from 
measles patients are saturated with the exhalations of the 
disease, and may convey measles to others. In scarlet fever 
the breath, pharyngeal and nasal excretions, and the larger 
and smaller scales of epidermis, may spread the disease 
about. In whooping-cough the breath and dried expectoration 
which has clung to the dresses of patients and attendants 
may be the means of carrying the disease abroad. In small- 
pox the dried crusts and scabs which cling to the head and 
linger in the hair, may retain the disease for months. The 
clothes of all these patients and of cholera subjects, saturated 
as they are with the dried perspiration or fouler discharges, 
may retain the poison for long periods of time. 

This cholera liquid is comparable in its action to that of an 



RELATIONS OF D I A R R H <E A , ETC. 165 

overdose of croton oil ; at least Dr. G-reenhow has seen a case 
in which an overdose of croton oil was given accidentally, 
and in the short space of two hours the patient had all the 
appearance of a person in the cold stage of cholera. There 
were very profuse watery purgmgs exactly resembling the 
rice-water stools of cholera patients ; the surface was cold, 
the features shrunken, the fingers shrivelled, the skin even 
more blue than is usual in cases of true cholera, and the pulse 
thready, and almost imperceptible ; the patient had severe 
cramps, was very restless, and her respiration gasping. Her 
intellect was unimpaired, and she died in ten hours. 

Orfila gives another instance in which there was a general 
collapse, such as is observed in malignant cholera, with profuse 
diarrhoea, and death in four hours. 

The great similarity of the action of Tartar emetic and Ela- 
terium to that of cholera, has been fully worked out on pages 
139 and 140. 

2.— RELATIONS OF DIARRHOEA AND CHOLERA. 

Prior to the onset of the epidemic in Malta in 1865, there 
was no prevalence of bowel complaint, either among the 
military or civil populations. Of the diarrhoea which pre- 
vailed during the epidemic, Drs. Adams and Welch describe 
three varieties. (See English Army Medical Reports, vol. vi.) 

1st. The common ordinary summer diarrhoea : characterized 
by pains in the stomach, foul coated tongue, numerous bilious 
stools. This was very tractable in its nature, and was caused 
by hot weather, spoiled fruit, irregular habits, and drunken- 
ness. 

2d. There was a diarrhoea not previously existing, character- 



166 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

ized by painless watery purging, and often accompanied by 
vomiting of the same character ; clear or white furred tongue, 
depression of countenance, dark rim under the eyes, and 
exhaustion. It occurred in every degree of intensity, and 
when severe was classed under " choleraic diarrhoea." But, 
although intractable, it evinced no tendency to pass beyond a 
certain point or assume a more malignant form. It was very 
frequent both during the height and decline of the epidemic. 
Drs. Adams and Welch repeat that this second variety showed 
no tendency to pass beyond a certain point, if not stopped. 

3d. There was a diarrhoea, an intensification of the second 
kind, and so completely intractable, that in sixty-one cases, 
where every possible attempt was made to check it, in none 
did it succeed, but was invariably followed by full develop- 
ment of cholera — in fact, it was the diarrhoea stage. It must 
be clearly stated that during no period of the epidemic was 
the " premonitory diarrhoea tending towards cholera, but 
easily checked," met with. The second variety showed no 
tendency to run into true cholera. In its severe form, the 
third variety was clearly a stage of the disease ; and it may 
be fairly questioned whether a single case was prevented from 
developing itself into cholera by treatment directed towards 
the suppression of the intestinal flux. 

It is well, however, to treat all minor bowel complaints so 
as to get any suspicious case under observation and treatment 
as quickly as possible. 

Barlow, of Guy's Hospital, says that the English or summer 
cholera occurs in most summers, to a greater or less extent, 
and in greater or less degrees of intensity. In some cases it 
is a matter of very little moment ; in others, the diarrhoea 
goes on to an extent that is exhausting to the patient ; and, 



RELATIONS OF DIARRHEA, ETC. 167 

in some few cases, we meet with thirst, suppression of urine, 
cramps, lividity and collapse, and, in short, the condition of the 
patient so closely resembles that of one passing into the col- 
lapse of true Asiatic cholera, that it is impossible for any one, 
by mere examination of the patient, to distinguish it ; the only 
guide being the character of the prevailing epidemic. Barlow 
has more than once seen cases of this kind, of which he has 
said : " If Asiatic cholera were now prevalent, there would be 
hardly a chance of the recovery of this patient ; but, as it is 
not, I hope, and even expect, that he will do well." And such 
has been the case in every instance which Barlow has seen, 
with the exception of aged and diseased persons. The only 
difference is that the collapse is not so profound as in the epi- 
demic form of the disease, and the rice-water dejections not 
quite so copious. 

In the times of Shakespeare, and even later, English cholera 
was much more common than now. Then the floors were of 
earth only ; broom and brush were used but little ; garbage 
was thrown down without care, as now in Abyssinia, and 
allowed to lie and rot till it became so vile that the device was 
invented of covering it with straw, so that it might be trodden 
down, as cattle make manure in straw-yards. Finally, when 
the earth of the floor became over-weighted with putrid mat- 
ter, the formation of nitre or saltpetre began, and oxygen accu- 
mulated rapidly, rendering these houses habitable in a way. 
On the discovery of gunpowder, the Government sent Petre 
men to obtain this saltpetre by force. They entered houses 
without pity, for villanous saltpetre. 

Septic cholera can often be distinguished only with diffi- 
culty from the Asiatic cases. (See pages 72 and 73.) In Boston 
a large number occurred in one district, in the immediate 



168 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

vicinity or directly in the midst of a large sunken area, which 
was nothing more or less than a pestiferous quagmire, receiv- 
ing a large part of the drainage of the surrounding vicinity, 
and the filth of many tenements occupied by the lower classes. 

Sir Henry Cooper says the diarrhoea premonitory of cholera 
is not distinguishable in its history or symptoms from spo- 
radic or ordinary diarrhoea, until all the natural pre-accumu- 
lated fsecal contents of the bowels have been evacuated, and 
the characteristic stools begin to appear. 

Carroll, of Cincinnati, says it is often difficult to distinguish 
between common diarrhoea and the first stage of cholera. If 
the patient has been exposed to the cholera influence ; if the 
evacuations are lighter in color — resembling dirty water, or 
soap suds ; if they are painless, copious, or debilitating, and 
occur without imprudence in diet, exposure to cold, etc., he 
thinks he has to deal with cholera, especially if there is 
slight blueness of the face and fingers, some coldness of the 
tongue and breath, as well as of the ears and hands ; slight 
clammy perspiration, and slowness of the pulse. 

3.— DISTRIBUTION BY WATER. 
Dr. Norman Cheevers, of Calcutta, has given attention to 
the influence of impure water in the development of cholera 
at the presumed chief focus of the disease, viz., the delta 
of the Ganges. He shows that the night-soil of Calcutta 
is deposited in the Hooghly, at mid-stream, at the rate of 
one hundred and eighty tons a day, and that the river water 
from two to thirteen miles up the stream is unfit for human 
consumption. Yet this filthy river water is drunk by sailors 
in ships moored in the neighborhood. In addition, twenty- 
two sewers open directly upon the commencement of a soft 



DISTRIBUTION BY WATER. 169 

muddy bank, on the irregular surface of which much of their 
contents is retained ; and in February, March, April, May, 
and June, the poison of cholera from this source is in 
active operation. It is also worthy of note that a sewer emp- 
ties itself close to each of the principal bathing places, as 
if the sacred stream was not already poisoned enough by 
the daily Augean deposit of night soil — the bathers are fur- 
nished with a special fountain for themselves. This polluted 
river has been termed, not too emphatically, the ''Maelstrom 
of Death," and Cheevers says it is idle to talk of unripe 
fruits, bad lemonade, of Jack's imprudence in exposing him- 
self to the sun, and of his drunken habits, for one draught 
of this " poison water " will be more fatal than all of them 
combined. This polluted water converts a harbor of refuge 
into a port of danger. Of three hundred and ninety-two 
cases of cholera, taken into one hospital, one hundred and 
eighty-nine, or almost one half, came from ships. Only 
nine cases came from a mooring where there was a greater 
crowd of ships than elsewhere, but out of the way of the 
filth ; while ninety-four and sixty-one cases came respectively 
from the two filthiest mooring spots. 

We can now readily understand why, as long as the char- 
acter of the water was overlooked, the so-called greatest 
amount of care did not make it possible to prevent frequent 
outbreaks of cholera in ships going down the Granges from 
Calcutta, nor even occasional outbreaks as long as a fortnight 
after leaving the river. 

" In the Crimean campaign," says Dr. Richardson, " the English 
Black Sea fleet had seven hundred and ten cases of cholera, 
and three hundred and ninety-seven deaths, and ninety-one per 
cent, of these were supplied with water derived from springs 



1*70 ASIATIC CHOLEKA. 

at Baltschick, a spot on which French troops had been quar- 
tered while suffering from cholera. These troops had washed 
their clothing at these springs, and the ground for a great dis- 
tance around was saturated with their excreta. The remain- 
ing nine per cent, of the infected were supplied with water 
partly from Baltschick; at least, of the crews of three vessels 
which suffered severely, two positively took in water from 
Baltschick, and the third probably so. In all ships, except 
one, which were supplied with distilled water, not a case 
occurred ; and in that one, the water was passed through a 
foul hose." — London Medical Times and Gazette, July 28, 
1866. 

In 1866, the little town of Amiens suffered more severely 
than any other known place. It was ravaged by the most 
terrible outbreak of cholera that has ever visited any Euro* 
pean city. It raged most in the lower town and old city, 
carrying off whole families when it once entered a habita- 
tion. The backs of the infected houses mostly opened upon 
the river Somme and its numerous tributaries. There the 
people were constantly engaged in washing filthy baskets, 
rinsing linen, throwing out slops, or ladling up water to be 
carried in-doors. The water is still used for domestic pur- 
poses, although it is plain that it is fouled most abundantly 
by sewage matters, and before the outbreak of cholera it was 
used for drinking. Police officers have seen the people 
drinking it often and often. 

" In 1832, one thousand cases of cholera occurred in Exeter, 
England, with three hundred and forty-seven deaths. The 
water was supplied at that time from the rivei , and was con- 
taminated. In 1834, the water supply was improved, being 
drawn from the river two miles above town, and in 1849 



CONVEYANCE OF CHOLERA. 171 

there were only forty-four cases, and those chiefly among 
strangers. 

"In Dumfries, Scotland, in 1832 and 1849, the supply of 
water was both scanty and impure, but then a better supply 
was obtained, and in 1854 the place was very lightly visited. 

" In 1866, six districts in East London were supplied by the 
East London Company, and every one has been ravaged by 
cholera ; from nine hundred to one thousand cases occurring 
in one week, whilst the remaining thirty-one districts have 
been comparatively unharmed. 

" A woman lodging at the top of a house in Red Lion street, 
Wapping, was attacked with cholera ; her slops and filth were 
emptied down the rain-water pipe, which communicated with 
the water butt below. The other people in the house drank 
of this water, and five out of nine died of cholera." — Medical 
Times and Gazette, Sept. 11, 1866. 

The tenacity with which water retains " cholera stuff" has 
been established by Dr. Falkland. He has shown that it 
passes readily through filtering paper, and that water con- 
taining one-five-hundredth part of it, is not entirely purified 
by transmission through animal charcoal. 

4.— CONVEYANCE OF CHOLERA FROM INDIA TO 
EUROPE AND AMERICA IN 1865 AND 1866. 

From Ranking's Abstract of Medical Sciences, Vol. 44, p. 
206, we learn that : " At the' beginning of 1865 cholera was 
epidemic in the Bombay Presidency, and during that year the 
city of Bombay (although it has not been free from the disease 
for a single month for the last twenty years) suffered from a 
severer outbreak than had been experienced since the great 

9* 



1T2 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

cholera year, 1850." From page 289 (ibid.), and also from 
London Lancet, Jan. 19, 1867, we learn that cholera first ap- 
peared in the Red Sea in 1865, on board two English ships, 
the Persia and North- Wind, carrying Eastern or Asiatic pil- 
grims from Singapore to Jeddah and Mecca. The captains 
both stated that the passengers and crews caught the disease 
at Mokulla, on the Arabian coast, where both vessels touched, 
and that it raged severely among them until they were oppo- 
site Leet, about one hundred miles below Jeddah. 

As Mokulla trades largely, and perhaps chiefly, with Bom- 
bay, the disease may have been brought over from that city 
both in 1864 and 1865. Still, it is well known that cholera 
also prevailed in Java and Singapore in 1864 and 1865, and 
that convalescents from the disease were embarked on board 
pilgrim ships for Mecca. It may also have been brought 
from Calcutta, as two native vessels from Bengal, and a third 
vessel from Singapore, had numerous deaths from diarrhoea 
(and cholera) among their pilgrim passengers on the voyage 
to Jeddah. 

About May 2, 1865, the cholera broke out violently in Jeddah 
and Mecca ; and on May 21st, the cholera again broke out on 
the ship Persia, which was now carrying Western or Euro- 
pean pilgrims from Mecca to Suez. Both the captain and his 
wife were attacked. 

The London Medical Times and Gazette states that cholera 
reached Alexandria from Suez as early as May 11. By 
June 2, cases were frequent, and on the 11th there were 
thirty deaths per day, and on the 17th as many as sixty-one ; 
yet the disease was not officially recognized till June 11, and 
foul bills of health were only issued to vessels from Alexandria 
on the 14th of June. Thus the disease was allowed to slip 



CONVEYANCE OF CHOLERA. 1*13 

out into the Mediterranean, and the cholera poison was widely 
disseminated, and had formed lodgments in Constantinople, 
Ancona, Malta, Marseilles, and Gibraltar, before the Egyptian 
sanitary authorities had taken any steps to stop its march. 

On page 214 of Ranking's Abstract, Vol. 44, we find a report 
of the cholera epidemic of 1865, in the Maltese Islands, taken 
from the Official Medical Reports of the English Army Medi- 
cal Department, Vol. 6, 1866 (Blue-Book). Army-Surgeons 
Adams and Welch state : " Towards the end of May, and 
before there was any knowledge of cholera having appeared 
at Alexandria, numerous pilgrims returning from Mecca had 
landed at Malta, without the imposition of quarantine. About 
the same time (May), the alarm beginning to spread in Egypt 
of cholera appearing in the track of the returning pilgrims, 
many Maltese returned home from Alexandria (without going 
to Mecca ?). A quarantine was not established in Malta against 
Alexandria until June 14th. But Drs. Adams and Welch, 
from an attentive consideration of all the facts, are of 
opinion that Malta was infected by the choleraic poison prior 
to the commencement of quarantine, and that the poison 
came first to Malta in the track of the pilgrims and earlier 
fugitives." 

" The facts relating to the appearance of cholera in the 
island of Gozo (a Maltese island) are very precise. A sailor, 
who had been serving on board a small vessel in the harbor of 
Valetta (Malta), returned to his home on the island of Gozo, 
with all the symptoms of cholera, on July 21st. He was 
nursed by his two sisters and two other women. All these 
were attacked on the 24th, and on the 25th another female 
attendant succumbed. From this last-named date, and from 



1*14 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

these cases, the disease spread among the population of the 
island." 

On page 208, we find that cholera was not officially recog- 
nized at Marseilles till July 23, 1865, although it must have 
arrived there early in June. From the London Lancet, Jan- 
uary 12, 1867, we learn that : " From papers laid before the 
French Academy by M. Grimaud de Caux, it seems proven 
beyond all question, that cholera was introduced into France 
and first appeared in Marseilles subsequently to the arrival of 
a vessel with pilgrims from Alexandria. It has been asserted 
that cholera was present in Marseilles previously ; but the 
supposed cases have been most satisfactorily explained away. 
Thus, much evidence was brought forward in proof of the 
contagion theory. Grimaud's reply, in full, will be found in 
the Comptes Rendus, Vol. 73, No. 16." 

Marseilles was a great centre for the distribution of 
cholera in 1865. It was quickly conveyed to Paris, for as 
many as 16 deaths from cholera occurred in Paris in June ; 
30 in July ; 125 in August ; 200 in September ; 4,466 in 
October ; 1,218 in November ; and 768 in December, 1865. 

In October, when there were 144 deaths daily in Paris, 
the disease was conveyed to Havre, and carried by the pas- 
sengers of the steamship Atalanta to New York by November 
3d. A patient from the Atalanta introduced the disease into 
Ward's Island Emigrant Hospital, where on and after Novem- 
ber 22 there were twenty-seven fatal cases. 

From Marseilles the disease was also carried to Toulon. 
Mr. Calvy says three deaths occurred in a house in a healthy 
and isolated locality near Toulon, which was free from 
cholera at the time. A member of this family had attended 
upon persons who died of cholera in Marseilles. 



CONVEYANCE OF CHOLERA. 175 

From Marseilles it was also conveyed to Algiers by pil- 
grims from Mecca by September 24th. Also to Guadaloupe 
by a Marseilles ship by October 20th, and 10,806 died in 
this island out of a population of 149,107. 

Cholera reached Odessa by August 6th, and was carried to 
Altenburg, in the heart of Saxony, in the manner described 
on page 52 of this treatise, and thus introduced into the 
Prussian armies, in which it committed great ravages. 

CHOLERA IX SOUTHAMPTON. 

On page 209 of Ranking's Abstract, Vol. 44, we learn that 
Southampton is the English port which maintains the closest 
and most rapid intercourse with Alexandria, and that it was 
only (p. 208) in this one port in all England that vessels 
arrived, in 1865, having had cholera on board shortly before, 
and in reality having the disease in active operation when 
they entered the harbor. In this same town occurred, shortly 
after, the first cases of cholera in England in 1865, viz., sixty 
cases, with thirty-five deaths. The extension of cholera 
from Southampton to Epping is noticed on page 51 of this 
treatise. 

This was the first time that cholera reached England by 
the way of the South, but the disease did not commence to 
prevail till September, although suspicious vessels arrived 
in July, and cases of sickness attended with choleraic symp- 
toms occurred in Southampton long before the disease was 
officially recognized. 

Precisely similar events occurred in 1866. 

In the London Medical Times, July 28, 1866, we read : * Up to 
June 10, 1866, Southampton had enjoyed a singular immunity 



116 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

from disease of every kind, and diarrhoea was unknown in the 
place. On that day the steamship Poona arrived, having lost 
a man from cholera on the previous day. On the 11th, 12th, 
and 13th, several cases of diarrhoea occurred among the crew. 
On the 13th, a child of one of these men died in five hours 
with cholera, having slept in the same berth with its father, 
who was sick with severe vomiting and purging ; the father 
died two days after. Then up to July 24th there were one 
hundred and twenty cases of cholera in Southampton, with 
sixty-six deaths." 

The London Medical Gazette and Times, August 4, 1866, 
says: 

" The first decided case of contagious cholera in Liverpool, 
unconnected with the Helvetia, was that of Mrs. Boyle, in a 
wretched close court in Bispham street, and the infection 
was spread in the neighborhood by the orgies of an Irish 
wake. Seventy-three cases were traced to this one cause." 

Dr. Houghton says, in London Medical Times and Gazette, 
February 16, 1867 : 

" As a matter of fact, the first case of Asiatic cholera in 
Dublin, in 1866, appeared in the person of a woman named 
Magee, who imported the disease from Liverpool, on July 26, 
and carried it with her to the house No. 22 City Quay, where 
she died, having previously given the disease to a little girl, 
Mary Anne Mezler, who also died in a short time. The child's 
father, Andrew Mezler, next died, July 31 ; his widow 
sickened August 2d. The cholera thus introduced by Ellen 
Magee spread rapidly over Dublin, and killed one thousand 
one hundred and ninety-three persons." 

" The disease contracted by Ellen Magee in Liverpool and 
thence imported into Dublin was in its turn originally ini- 



CONVEYANCE OF CHOLERA. lit 

ported by the ship Helvetia into Liverpool, by German and 
Dutch emigrants, and Dr. Houghton has no doubt, if we pos- 
sessed the requisite knowledge, the disease could be traced 
backwards in lineal descent to its origin in some poor Hindoo 
on the banks of the Ganges, as certainly as the pedigree of a 
horse or dog of repute can be traced to his remote an- 
cestors.*' 

I think I have almost succeeded in doing this. 

Dr. Houghton thinks that, as long as we possess such a 
history of the introduction of Asiatic cholera, we are justified 
in rejecting other possible modes of its causation. 

The London Medical Times and Gazette of Sept. 1, 1866, 
says : " The spread of cholera from the eastern to other dis- 
tricts of London has taken place so deliberately as to have 
made it an easy matter to investigate carefully into the history 
of isolated outbreaks, and a good deal of evidence of the 
transportation of the disease from infected to non-infected 
places and houses has been collected, and striking instances 
of infection are reported." 

The London Lancet, Feb. 23, 1867, says about the recent 
outbreak of cholera in Jersey : " The disease is stated to be 
prevailing in Brittany, near St. Brieux, a port with which 
Jersey has communication. A French woman died Feb. 6, 
1867, and her husband next day. An Irishman who waited 
on them formed the communication between this house and 
another, about one-quarter mile off, in which he and another 
died. A wake was held on these two persons, and ten of the 
company have since died. One hundred and two cases and 
thirty -nine deaths have already occurred. All the first cases 
died quickly, with diarrhoea, vomiting, cramps, and pulseless- 
ness. Later, the cases began by choleraic diarrhoea, running 



118 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

or not into collapse. This is the fourth visitation of cholera 
in Jersey, viz., in 1832, 1849, 1854, and 1867. There had 
been no previous prevalence of diarrhoea — the disease dropped 
on the island without warning." 

The history of the introduction of cholera in the County 
Hospital of Chicago in 1866, as reported by Dr. T. Bevan, is 
very instructive. 

Up to August 6th, no apparent tendency to intestinal 
troubles beyond an occasional dysentery of some returned 
soldier with chronic diarrhoea had occurred in the hospital, 
when a Mormon train abandoned a man named Christian 
Hansen at the railroad depot ; he was taken to the hospital, 
and died in five hours of cholera. The second and third 
cases occurred in a nurse and a patient on the 9th ; the fourth 
occupied a bed next No. 1, and sickened on the 10th; the 
fifth on the 11th ; the sixth on the 12th ; the seventh, eighth, 
ninth, tenth, and eleventh cases occurred on the 13th of Au- 
gust; the twelfth, thirteenth, fourteenth, fifteenth, and six- 
teenth cases on the 14th; the seventeenth and eighteenth 
cases on the 16th, and the nineteenth and last case on the 
17th of August. In addition, the warden of the hospital and 
the resident physician had distinctly marked choleraic attacks, 
but recovered. The epidemic lasted fourteen days, and was 
stayed by isolation of the patients, disinfection of discharges, 
cleanliness, and free ventilation. Fifty per cent, of the paupers 
died, and only twenty per cent, of the better class of patients 
although the cases among the latter were more violent than 
among the former ; the latter would react and convalesce, 
while the paupers quickly succumbed. 

If the hospitals on Black well's Island had been as small, 
and the inmates as little numerous, the introduction of cholera 



PREVENTION OF CHOLERA. H9 

into them would not have been as mysterious as it now seems 
to be. The same holds good of the Brooklyn Penitentiary. 
(See pages 94 and 106 of this treatise.) 

5.— PREVENTION OF CHOLERA. 

In consequence of the sanitary measures described on page 
22 of this treatise three, if not four, festivals at Conjeiveram 
have passed without an explosion of cholera. 

In the Bombay Presidency there are 94 shrines to which 
pilgrimages are made. In the past year (1866), for the first 
time, these shrines and the devotees were subjected to sani- 
tary control. The result has been remarkable, for cholera 
appeared at two only. This renders it probable if this im- 
portant duty had been commenced in 1865, as at Conjeiveram, 
the disease would not have been conveyed from Bombay to 
Mokulla, and the epidemics of 1865 and 1866 would have been 
prevented from reaching Europe. 

At Mecca the same sort of scavengering, burial of excreta 
and all organic refuse, was only commenced in 1866, but now 
will always be carried out. The great importance of this at 
Mecca is evident from Burton's account. He says : " At the 
feast of sacrifices the surface of the valley soon came to re- 
semble the dirtiest of slaughter-houses, and in a few days, 
literally, the land stank. In addition the heat of Mecca is so 
great that clothing is unendurable during the middle of the 
day, for the city is so compacted together by hills that even 
the Simoom can scarcely sweep it. The heat, reverberated by 
the bare rocks, is intense and occasions great lassitude of 
body and mind." 

The strictest quarantine and the most rigid and sanitary 



180 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

regulations are necessary at Alexandria, Marseilles, Southamp- 
ton, and New York. 

As regards the disinfection of cholera discharges Petten- 
kofer's directions are the best. He says : 

"The dejections of cholera patients, in their recent state, are 
generally either neutral or feebly alkaline. But after a lapse 
of a short time they become decidedly alkaline, and means 
should be taken to render and retain both the urine and fasces 
acid, and thus prevent alkaline or ammoniacal decomposition. 
This is easily done, for some metallic salts, mineral acids, and 
carbolic acid will preserve the urine and faeces in an acid 
condition for months. Sulphate of iron is the best on account 
of its efficiency, cheapness, and ready accessibility. For the 
disinfection of cesspools and out-door privies where urinary 
and faecal discharges have accumulated in large quantities, 
and have already undergone alkaline or ammoniacal decompo- 
sition, the sulphate of iron or copperas must be added, in a 
concentrated solution, until the odor of ammonia and of sul- 
phuretted hydrogen is completely removed, and the contents of 
the pit have an acid reaction after stirring. Then we may rest 
assured that ammoniacal decomposition will be delayed for 
months, although some other innocuous changes and some un- 
pleasant fetor may arise. The offensive odor cannot all be 
removed by any known means, and can only be concealed by 
stronger penetrating odors ; still, carbolic acid conceals the 
fetor of excrement completely, whilst its own smell, when 
diluted, is very bearable and even decidedly healthy. It also 
prevents ammoniacal decomposition. If one part of carbolic 
acid be dissolved in twenty parts of water, half a pint will be 
sufficient for the daily excreta of four persons, and will keep 



PREVENTION OF CHOLERA. 181 

them acid. About one ounce of copperas is required for the 
recent excrement of each person daily. 

The disinfection of cholera-air has been discussed on pages 
103 and 104. But some practical men think that cloths or 
towels soaked in a solution of permanganate of potash and 
waved about the sick-room is the best expedient. Still, Dr. 
Clemens prefers a spirit of chlorate of copper as a cholera-air 
disinfectant. Take of liq. cupri perchlorati concent. gij, 5 
chloroformi 3j- ; spir. vini §vj. ; put some in a common glass 
spirit lamp. When the wick is lighted a vapor of chlorate of 
copper is formed, which in five minutes will pervade a cham- 
ber of 5,000 cubic feet so completely that all objects contained 
therein will be impregnated. In this way both the air and all 
other matters will be quickly disinfected, and that without 
danger, for it is claimed that even children do not suffer the 
slightest injury from this vapor. 

The good effect of these preventive measures were abun- 
dantly proved in the experience of New York during the last 
epidemic. In New York city proper there were but 600 
deaths from cholera last year, while in St. Louis there were no 
less than 3,527. Much credit is due to our efficient quarantine 
health officers ; for in 1832 only 23 cases of cholera were 
received into the quarantine hospital, yet there were 3,572 
deaths in the city ; in 1849 there were 230 cases in quaran- 
tine, and 5,071 deaths in New York ; in 1854, 415 cases at 
quarantine, and 2,509 deaths in the city; in 1868, 608 cases in 
the lower bay, and only 1,210 deaths in New York, Brooklyn, 
and in the numerous islands occupied by the extensive chari- 
table, penal, and military establishments. 

Of European towns the city of Bristol, England, has given 
the strongest testimony of the value of prevention and disin- 



182 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

fection. Bristol is the home of Dr. Budd, who first suggested 
these procedures. In 1866 cholera was imported over thirty 
times into Bristol, and was directly traced to infection from 
other places in which it prevailed epidemically. There were 
only two instances in which a second case occurred in the 
same house after it came under the control of the sanitary 
authorities. 

The results in London were also very striking : 
From the 7th to 14th of July, 1866, there were 32 deaths 
in London; in the next week 346. From the 21st to 28th 
July, there were 904 deaths ; in the following week 1,053 
deaths occurred from cholera. The mortality had now 
attained a height that was not reached till two weeks later 
in 1849, and four weeks later in 1854, and cholera might 
well have proven a more terrible destroyer than it had ever 
yet been. But sanitary science fought against it as it had 
never fought before. In every parish the health officers 
were supported much better than in former epidemics ; 
house to house visitation was energetically and efficiently 
carried out; cholera patients were removed to special hos- 
pitals ; disinfection of all drains and sewers and of infected 
houses, bedding, and clothing was rigorously insisted upon ; 
the still healthy were removed from infected houses, the 
water supply was looked to, and private charity came nobly 
forward. In the very next week the deaths from cholera fell 
from 1,053 to 781, and by the first week of September, which 
was the most fatal week in the two previous epidemics, the 
deaths were only 132. In 1849, 14,137 died in London ; in 
1854, 10,738 ; in 1866, only 5,548, of which 3,909 occurred 
in the Eastern district, and only 1,639 in all the rest of 
London. 



PATHOLOGY. 183 

The East London Company's water supply caused the in- 
creased deaths in East London, viz., from thirty-two to forty 
fold greater than either in the West, Central, North or South 
of London, and afforded another instance of the cholera-con- 
veying power of water, and again proved that water is one 
of the greatest agents in diffusing cholera. 

6.— PATHOLOGY. 

It has been said that no disease presents more uniformity 
in respect to its morbid anatomy than cholera. But, unfor- 
tunately, the secondary phenomena, viz., those of congestion, 
are so much more prominent, that the real disease, that of 
the intestinal villi, has generally been overlooked. 

The small intestines are generally well filled with a con- 
siderable quantity of pale, nearly colorless gruel, or rice, or 
cream-like matter, which Beale and others have proven to 
consist almost entirely of columnar epithelium, which has 
been stripped from the villi, so that all, or nearly all of 
them are left bare. The surface of the intestine is converted 
into a raw surface, comparable to that produced by an ex- 
tensive and severe scald or burn, and the villi are so damaged 
that they can no longer act as organs of absorption. 

Lionel Beale says it is probable that in bad cases almost 
every villus, from the pylorus to the ileo-caecal valve, has 
been stripped of its epithelial coating during life. These 
important organs, the villi, are, in very bad cases, all or 
nearly all left bare, and a very essential part of what con- 
stitutes the absorbing apparatus is completely destroyed. 

It is probable that the extent of this process of denuda- 
tion determines the severity or mildness of an attack of 



184 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

cholera. If the great majority of the villi have been stripped, 
it is scarcely reasonable to consider recovery more probable 
than it would be after a very extensive burn or scald. 

Dr. Bartholow, of Cincinnati, says it is obvious that this 
destruction of the columnar epithelium not only arrests the 
vital power of selection and absorption naturally possessed 
by the villi, but produces an outward diffusive current of 
serum from the intestinal capillaries, followed by an extra- 
ordinary amount of congestion of the veins of the bowels. 

Beale says the capillaries are distended to three or four 
times their ordinary diameter, so that the smallest vessels 
are injected very easily, and a very rapid transudation of 
fluid through the capillary walls can easily be made to take 
place after death. 

The glandular apparatus of the small and large intestines 
becomes the seat of equally striking changes. The solitary 
glands enlarge, become filled with a milky fluid. The plates 
of Peyer become prominent, and the mesenteric glands also 
enlarge somewhat. 

Not only is a great outpouring of serum from the intes- 
tinal capillaries thus induced, but the digestive process is 
arrested ; no faeces are formed, although bile is still pro- 
duced, and may be present at times in the discharges. 

The arrest of primary assimilation, and the rapid loss of 
serum, soon occasion serious changes in the blood. It be- 
comes viscid and dark. The red globules in the portal 
vein are irregular in outline, and broken up ; the serum is 
crowded with debris and granular matter. The blood glob- 
ules in the capillaries, small veins of the villi, and sub- 
mucous tissue of the bowels, appear to have been in a great 
measure destroyed, and in their place are seen clots contain- 



PATHOLOGY. 



185 



ing blood-coloring matter, minute grannies, and small masses 
of germinal matter evidently undergoing active multiplication. 

Similar appearances are found in the air-tubes, for Mr. 
Besnier has found throughout the entire extent of the 
bronchial mucous membrane a deposit of reddish viscous 
matter, forming a kind of jelly on the surface. The quantity 
is variable, but it often formed a layer sufficiently thick to 
block markedly the bronchial tubes. It was detached with 
difficulty by a very strong current of water, and was more 
abundant in the smaller bronchial tubes. The deposit was 
evidently formed of the epithelial cells of the bronchial 
mucous membrane, which, though rare in the normal state, 
become very abundant and voluminous in cholera. 

Below the epithelial deposit, the bronchial mucous mem- 
brane presented an intense uniform redness. 

When the cholera asphyxia occurred rapidly, there was 
congestion of the inferior lobes of the lungs ; but when it 
was slow and progressive, the pulmonary congestion was 
slight, but the epithelial deposit abundant and accompanied 
by an emphysematous condition of the lungs more marked 
and extensive than in the rapid cases. Besnier contends 
that the asphyxia of cholera arises from the obstacle opposed 
by this epithelial deposit to the entry of air into the air 
cells, and not solely to mere thickening of the blood, or to 
non-penetration of blood into the pulmonary capillaries. 

Bartholow, of Cincinnati, found the pleura, sac of peri- 
cardium and peritonaeum, coated with a gummy substance 
which adhered tenaciously to the hands, and so glued the 
pulmonary and costal pleura together, as to require, in some 
instances, no inconsiderable force to separate them, and which 
must have increased the difficulty of respiration. This sub- 



186 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

stance was found to consist of cast-off epithelium, and of the 
lubricating serum deprived of much of its water. 

7.— TREATMENT OF CHOLERA. 

Internal disinfection is the most important part of the treat- 
ment of cholera. This may be readily and pleasantly done by 
using a small quantity of permanganate of potash in water as 
a common drink. Carbolic acid has been used, very dilute, as 
a drink, and in starch injections, in five slight and seven 
severe cases, with only three deaths. I have seen cases re- 
cover under the use of sulphate of iron, and think that the 
directions on page 110, prescription No. 32, on page 115, and 
Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,14, 26, and 27, on pages 116, 117, and 119, are 
well worth attention and trial. Injections of a strong hot so- 
lution of sulphate of iron will doubtless be found more useful 
than those of green tea, but they will almost indelibly stain 
the clothing. 

The next indications of treatment are to prevent the de- 
struction of the columnar epithelium, arrest the outward dif- 
fusion current through the intestinal canal, and obviate the 
retention in the blood of the eifete and poisonous substances 
which should be eliminated by the kidneys. 

Beale truly says : The removal of the columnar epithelium 
from the villi, and the consequent destruction of the mechan- 
ism of absorption, are broad facts in cholera which deserve 
our first attention. We must well consider how this denu- 
dation may be prevented, lessened, or retarded ; and when it 
has taken place, what medicines or substances should be 
brought in contact with the raw and naked intestinal mucous 
membrane, to soothe or heal it. In preference to using any 



TREATMENT OF CHOLERA. 18T 

harsh measures, Beale thinks it better to let the denuded villi 
remain perfectly quiet in the hope that the damage may be 
repaired by nature. 

Guided by these suggestions, Dr. Clarke, of the London 
Hospital, treated fifty-six cases with colored sweetened water, 
with twenty-eight deaths. On board the hospital ship Belle- 
isle, near London, twenty-eight slight and nine severe cases 
were treated with nothing, with only one death. Flaxseed 
tea, white of eggs, mucilage of gum-arabic, glycerine, and 
sweet oil and lime water, have been suggested for the simple 
treatment of cholera. 

Dr. Bartholow, of Cincinnati, found all the discharges in 
cholera to have an alkaline reaction, and to consist of a serous 
fluid, almost identical with the serum of the blood, merely 
mixed with columnar epithelium and debris. The perspira- 
tion was feebly alkaline or neutral. The urine rapidly dimin- 
ished in acidity, and finally became alkaline. Hence it has 
been inferred that acids should form a principal part of the 
treatment of cholera. Prescriptions No. 22, page 114 ; No. 6, 
page 117 ; and Nos. 23 and 24, p. 119, deserve trial in cases 
which resist the internal disinfectant treatment. Sulphuric 
acid stops diarrhoea and relieves pain. It is suited to atonic 
and pale serous diarrhoea in every stage, and often acts like a 
charm. 

Its action in cholera is explained thus : The contents 
of healthy bowels are naturally acid ; but in true choleraic 
diarrhoea the alkaline serum of the blood is poured out so co- 
piously into the intestines as to render their contents no 
longer acid. Acids not only restore the natural acidity of the 
bowels, but cause the endosmatic current, which is always 

10 



188 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

towards the alkaline side, to return to its proper course, and 
thus reestablish the function of absorption. 

I prefer diluted phosphoric acid, either plain or given in 
gum-water, orgeat, or in syrup of gum arabic, and flavored or 
not with syrup of lemons or raspberries. There is, at least, 
no danger of injury to the teeth, as there always is when 
using the other mineral acids. 

When the vomiting is excessive, one-grain doses of oxalate 
of cerium have been found useful. 

The urine is very scanty in the first and second stages of 
cholera, and suppressed in all cases of collapse, so that a direct 
ratio exists between the severity of the case and the amount 
of the urinary secretion. Albumen, epithelium, and tube 
casts appear early in the urine, and increase rapidly in quan- 
tity. These appearances are manifest in the very inception of 
the diarrhosal stage, and are of great importance, both in a 
diagnostic and therapeutical point of view. Hence, at one 
stage of cholera, the treatment is resolved into that of Bright's 
disease, and bromide of potash is the best remedy. 

Dr. Bigbie, physician to the Queen in Scotland, has also 
used bromide of potash with some success, especially against 
the cramps, in thirty-grain doses, every half or one hour, 
till one and a half or two ounces were taken. He says it will 
arrest the cramps and restlessness as few other remedies can ; 
relieves capillary obstruction, brings on reaction, and speedy 
return of secretion of urine. It is a perfectly safe remedy. 

In the later stages of the disease, when the system has 
sunk into a complete torpor, more active diuretics have been 
used with success. (See page 151, and prescriptions Nos. 10, 
11, 12, and 13, page 117.) 

Dr. Bevan, of Chicago, deserves great credit for the bold 



TREATMENT OF CHOLERA. 189 

but careful use of hypodermic injections of morphine and 
atropine, which he instituted. Of the former he used from 
one-sixth to one-fourth, and even one-third grain per time. 
It often moderated the cramps immediately, and lessened the 
vomiting and diarrhoea. In terrific cramps, one-third grain 
injections of morphine and inhalations of chloroform were 
found useless, but when one-thirtieth of a grain of atropine 
was added, relief ensued in half an hour, and lasted for nearly 
twenty hours. Then injections of one-fiftieth of a grain of 
atropine, with one-quarter grain of morphine, produced com- 
fortable sleep, and ultimate recovery. 

As simple non-absorption of water is said to produce all 
the symptoms of collapse, the directions on page 122 should 
be followed. 

Artificial serum, composed of water, white of eggs, and 
table salt, has been largely used as a common drink to replace 
the immense quantity of blood-serum which is lost in the 
cholera discharges. Dr. Clark, of the London Hospital, has 
suggested a more complex and scientific artificial serum, viz. : 
Carbonate of soda, twelve grains ; phosphate of soda, one 
grain ; phosphate of lime, one grain ; phosphate of magnesia, 
one-half grain ; water, eight ounces. This mixture was sup- 
plied to his patients in large bottles, with pieces of lemon 
floating in it. They liked it, and drank it freely, as a common 
drink, and only six cases out of eighteen died. 

Richardson thinks that the food and drink may also be 
made the means of introducing heat abundantly into the 
interior of the system, in the algid stage of cholera. Dissolve 
with gentle heat, two ounces each of stearine and best fresh 
butter ; beat up well eight ounces of whites and yolks of 
eggs with twenty grains of carbonate of soda, and eighty grains 



190 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

of best fine table salt. Then mix the whole together at a tem- 
perature not above one hundred and forty degrees. 

Let the whole cool to a soft consistency ; then spread it on 
a board or slab and rub in two ounces of water with a broad 
spatula. Place the whole in a broad-mouthed jar. 

For use in cholera, put one table-spoonful of this mass in 
a large breakfast cup and rub it up equally with a tea-spoon- 
ful of glycerine, or water, or fine sugar and water, or honey 
and water ; then pour on three ounces of actually boiling water, 
and mix well. This mixture will cool at once, and the ther- 
mometer will only register one hundred and thirty degrees to 
one hundred and thirty-five degrees of heat ; proving that 
forty-four degrees have been rendered latent for every ounce 
of fluid. This will be given up to the tissues when it reaches 
them. A pint of this fluid will render up no less than two 
hundred and four degrees of heat. 

It is agreeable to taste, and sets well on stomach. Opium, 
creosote, dilute sulphuric acid, or port wine and other medi- 
cines, have been given in it. 

It is to be hoped that these complicated mixtures will 
prove more useful than the simpler ones directed on pages 122 
to 125. 

The simple treatment of collapse has been found the most 
efficacious. (See pages 124 and 125.) 

In collapse, Dr. Carroll, of Cincinnati, says, all the blood 
which sustains life is confined to the brain, chest, and abdo- 
men. After the patient has lost twelve or fifteen pounds of 
fluid, the remainder accumulates in the great centres of the 
body, and if you attempt to produce reaction too suddenly 
and diffuse this quantity, already too small, too quickly 
throughout the general system, the result will be disastrous. 



TREATMENT OF CHOLERA. 191 

The heart is already feeble and contracts on a small amount 
of blood, only sufficient to keep up its pulsation ; the brain? 
too, has barely an adequate quantity to prevent fatal exhaus- 
tion ; withdraw this little too quickly, and the patient will die 
suddenly. 

Hence use light, instead of very heavy and warm coverings. 
Give one teaspoonful of brandy in two of water or gum- 
water, five or ten minutes. For if you suddenly produce 
excessive external heat, the heart and nervous system are left 
so deserted that they will fail rapidly. Free ventilation should 
be secured ; the windows should all be open ; nothing should 
be said or done to discourage the patient : moderate friction 
only should be used ; no heating substances should be applied 
externally for six or ten hours after collapse has been ush- 
ered in ; then apply gentle heat only, by means of hot water 
in bottles, hot sand-bags for the purpose of gradually increas- 
ing the temperature of the extremities. In cool weather have 
fire in the room, but leave the windows open. Of twenty-nine 
cases of collapse, thus treated, nineteen rallied into the stage 
of reaction ; and of these nineteen, twelve recovered. 

Warm baths at ninety-eight to one hundred and four degrees 
were used in one hundred and thirty of Clarke's worst cases. 
The cramps ceased, anxiety of mind vanished, the pulse rallied, 
pain was relieved, and in some a tranquil slumber ensued. 
But the improvement was permanent in but few cases, and 
only transient in many. (See page 133.) 

Richardson thinks that in collapse the homogeneousness of 
the blood can only be restored by direct injection into the 
veins of a proper fluid. To make this, dissolve one drachm 
of table-salt and one scruple of carb. soda in five ounces of 
water ; whip up four ounces of white of eggs well and add 



192 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

them to the water ; heat the mixture in a water bath to one 
hundred and thirty degrees ; stir steadily, digest for one hour, 
and remove from the fire. This forms a perfect artificial 
serum, the albumen of which hydrates freely. 

Next melt one ounce of clarified animal fat and two ounces 
of pure glycerine in a crucible and pour it into the artificial 
serum at a temperature of one hundred and twenty degrees, 
and stir in carefully ; let it cool to eighty degrees, skim off the 
floating fat and filter the remainder through coarse paper or 
close cloth. 

The fluid thus obtained is of a pinkish color, alkaline reac- 
tion, saline sweetish taste, of specific gravity of 1.038 ; it 
picks up semi-fluid blood with instant readiness and diffuses it 
most equally. Two pints may be injected at one time at a 
temperature of one hundred and six degrees, when it will take 
up one-third more heat than water, and on cooling restore one- 
third more. A small quantity of alcohol increases the effi- 
ciency of these injections. 

A more simple fluid for injection into the veins is : distilled 
water, twenty ounces ; chloride of sodium, 5i ; carb. soda, 
twenty grains ; chlorate of potash, six grains ; phosphate of 
soda, three grains ; pure alcohol, two drachms. Of fifteen cases, 
eleven died without the addition of alcohol, and four recovered 
with it. 



7.— HOMOEOPATHY AND CHOLERA. 

It is well known that the hydragogue cathartics, like elate- 
rium, croton oil, jalap, gamboge, etc., are the truly homoeopa- 
thic remedies for cholera. (See pages 140 and 165.) Yet, sin- 
gularly enough, the homoeopathists rarely or ever use them, 



HOMOEOPATHY AND CHOLERA. 193 

but rely upon infinitesimal doses of more or less antagonistic 
and allopathic remedies, like camphor, copper, arsenic, etc. 

The homoeopathic treatment is generally commenced with 
camphor, which has been used from time immemorial against 
diarrhoea, ordinary cholera, etc. Leadam says that it was 
even used by Serapius, who translated Dioscorides into Syriac. 
But Hahnemann doubtless got the idea from much later 
sources, for he tells us in his Lesser writings (page 753) that 
fo a receipt has been given to the world which has proved so 
efficacious against Asiatic cholera, that of ten patients but 
one died. The chief ingredient is camphor, which is .in ten 
times the proportion of the other ingredients." It is scarcely 
necessary to add that camphor has little or no homoeopathic 
relation to cholera — certainly not as much as elaterium. 
Hahnemann and all his followers, also, instinctively avoid the 
use of infinitesimal or homoeopathic doses of camphor, and 
the former directs strong spirits of camphor to be given at 
least every five minutes ; also to rub some on the neck, head, 
arms, chest, abdomen, legs, etc. ; also a clyster with two tea- 
spoonfuls of spirits of camphor in one half pint of warm 
water ; and, finally, that some camphor should be burned on a 
hot iron from time to time, so that the patient may inhale its 
vapors. This is very good treatment, but it is not homoeo- 
pathic ; on the contrary, camphor is an antidote to almost all 
homoeopathic remedies and doses, which may be given subse- 
quently. We have seen, on page 141, that veratrum, the rem- 
edy for the second stage, is not as successful as many homoeo- 
pathists" suppose, and it cannot well be in infinitesimal doses 
after the previous use of large doses of camphor, which anti- 
dotes it. The Hahnemannian remedy for the third stage, or 
that of cramps, when the patient is saturated, and his room and 



194 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

clothes loaded with the vapors of camphor, is one or two glob- 
ules of the thirtieth dilution of cuprum, or copper. This is 
an allopathic astringent, but cannot act as such in infinitesimal 
doses. Even the use of copper was not original with Hahne- 
mann, for Dupuytren and others had used it previously (see 
page 145), and he tells us in his Lesser writings (page 755) that 
" trustworthy information from Hungary informs him that those 
who wore a plate of copper next the skin escaped the infec- 
tion." We have shown, on pages 160 and 161, that few or none 
of the remedies in ordinary use by the homoeopathists are ho- 
moeopathic to cholera, as they do not use elaterium, etc., and it 
is almost safe to assume that they have never treated a case of 
cholera truly homoeopathically. Hence, as they generally give 
infinitesimal doses of allopathic remedies, they must necessa- 
rily fail. They do not use their own remedies rightly, and a 
well-instructed regular physician can easily treat his cases, if 
he chooses, far more homoeopathically than the oldest and 
most experienced homoeopathist. 

As it is not only easy, but natural to mistake various milder 
forms of disease for true Asiatic cholera, it is a matter of 
course that very many homoeopathic physicians will rate their 
success very highly ; others much more moderately. Thus 
two Cincinnati physicians say they treated one thousand one 
hundred and sixteen genuine cholera patients in 1849, with 
a loss of only thirty-five, or five and a half per cent. ; Rubini, 
of Naples, five hundred and ninety-two cases (with allopathic 
doses of camphor), without a single death. 

The British Journal of Homoeopath]/ (vol. 15, p. 130) says : 
Dr. Stens makes the rather rash assertion that the homoeopathic 
mortality in cholera is only eight and a half per cent. The 
British editors add : " Now, we should rejoice very much were 



HOMCEOPATHY AND CHOLERA. 195 

this the case ; but, alas ! we know from sad experience that it 
is at least three times as high as here stated. And this is a 
fact so easily ascertained by reference to the statistics of 
homoeopathists themselves, that we (the British journalists) are 
surprised Dr. Stens has allowed such a flagrant exaggeration 
to damage the credibility of his other statements. We know 
very well the data on which the percentage of mortality 
he gives is founded, and we are well convinced of their utter 
un trust worthiness. How he could allow himself to put for- 
ward such an exaggeration, we are at loss to imagine." 

The British journalists, of course, cannot believe Dr. G-erstel, 
who reported (see vol. 13, p. 329) to an Austrian Medical 
Society that he had treated three hundred cases of cholera, of 
a most inveterate character, with a loss of only thirty-two, or 
about ten per cent An offer was made to Dr. G-erstel to 
practise under the control of the District Superintendent, Dr. 
Nushard, in order to establish proofs of the success of the 
homoeopathic treatment, which he declined. 

Dr. Rutherford Russell, one of the editors of the British 
Journal of Homoeopathy, says, in vol. 7, p. 179 : 

" We cannot help deprecating the boastful tone we so often 
hear assumed by homoeopathists on this subject — the treat- 
ment of cholera. It would argue a singular callousness of 
feeling in any one who has had much experience in the 
disease, at all events as it appeared among us, in Edinburgh, 
not to be penetrated with a profound sense of the comparative 
importance of our art in arresting, or even greatly modifying 
this terrible plague. In assuming what may be thought 
a tone of too great despondency as to the results of homoe- 
opathic treatment, we (Dr. Russell) refer to the fully devel- 
oped disease. In its first stage, if we are permitted to see it 



196 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

at this time, much may be done to prevent its further develop- 
ment, and we cannot speak too strongly of the value of 
camphor ; but in the stage of collapse, I have never seen any 
evidence of camphor being of service." 

In the British Journal of Romceopatliy ;, vol. 9, p. 693, we 
read : " We paid a visit to Dr. Tessier's hospital. He has one 
hundred beds ; the wards are airy and high, and the hospital 
is well situated and served. He informed us that he had 
never met anything but uniform kindness and respect from 
the Central Bureau of Hospitals, although at various periods 
there have been medical men among them, and such is the 
case at present ; not the slightest opposition has been offered 
to him in the change (from allopathic to homoeopathic practice) 
that he has carried out in the medical treatment of his 
patients." This we know refers to the Hospital St. Margue- 
rite, in which Tessier admits a loss of forty-eight or forty-nine 
per cent, of his cholera cases. (See Hempel's and Radde's 
Tessier on Cholera, p. 107.) The loss was only thirty-five to 
thirty-nine per cent, at our quarantine last season ; of six hun- 
dred and twenty-two cases of cholera and over fifteen hundred 
of diarrhoea, two hundred and forty-two died. Drs. Stens and 
Gerstel would doubtless have reported twenty-one hundred 
and twenty-two cases of cholera with about ten per cent, loss* 

In vol. 12, p. 698, we learn that : u Dr. Tessier has been 
transferred from St. Marguerite to the Hospital Beaujon, one 
of the best regulated hospitals in Paris. His wards, male and 
female, contain one hundred beds. We are sorry to learn 
that the cholera has, in his wards, as well as in other hospitals 
in Paris, shown so malignant a type. One great cause for the 
increased mortality in all the hospitals, is the decidedly con- 
tagious character the disease has manifested. It thus spreads 



HOMOEOPATHY AND CHOLERA. 191 

from bed to bed and attacks patients already suffering from 
serious diseases." I infer that the loss was still greater than 
in trie Hospital St. Marguerite, and believe that Tessier has 
never published any account of it. 

In old times it might have been supposed and assumed that 
the contagiousness of the cholera in Tessier's wards accounted 
for the increased mortality. But we almost all believe in the 
contagiousness of cholera now, and cases occurring in a well- 
appointed hospital, come earlier under treatment than under 
many other circumstances. The drawback that they have 
been or are sick with other diseases is somewhat counter- 
balanced by the facts that they do not have to be transported 
a great distance, are not half starved or racked with the pangs 
of exhaustion and debauchery, as many other cholera patients . 
are, and that physicians, trained nurses, medicines, food, and 
every aid and comfort, are on the spot, for instant service, by 
night or day. 

Besides, this loss from contagion occurred in 1854, when Dr. 
Budd, of Bristol, had established the great principles of disin- 
fection (see page 100 of this treatise). Tessier, who is cer- 
tainly an honest, earnest, and scientific homoeopathist, neither 
knew how to prevent the infection, nor control it after it had 
commenced. 

Dr. Fleischman, of Vienna, has had the largest hospital 
experience of the homoeopathic treatment of cholera (see Brit 
Jour, of Horn., vol 14, p. 27) ; viz., twelve hundred and two 
cases, with seven hundred and ninety-three recoveries and 
four hundred and nine deaths. I know, from personal obser- 
vation, that Fleischman's hospital is perfect in all its appoint- 
ments. It is almost exquisite in its neatness, cleanliness, 
order. The consolations of religion are extended by the Sisters 



198 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

of Charity, and only the better class of the poor are admitted. 
The worst and most depraved classes find no entrance 
there. Yet Fleischman's results were only five per cent, better 
than on board the hospital-ship Falcon in our harbor last 
year. Fleischman candidly says : " In the treatment of this 
disease, at least, as we have it in a hospital, even for us 
homoeopathists much remains to wish for. Every remedy 
which has been recommended has been tried and tried again 
by me, but I have little to say in praise of any of them." 

Dr. Charge, of Marseilles, received from the French Gov- 
ernment the order of the Legion of Honor, and from Pope 
Pius IX. that of Gregory the Great, for services rendered in 
the cholera of 1849, in general practice. In the British Jour- 
nal of Homoeopathy (vol. 15, p. 173) we read : " In 1854 he 
was applied to by the Mayor of Marseilles to take charge of 
two cholera wards in the Hotel Dieu. All patients were to 
be sent on alternate days to the homoeopathic and allopathic 
wards. It is true that Dr. Charge resigned his trust after 
three reception days ; it is also true that during those three 
days twenty-six patients were received and twenty-one died. 
Dr. Charge complained that he had too few nurses allowed ; 
that there was a great want of bed clothing, flannels, etc. ; 
that patients in other wards, when they took the cholera, as 
they often did, were transferred to the cholera wards ; and, 
as this process of transfer was entirely in the hands of the 
allopathic medical officers, an opportunity was thereby afforded 
them of retaining in their own wards patients attacked by 
cholera on the day of the allopathic admission until the fol- 
lowing day, when they might be thrust, in a dying state, into 
the homoeopathic wards ; and this, Dr. Charge asserts, was 
frequently done." 



H0MCE0PATHY AND CHOLERA. 199 

This I cannot believe, but think the explanation is, that in 
1849 Dr. Chaige was dealing with diarrhoea, cholera morbus, 
and cholerine, in private practice, and hence seemed very 
successful ; while in 1854 he for the first time came in contact 
with true cholera, as it appears in general hospitals. Dr. 
Charge certainly is not as able nor as scientific a physician as 
Tessier, and his success, we have seen, was not great, without 
any such imaginary unfair play. 

Finally, Dr. Drysdale, one of the editors of the British Jour- 
nal of Homoeopathy, gives us, in vol. 8, some data by which 
we can form a prognosis under homoeopathic treatment. He 
treated one hundred and seventy-five cases, of which forty- 
three or more were mild, with forty-five deaths. About twenty 
cases seen in the first stage could not be saved. The cure of 
real choleraic, rice-water, painless diarrhoea, he says, was by 
no means an easy matter. Of those with severe cramps, 
twenty-two out of forty-six died ; with coma, ten out of four- 
teen ; with agonizing pain from the region of the heart, 
through the back, all, nine in number, died ; with red purging, 
four, or all died ; of the severe cases, without cramps, eight 
out of fourteen ; with grinding of the teeth, four out of eight ; 
with greenish tint of complexion, four, or all, died ; when 
purging was followed by cramps before vomiting, six out of 
nine died ; all, (only two) died which commenced with faint- 
ing. If the vomiting began before the purging, four out of 
eleven died ; if the purging preceded the vomiting, only six 
out of twenty-six proved fatal ; with delirium, only four out of 
eleven died ; with vomiting in gushes, only four out of ten ; 
with hiccup, only two out of twelve ; with epigastric pain, 
six out of twenty-four ; with abdominal pain, six out of thirty- 



200 ASIATIC CHOLERA. 

six ; with moderate cramps, three out of nineteen ; and all 
those which commenced with colic recovered. 

In the consecutive fever, of nine with coma, six died ; with 
delirium, only two out of eight ; with slow pulse, four out of 
twelve ; with quick pulse, two out of four ; with suppressed 
urine, two out of five ; with restlessness, six out of sixteen ; 
with vomiting, three out of thirteen ; with purging, six out 
of thirteen ; with grinding of the teeth, three out of six ; 
with sighing respiration, six out of ten ; with sleeplessness, 
all, four in number, recovered ; with headache, four out of six. 

It is evident from all that has gone before, that many cases 
recover under all kinds of treatment, and under no treatment ; 
and that many die under all varieties of treatment, 



